4 ms·
I don’t think economists claim markets are efficient. There’s far too many examples to the contrary - see amazon, wellsfargo, and Verizon as examples. While tho
by ianai 8y ago
I don’t think economists claim markets are efficient. There’s far too many examples to the contrary - see amazon, wellsfargo, and Verizon as examples. While those companies do technically have competition, they operate with significant market power.
Also, I once heard an Econ explain EH as “true if enough people operate under the assumption that it is not true”
Edit-After waking up a little more, I’m not entirely sure of my statement that amazon, wellsfargo, and Verizon serve as examples against EH. But the later quote I heard from someone with 30+ years of research.
- sshine 8y agoThe "true if enough people operate under the assumption that it is not true" is funny and somewhat intuitive: If you know markets are efficient, there is no reason to haggle about the price. But haggling is the mechanism that enhances price efficiency.
- speedplane 8y agoIn a truly efficient market, you wouldn't need to haggle about the price. You would have a slew of options that you could choose from, and would choose the option that best fits your demand. In an efficient market, if you were ever being overcharged by a company, another company would pop up overnight, and you would immediately switch from one to the other. No haggling required, just knowledge of what's available and easy movement from one option to another.
- yellowstuff 8y agoThe efficient market theory is that all information, public and private, is incorporated into all stock prices at all times, so there's no point to researching companies to try to outperform the stock market. I don't think anyone believes it is literally true, just that it is a good model for most stocks most of the time. If everyone believed it then no one would bother to research stocks, and the markets would be less efficient.
- cimmanom 8y agoThat's a far more limited claim. There's a very common claim that "markets are efficient". Extending to all markets all the time. Explaining why market based solutions are the best way to provide health care and education and other (arguably common) goods. But many markets (the labor market, the health care market, etc) work in such a way that it's ridiculous to assume that most participants know all public and private information all or most of the time.
- zmk_ 8y agoEMH that this paper refers to is about financial markets. In other areas of econ, no one is claiming that markets are efficient, in fact most of econ talks about "first best", "second best", "losses in efficiency", etc.
- stult 8y agoThe EMH is specific to asset markets. So stocks and bonds basically. No (respectable, well-known) economist has ever argued that all markets are always efficient. Also what people mean when they say markets are efficient in other contexts means something very different. The EMH specifically describes how quickly and what kinds of information get incorporated into asset prices. It doesn't make claims about how markets organize production or optimize utility without centralized direction, which is usually what people mean when they say free markets are efficient. I think a lot of confusion has arisen from the very general-sounding name of the hypothesis which does not reflect its relatively narrow claims. Not that I buy the EMH (no pun intended), but that's a different story.
- zmk_ 8y agoPrivate information here refers to whatever insights you bring with your research. The point is that if you gain some private information (by being a quant, analyst, etc.) you would immediately trade on it and the price would then start reflecting your views. Also EMH, and that's the point Fama uses a lot to battle critics, does not put a time frame on when the price adjustment happens.
- speedplane 8y ago
- neffy 8y agoThe strong form of the efficient market theory is fairly well discredited by now, and there are much easier way to disprove it in any case than this.
- evrydayhustling 8y agoThis. Economists and decision theorists like Herb Simon have been actively modeling "bounded rationality" since the 70s, but well before that, literal interpretations of efficient market theory were limited to those with something to sell (mainly to regulators). There are limits to human (and corpory) rationality that kick in way before P?=NP.