3 ms·
To be fair, RS-422 is way better for this use case. The signals are differential pairs. And at the time, serial didn't automatically imply RS-232. RS-422 was
by monocasa 8y ago
To be fair, RS-422 is way better for this use case. The signals are differential pairs.
And at the time, serial didn't automatically imply RS-232. RS-422 was a totally valid choice, and typically the technically better option.
- ac29 8y agoIts my understanding that the reason for RS-422 (or 485) versus 232 is when you want long cable runs (say, over 10m). Not sure why this would matter much for computer peripherals. It would make more sense if AppleTalk used it, but it used a common ground, which eliminates the benefits of the balanced signals.
- pstuart 8y agoIt was a unified high speed interface that could do both. Farallon came up with cheap network adapters that allowed Macs to talk to each other (and a LaserWriter!) over local phone wiring. That was huge -- plug and play networking for mortals. Source: worked at Farallon way back when.
- watersb 8y agoI was around the corner, the Mac network admin at Chiron. Hundreds of Macs, running on single-pair UTP. Good times. :-)
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoSerial did imply RS-232 because it was an established industry standard, and by the 80s more than twenty years of hardware supported it. It's still in use today on technical equipment, although most of the world has moved on to its descendant - USB. It's true that RS-422 was technically better, but it was only ever used in the Apple ecosystem. Existing RS-232 hardware needed an adaptor or a complete redesign. This severely limited the appeal of the Mac in industrial automation, scientific control, and electronic development, and often made basic printing more complicated than it needed to be. Realistically, most of those were never going to be prime Mac markets. Even so, sales and market niches were lost to the PC and to competitors like HP.
- vidarh 8y agoIn the 80's a huge variety of systems used entirely different options altogether. RS-422 looks weird today because the other weird options have died out or become even more niche. E.g. Commodore used IEEE-488 variations on it's 8-bit lines. Many others were used by others. Peripherals were commonly expected to be specific to a specific computer manufacturers products still. In retrospect it's clear it wasn't ideal, but at the time RS-232 was just one more alternative that didn't really stand out as a winner yet.