3 ms·
> Warp travel? Subspace? Q? Accelerated human evolution into lizard people? There's a lot of bad Trek out there. But also a lot of good Trek. The best of it is
by AlexandrB 8y ago
> Warp travel? Subspace? Q? Accelerated human evolution into lizard people?
There's a lot of bad Trek out there. But also a lot of good Trek. The best of it is like a slice of speculative fiction - like a mini District 9, Interstellar, Her, or Arrival. The worst of it is pure melodrama with technobabble layered on top.
I think what the parent is getting at is that Star Wars never, ever goes the speculative fiction route. It's all "character drama in space".
- hobochili 8y agoFair to say that Star Wars is more psychological than philosophical?
- stephengillie 8y agoTo me, it's more political than mechanical. Star Wars has more political and interpersonal conflicts lead to shifts of power. Palpatine gained control of the Galactic Senate through political maneuvering - letting the Trade Federation apply political pressure through shipping fees, and then manipulating weak-minded senators while their stronger-minded companions are fleeing the Trade Federation. Rarely are technical details relevant to the plot - starship fuel or reactor operation details are vague at best, an executive summary. They don't goto Watto for engine parts, but a whole new engine, and Jedi aren't trained on starship repairs as they have astromech droids. Star Trek has more situations where mechanical failure or damage leads to interpersonal conflicts and shifts of power. During the Klingon Civil War, you get a pretty good idea of how Geordi keeps the Romulans away. Ship fuel was a main plotline through the entire Voyager series. Everyone on every Starfleet ship has taken a college class on how the warp core reactor works, and they flaunt that knowledge regularly.
- baud147258 8y ago> To me, it's more political than mechanical. That's mostly the 1-3 trilogy. The original trilogy is mostly fantasy in space/space opera