6 ms·
I feel like this whole thing with the GDPR is people fighting each other for the wrong reasons. The people for it argue that gets large companies to behave bet
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
I feel like this whole thing with the GDPR is people fighting each other for the wrong reasons.
The people for it argue that gets large companies to behave better.
The people against it argue that it's unnecessarily complicated, poorly drafted and burdensome to small businesses.
But it's both at the same time.
The issue is that it doesn't have to be. It's possible to get the desired effect without using such a complicated system, and to mitigate the impact it imposes.
For example, one of the major burdens on small businesses is the cost of producing the data the company has on you -- but there is a simple way to fix that. Require the requester to pay the cost of collecting the information, similar to FOIA requests in the US. Then the requirement is no longer an unfunded mandate and can't be used by griefers as a method of harassment.
Nobody bothered to use common sense like that when drafting it, so now in order to fix it, it has to be thrown out and rewritten. But then the people who support the spirit of the law end up fighting against the people who oppose the letter of the law, even though everybody really wants the same thing.
- Tomte 8y agoYour proposed solution gives companies zero incentive to minimize data collected, and even incentivizes them to make fulfilling such a request as convoluted and expensive as possible. What people online love to call "common sense solutions" are usually not solutions a all.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Your proposed solution gives companies zero incentive to minimize data collected The expense of producing the data isn't supposed to be an incentive to minimize data collected, that is what the other sections are for. For large companies it wouldn't be regardless because they could automate the process. > and even incentivizes them to make fulfilling such a request as convoluted and expensive as possible. A company charging outrageous prices would obviously invite investigative scrutiny.
- Tomte 8y ago> A company charging outrageous prices would obviously invite investigative scrutiny. Outrageous? No, just the mere cost that really happens. Say, the data can only be accessed by the CEO personally. For privacy reasons, okay? Very reasonable, and totally in the spirit of the GDPR. It can only be accessed in a very secure server location in Norway. Also commendable. Our CEO needs to travel (first-class air travel) to Norway. He stays in a first-class hotel. Oh, and his time as value, too. So let's say three days business trip, that adds 1 percent of his salary to the bill. Of course, this is an hypothetical, not-really-serious exaggeration. But it demonstrates the effect that would certainly happen on a much smaller scale.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Say, the data can only be accessed by the CEO personally. For privacy reasons, okay? Very reasonable, and totally in the spirit of the GDPR. Then the company has the same costs in making any use of the data, at which point they might as well not even collect it. > Of course, this is an hypothetical, not-really-serious exaggeration. But it demonstrates the effect that would certainly happen on a much smaller scale. But the scale makes all the difference. If they literally require the CEO to fly to Norway an stay in a hotel then it would add millions of dollars to the cost, but it's also manifestly unreasonable. They can easily add some nominally unnecessary bureaucracy to the process that adds a few percent to the cost and get away with it, but that isn't really going to deter a lot of people. The more they try to get away with, the more likely they make it that the regulators will crawl inside them and lay eggs. It's a losing trade off just so you can spite your own customers.
- geofft 8y agoThe problem is we don't all agree about what "outrageous prices" are, and courts are unlikely to conclude that anything that matches standard industry practices is "outrageous". The cost of complying with the GDPR nightmare letter, for the average large company that's not designed around the ability to comply with it, is likely to involve multiple engineers for several months digging out the data - if not a large internal redesign to make it even possible to dig out the data. It is not outrageous that the cost of doing that work is objectively going to be hundreds of thousands of dollars. And end users aren't going to pay for that. So the question is whether we think that it's worth it to society to cause companies to figure it out anyway, or not. If we don't, we don't need a law at all; we just let companies carry on as they are now. If we do, then we should give incentives to design your company right from the start, to minimize data collected, etc.
- DangerousPie 8y agoI'm not so sure - how do you make sure the cost isn't so high that it deters people with legitimate reasons to request their data, but also high enough to actually cover the cost of obtaining it? I would expect that those are two very different amounts.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> I'm not so sure - how do you make sure the cost isn't so high that it deters people with legitimate reasons to request their data, but also high enough to actually cover the cost of obtaining it? I would expect that those are two very different amounts. If the cost of doing something legitimately exceeds the value of doing it to the person asking for it to be done, isn't not doing it then the rational outcome?
- geofft 8y agoGDPR is trying to push a change in society's norms regarding privacy. The value of that change cannot be meaningfully measured by multiplying the "value" of one person's privacy by the number of people; there are effects that happen at scale that don't happen when you change privacy/data handling for an individual person for an individual company. And it's definitely unclear that the ability of any individual to pay for their data is a meaningful measure of that value; among other things, it can't be resold without destroying it. Imagine if a city with no roads, with just human-width sidewalks between skyscrapers. The cost of moving all the skyscrapers to fit even a single road is enormous; no single driver would be willing to pay it for the incremental benefit of being able to drive. Would you say that this means that rationally the society should never build roads?
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoYou can't justify an auto repair shop with just one customer with just one car either. The way it works isn't that the first customer pays all the fixed costs and every subsequent customer pays only the incremental costs, it's that the fixed costs are amortized over the projected number of customers. What obviously doesn't work is to try to say that the auto repair shop pays all the costs and never charges anything to anyone who wants to have their car repaired, because then they go out of business.
- d4l3k 8y ago"cost of producing the data" seems really hard to strictly define. What's stopping a company from implementing extremely tedious procedures and billing $100 an hour to discourage people from requesting it? In addition, GPDR says that getting access to data on you is a right and it seems contradictory to have to pay for something that is your right to have.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> "cost of producing the data" seems really hard to strictly define. What's stopping a company from implementing extremely tedious procedures and billing $100 an hour to discourage people from requesting it? Government agencies have been known to do this when they don't want to release FIOA information. Then they get sued over it by the ACLU or similar. > In addition, GPDR says that getting access to data on you is a right and it seems contradictory to have to pay for something that is your right to have. That is how all the other rights work. Freedom of the press isn't a right to use someone else's printing press without compensating them.
- ttoinou 8y agoaccess to data on you is a right Freedom of the press isn't a right Hence the classic liberal difference between rights to something and freedom to do something
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoBy this definition all of the usual "rights" are really freedoms. Which leaves me waiting for an explanation of why accessing data a third party has on you should be elevated above the freedom of speech, travel, association and so on as something private parties should be required to do for all comers without compensation.
- phreeza 8y agoOne (admittedly theoretical) way to get companies to reveal the cost is to tax them based on the self-declared value of the data. The lower value they declare, the less taxes they pay, but the cheaper they have to give it away. One could do this for either personal requests, or even more radical, force the companies to sell the data, at the delcared price, to competitors. I think this is pretty much suggested by Eric Posner in his book Radical Markets.
- jdietrich 8y ago>For example, one of the major burdens on small businesses is the cost of producing the data the company has on you -- but there is a simple way to fix that. Require the requester to pay the cost of collecting the information, similar to FOIA requests in the US. Then the requirement is no longer an unfunded mandate and can't be used by griefers as a method of harassment. If you can't cheaply and quickly respond to a subject access request, then you're probably breaching several other parts of GDPR. How would you respond to a deletion request under Article 17, a restriction of processing request under Article 18, a portability request under Article 20 or an objection under Article 21? Compliance with all of those requirements necessitates clear documentation of how you're processing personal data. If you don't have that documentation, how can you comply with the stewardship and security requirements of Articles 24, 25 and 32? How will you comply with the record-keeping requirements of Article 30 and the impact assessment requirements of Article 35? If you have a data breach, how will you be able to properly fulfil your notification requirements under Articles 33 and 34? How can you be confident that you're abiding by the general principles laid out in Chapter 2? Processing personal data is a serious responsibility with potentially grave risks. If you have been taking that responsibility seriously (and been in compliance with the 1995 Data Protection Directive), then complying with the GDPR is relatively straightforward. If you just copy-pasted a privacy policy and gave no real thought to data protection while hoovering up tons of potentially sensitive personal data, then compliance will be a painful and expensive process. Being a small business doesn't give you the right to be negligent. Not under the GDPR and not under any of the other laws governing businesses. If you don't have the expertise to comply with data protection law, you need to delegate those tasks to someone who is suitably qualified. If the scale and complexity of your processing activities makes compliance impossible, then the EU would very much prefer that you find a different business model or stop doing business with their citizens.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Being a small business doesn't give you the right to be negligent. I can't understand this attitude that it's negligence to not want to be bankrupted by poorly crafted regulations. We're dealing with things like a website to sell wood carvings that someone makes as a hobby. They've got names and addresses because they need to know where to ship them. This is not a reasonable place to apply a complex regulatory framework. The idea that this involves "serious responsibility" or "grave risks" is akin to applying a regulatory framework designed for an oil refinery to a garage sale because a used lawnmower may contain some "hazardous" motor oil. It's not that the danger isn't theoretically possible, it's that the regulatory requirements are totally inappropriate to the context.
- ryanwaggoner 8y agoI think you're thinking of this GDPR thing as two sides fighting each other, and you're there in the middle with this reasonable compromise. But you're wrong :) You're actually on the same side as most of the anti-GDPR arguments I see. Rather than speak for everyone, I'll just state my case: I like the intent of the law, and I don't like my privacy or anyone else's being violated. I'm fine with reasonable regulation to prevent that. But the GDPR is legitimately terrible regulation. It's overly broad, vague, has the potential for huge penalties, is anti-small business, tries to establish the entire globe as being within its jurisdiction because someone from the EU might stumble across your website, and expects us to just trust that regulators from 28 countries will forever be gracious and helpful instead of capriciously punitive. If the GDPR was restricted to company with an actual presence in the EU and above a certain size, I'd be fully in favor of it. I'm not sure I'd think it's smart, but the EU should do what it thinks is right for its citizens. But instead the GDPR claims that my side project on a server in Alabama (hypothetical) is a violation of their residents' human rights worth a fine up to millions of Euros depending on the whims of 28 different regulatory agencies (yes, I know they almost certainly won't fine me millions, but this law leaves it up to them to decide). But the reason the other side disagrees is because: a) they trust the regulators, and b) they see any collection of anything remotely resembling "private data" as a fundamental violation of their human rights. Under that set of assumptions, why would you let small businesses off the hook so they can be free to violate anyone's human rights as they see fit?
- jadedhacker 8y agoA pay solution disadvantages anyone poor or unable to access funds from your plan. There's no reason a company can't just jack up the prices because they failed to create a decent system for performing mass deletions.
- Nullabillity 8y agoNo, the point is that the cost of automating this should be part of the cost of doing the collection, not a separate item. If you can't afford to deal with the so-called "nightmare letter", then you can't afford to snoop.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoThe problem is there is no exception for companies whose business model isn't snooping. Normal companies have customer lists, accounts receivable information, customer email addresses for password resets and announcements etc. A business can't stop keeping records of who owes them money. But then they're subject to regulations designed to make things difficult for the likes of Facebook and Microsoft.
- ATsch 8y agoThere is exceptions though, since this data is required. They just need to delete it, if they no longer have a reason to keep it.
- Nullabillity 8y agoYes, because it's so amazingly difficult to run a few SQL queries and send out an email.