6 ms·
One part of the 18th century that we left behind that maybe we shouldn't have was the level of representation in the house. Back then, each US rep had about 10
by monocasa 8y ago
One part of the 18th century that we left behind that maybe we shouldn't have was the level of representation in the house. Back then, each US rep had about 10,000 constituents, but today each has close to 1,000,000.
Going back to the original proportions, and having ~35,000 representatives could solve a lot of the money in politics issues.
- alistairSH 8y agoAnd as an added benefit, in Presidential elections, low populations states wield less power than they do now. With the current number of representatives, votes in CA and TX count less than those in SD and MN.
- jethro_tell 8y agoI find that to be an added benefit.
- moate 8y agoThat's what the Senate is for.
- jethro_tell 8y agoNo, the house is supposed to represent the population and the senate is supposed to represent the state. Each member of the house should represent the same number of people, the senate should not. That's not the case though. CA/TX/WA/NY reps represent more people than less populous states.
- jrs95 8y agoThe last census included non-citizen residents of those states, so this may be less true than you'd assume just based on census data. A sizable portion of the population in CA and TX are not eligible voters but they are represented in the electoral college anyways.
- kaibee 8y ago> A sizable portion of the population in CA and TX are not eligible voters but they are represented in the electoral college anyways. This is intended behavior. IIRC it was to address the question of whether slaves counted as members of the population for the purposes of determining number of congressmen.
- alistairSH 8y agoCalifornia has a total population (census 2010) of about 37,000,000 [1]. And about 87% of those are citizens [2]. CA has 55 electors, so roughly 585,000 citizens per elector. Wyoming has a total population (census 2010) of about 563,000. And about 98% of those are citizen. WY has 3 electors, so roughly 187,000 citizens per elector. Citizen in WY have roughly 3x the voting power as citizen in CA, due in large part to a system designed to appease slave-holding states 200 years ago. 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_and_territories_by_population#Electoral_apportionment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_and_territ... 2 - https://www.kff.org/other/state-indicator/distribution-by-citizenship-status/?currentTimeframe=0&sortModel=%7B%22colId%22:%22Location%22,%22sort%22:%22asc%22%7D https://www.kff.org/other/state-indicator/distribution-by-ci...
- remarkEon 8y ago>Citizen[s] in WY have roughly 3x the voting power as citizen in CA Which is the point, so as to prevent high population urban centers from dictating everything to the rest of American that doesn't share their values. >due in large part to a system designed to appease slave-holding states 200 years ago. I assume you're referring to the 3/5 Compromise here. While true that this was a consideration, the underlying reasoning is still sound. It makes no more sense for San Francisco to rule over Sac City Iowa than Sac City Iowa to rule over San Francisco. That's the beauty of the system the Founders designed. Otherwise you just drift further and further toward Direct Democracy, which is a euphemism for "chaos".
- alistairSH 8y agoSure. But, by capping the total number of representatives, the large, urban states are slowly losing power in relation to the small, rural states (at least when it comes to presidential elections).
- maxxxxx 8y agoYou would need a lot of money to pay these reps though :k
- sanxiyn 8y agoPaying representatives is totally worth it. Are you saying that we shouldn't pay even the current number of representatives, or benefit of representatives sharply decline as their numbers increase?
- maxxxxx 8y agoI am saying currently we have 600 reps making 150000 or something like that per year. Having 35000 at the same salary would just cost a little more. In addition 35000 is like a decent town. TO get anything done probably would need some elections to form a council that makes decisions.
- xienze 8y agoThe representatives will elect representatives. Problem solved!
- chuckkir 8y agoWhile I think the parent was referring to how much a company would need to spend to buy off enough reps for their legislation, it is a valid point that increasing the current $100M or so we currently spend on these guys by 2 orders of magnitude would eat a lot of the national budget. Then again, it would also lower unemployment.
- gnopgnip 8y agoYou can greatly reduce the money spent on support staff to compensate for the additional reps.
- lainga 8y agoOn the other hand, a 35,000-member House would undoubtedly be too large for more than a small handful of important members to actually debate anything. Think of the PRC National People's Congress (setting aside that it would probably be powerless at any size..!), but 10 times as large: all the work in the 3,000-strong NPC is done by a standing committee of only 150. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_People%27s_Congress https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_People%27s_Congress
- monocasa 8y agoOh no... we'd have to more closely approximate a direct democracy in the part of the federal government that is supposed to be the most answerable to the people...
- monocasa 8y agoBut really, just because the extremely autocratic CCP decides to concentrate power, doesn't mean that that's your only option.
- bshanks 8y agoIt might be something structural that is general to all such situations; maybe when there is a very large number of 'ordinary legislators' there is a high probability of them becoming, over time, de facto powerless compared to party leadership.
- gowld 8y agoThe US already had de facto individually-powerless legislators -- The Republicans especially vote as a bloc whichever way party leadership declares.
- gowld 8y agoGood. The Federal Congress has too much power anyway. Power should devolve to the several States.
- 8y ago
- snowwrestler 8y ago> Going back to the original proportions, and having ~35,000 representatives could solve a lot of the money in politics issues. How? When people complain about money in politics issues these days, they're usually complaining about 3rd party money. I don't see how having 100x more representatives would reduce 3rd party money. It's not like it's hard to target 3rd party ads to small geographic areas.
- monocasa 8y agoI'm talking more about the borederline quid pro quo "I donated $10,000 to your campaign so here's my lobbyists, and more importantly if you don't vote the way they want, that $10,000 is going to your most difficult opponent next round". At the same funding levels, that $10,000 is now $100.
- jessriedel 8y agoBut the cost of campaigns downs basically linearly with number of voters too. (TV ads are proportional to eyeballs.) There are some non-linear effects here, but I'm not sure how they operate.
- monocasa 8y ago> But the cost of campaigns downs basically linearly with number of voters too. What makes you say that? Hell at 10,000 constituents you borderline don't even need to run ads, just go door to door, personally.
- bryondowd 8y agoExactly. Seems to me it would be more plausible for a candidate without deep pockets backing them to be able to run a competitive campaign on issues the district cares about. Simply because they could just go around knocking on doors. A candidate and nine helpers each talking to 100 people a week for ten weeks could theoretically cover the entire district. Not to mention being able reach a good chunk of them by just hanging out at a local grocery store or visiting local bars and other hotspots. Throwing money at a hotspot race would have rapidly diminishing returns compared to a race with several hundred thousand people who can only be reached in numbers by broadcast ads or a truly massive campaign force. EDIT: Although I suppose the tactic could at that point be turned to buying voters more directly. Spend a ton of money on something that benefits everyone in the district and make it clear that it'll keep coming only if they vote for your candidate, and you might have the same effect.
- repolfx 8y agoThat's straightforward in the case of massive defederalisation. 50 states. 300 representatives in each state's assembly, almost all power devolved to those states. 15000 representatives. OK, it's not 35,000, but I doubt that makes much difference.
- excalibur 8y agoThis is a great start, but there's room for improvement. What if we could scale it up to roughly one representative per 10K constituents AND have each constituent represented by someone whose views closely resemble their own? This is possible if you eliminate congressional districts altogether and have people "subscribe" to a representative. It removes the problem of a single congressman "trying" to represent constituents with widely disparate views equally, and abolishes gerrymandering in the process.
- rland 8y agoPardon my GenZ analogy: Like YouTube, you would end up with superstar representatives that would capture an even larger share than the most powerful do now. And the fact that they wouldn't even have a home district would mean that they would be accountable to absolutely no-one besides those who helped them achieve their superstar status. So yes, you would have "your rep" but he would be like a small you-tuber compared to PewDiePie—4k subs vs. 100,000,000.
- excalibur 8y agoThat's a feature, not a bug. The system grants more weight to the voices of those who are thoughtful and contemplative in their selection than it does to lemmings. PewDiePie may have eleventy billion constituents, but he still only gets one vote.
- PurpleBoxDragon 8y agoIt definitely would be different because the focus would shift from the popular candidates who are clearly going to get in to the ones who are right at the cut off. Depending upon the spread, if a lot of candidates are at the 'barely enough' line, it would mean major swings in policy driven by a small population shift, as long as the general population doesn't shift as well. I'm guessing the numbers won't be known until after the voting is done, meaning a lot of effort will be spent finding out where the line is at. I kinda want to simulate it for a few elections to see what happens, but there isn't any sufficient simulation.
- 8y ago
- dangoor 8y agohttp://www.thirty-thousand.org http://www.thirty-thousand.org Even if we upped it to 5,000-6,000 reps, it would be a huge improvement.
- mullen 8y agoIt wouldn't be the House of Representatives anymore, it would be the Colosseum of Representatives or Sports Arena of Representatives.
- Torwald 8y agoLike in Star Wars. I think it can work.
- snarf21 8y agoInteresting to think about it from this perspective. Just off the top, I wonder if we could have a second level. Then each "Advocate" (just picking a word) that represents 10K people would then be the constituency for the representative. This is a model like the Rep is the CEO and the Advocates are the C suite. The Advocates never go to DC or the state capital, then only remain local. Then to make things simpler and cleaner, outlaw lobbying at the Rep level and make the Rep elected by most votes among the Advocates. Now to get a quorum on the Rep or an issue, lobbyists have to try to convince a majority of the Advocates. Hopefully this increases the cost and decreases the payoff. It could also be that the role of the representative is to just help with the negotiations and wrangling for the bills but doesn't actually get to vote. The act as a Super-Advocate based on the position of the majority of their Advocates and in the end, the must cast their vote on a bill based on a sub-vote of their advocates. Don't take the above too seriously, I'm sure there are holes. Just a thought experiment in my brain right now.
- willyt 8y agoThat’s roughly how the Cuban system works although I think representatives are chosen by groups much smaller thank 10k and there are more of them.
- mabbo 8y agoThe problem is that such a system is actually more easy to game and have a larger proportion of voters not support the overall policy. If 51% of districts are 51% yellow while 49% are 100% pink, yellow wins. With a second level, you can run that game twice, and 25% are enough to win.
- Shivetya 8y agomoney? the real issue is party control of the system. money is the only chance anyone has at breaking through the control each party exerts over elections. if we want to take money out we need to remove the ability of the political parties from spending money on who they chose and require them to fund a set number of candidates equally. Not all candidates as its obvious you can get some kooks, but as it stands now elections are more decided by the party than the voters. the parties decide who gets to run for the seat and it becomes big news when a maverick usually with their own funds upsets this quagmire. so please by all means try to minimize the money influence elections but understand that most people's views are being heavily manipulated by operatives of both parties to make sure that the only money in politics is money they have full control over.
- usrusr 8y agoEven if you go down one representative for ten citizens, chances are that four out of ten won't be represented at all, given enough polarization. Regional representatives, on any level of granularity, solve underrepresented regions, but not underrepresented opinions.
- abecedarius 8y agoInteresting that ~30,000 was also the number of Athenian citizens. The US framers aimed to avoid some of the problems of their system, but this is also evidence that that number is not unworkable.
- airstrike 8y ago> Going back to the original proportions, and having ~35,000 representatives could solve a lot of the money in politics issues. As much as I like the idea of proportional representation, I don't think getting 35,000 people to agree on anything is a viable solution. Perhaps a better approach is one that decentralizes power as much as possible, giving more voice to local constituencies versus the Federal government -- and similarly, giving power to continuously smaller communities such as county vs. state, city vs. county and so on and so forth. An improvement on top of that is having the superior legislature write framework laws that more local communities can elect to follow, should they prefer that over drafting their own legislation, for whatever reason. While this isn't applicable to every legislative issue, the theoretical argument for this approach is quite compelling¹, at least according to one UVA Law professor² __________ 1. http://www.law.virginia.edu/pdf/faculty/hein/kitch/70va_l_rev857_1984.pdf http://www.law.virginia.edu/pdf/faculty/hein/kitch/70va_l_re... 2. https://content.law.virginia.edu/faculty/profile/ewk/1180712 https://content.law.virginia.edu/faculty/profile/ewk/1180712