3 ms·
But still better overall than coal, perhaps?
by mirimir 8y ago
But still better overall than coal, perhaps?
- manicdee 8y agoIf you are switching away from coal, the economically sensible decision is renewables. The ecologically sensible decision is also renewables. Switching to gas is just trading one version of disaster for another. Instead of your world being razed by Godzilla you spend lots of money so it gets razed by Hedorah instead.
- adrianN 8y agoBut coal and renewables are very different, unless you also buy lots of storage.
- manicdee 8y agoThe issue has been done to death in academic circles. All we need to do is stop subsidising coal and nuclear, focus on investing in (companies rolling out) renewables, and let the propeller heads get the job done. Here's one recent take on the issue: https://reneweconomy.com.au/a-100-renewable-grid-isnt-just-feasible-its-already-happening-73505/ https://reneweconomy.com.au/a-100-renewable-grid-isnt-just-f... Note that last bit: as we shift to a transport fleet consisting of more and more EVs, the possibility of using storage to balance out demand vs supply becomes more likely, without huge investment in utility scale static batteries.
- Baeocystin 8y agoNo perhaps about it. Natural gas is far better a fossil fuel to burn than coal per BTU. Still not ideal, of course. But it absolutely has its place as a transition fuel as we work to decarbonize our energy production.
- manicdee 8y agoFor the same money we can build solar and wind plant faster than gas, with the benefit of not using fossil fuels and increasing the rate of greenhouse gas emissions. Methane is not a transition fuel, it is simply a smoke and mirrors truck replacing some of the CO2 emissions of coal with methane emissions from well to furnace. Methane is far worse than carbon dioxide, we should not be following plans to increase methane emissions for a token reduction of CO2 emissions.