4 ms·
We have a federal, not national, government. National percentages of votes earned are meaningless. I'm not saying that's good or bad, but that's what it is.
by zdragnar 8y ago
We have a federal, not national, government. National percentages of votes earned are meaningless.
I'm not saying that's good or bad, but that's what it is.
- maxxxxx 8y agoAgreed. But I hope my point makes sense. If 18 percent of people vote for someone and get no representation out of it they quickly will get disillusioned about voting and the country's politics will not be representative of the people.
- stevenwoo 8y agoIs it worse that Clinton got 48 percent of the popular vote or McCain got 46 percent and lost - that is a much bigger disenfranchised proportion.
- maxxxxx 8y agoYes. Because by definition in a presidential election there can be only one winner. In the House or Senate there is no reason to not have proportional element.
- nybble41 8y agoPresidential elections can't be proportional, true, but they could be made less polarizing. The goal should be consensus, the election of a candidate acceptable to the vast majority of the population, not someone loved by 51% but loathed by the other 49%.
- maxxxxx 8y agoIn the good old days the winner became president and the loser vice president. Maybe we should back to that. I would love a Trump/Clinton presidency.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sampo 8y agoThose Clinton voters still have their representatives in the House (and probably in Senate, too), so they are represented in the political system, just not in the White House.
- mortehu 8y agoThe lack of proportional representation is a feature of single winner districts, as opposed to multi-winner districts, not national vs federal.
- maxxxxx 8y agoI am not even saying we need full proportional representation but just some element so a party that gets voted for by a certain percentage of people can get some foothold. Right now you can't maintain a third party because the threshold to have an impact is way too high.
- mortehu 8y agoThe Scandinavian countries have something like this, called leveling seats: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leveling_seat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leveling_seat
- sampo 8y agoThe Scandinavian countries have voting systems that are approximately proportional in the core. Then they use those leveling seats to fix the sub-5% differences in the vote proportions and the seats. But that's just a small correction if we are comparing voting systems that are not proportional in their design at all. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Webster/Sainte-Lagu%C3%AB_method https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Webster/Sainte-Lagu%C3%AB_meth... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/D%27Hondt_method https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/D%27Hondt_method
- alistairSH 8y agoThe argument might better applied to state-level elections for legislative bodies. They are usually FPTP by district, so in a 51/49 split district, a significant portion of the electorate is left out in the cold. We could adopt some flavor of split system... FPTP for district reps, with some number of positions set aside state-wide for proportional representation. I believe Germany does something like this, though I'll have to dig up the details.
- maxxxxx 8y agoYes. That's what Germany does. If your party gets 5 percent you are in parliament even without winning a single district.
- Xylakant 8y agoThe german Bundestag (federal level) election rules can be roughly summarized like this: Each voter gets two votes, one for a candidate and a second for a party list. Half of the members of the Bundestag are elected by direct vote. The candidate in the election district that gets the most votes is elected. The other half are distributed so that the total distribution matches the distribution for the party list. A party that fails to accumulate at least 5% doesn't get any seats from the second vote, but gets to keep any direct seats they gained, unless they win a minimum number of direct candidates. If a party wins more direct candidates in a state than their share of votes per party list would allow for, the Bundestag grows and more seats are distributed to balance the proportion. The system is designed to allow for direct candidates, but still keeps smaller parties relevant since any party that gets beyond 5% or manages to win direct candidates is part of the Bundestag. (grossly simplified, but probably good enough for here)
- alistairSH 8y agoThanks for the summary!