4 ms·
Companies need to be able to die, and extracting as much value from the dying company is worthwhile. The alternative is to let a company waste away, slowly blee
by cortesoft 8y ago
Companies need to be able to die, and extracting as much value from the dying company is worthwhile. The alternative is to let a company waste away, slowly bleeding out the last of their resources until their is nothing left. That is not good for the economy, and only prolongs the inevitable. This might feel morbid, but it shouldn't; companies aren't people.
Obviously the people at the company need to be taken care of, but that is a larger societal issue about how we deal with people who lose their jobs in general, not about companies that go out of business.
If the people making the largest bid for a company want to close it down, then that is probably the best thing to do; if it was really worth it to turn the business around, then someone else would offer more money to keep it going (or at least the same amount).
- derefr 8y ago> If the people making the largest bid for a company want to close it down, then that is probably the best thing to do; if it was really worth it to turn the business around, then someone else would offer more money to keep it going (or at least the same amount). Do you really think this? What if hedge funds just happen to get larger than anyone else in the spaces they operate in, precisely by executing this technique, such that there's no "someone else" who would offer more money? An analogy: you're essentially saying that it's "the best thing to do" to date a vampire and let them suck out all your blood, because if there were a better partner for you to date than a vampire, surely such a partner would be more attractive than the vampire is, and would try harder to date you than the vampire is. Now that doesn't sound right, does it? These vampire[-corporations] are supernaturally attractive [to shareholders] and are driven by their bloodlust to seduce people [i.e. board-members] far more effectively than regular human[-corporations] can manage.
- mlindner 8y ago> What if hedge funds just happen to get larger than anyone else in the spaces they operate in, precisely by executing this technique, such that there's no "someone else" who would offer more money? Companies buy companies all the time. Hedge funds, in the grand scheme of things, are not that incredibly large compared to other companies. Also, companies making acquisitions have effectively unlimited funds to do so by taking out loans in order to buy companies. They can also buy companies without even exchanging money by converting stock in a larger ratio, effectively inflating the company's value in order to buy it. So what you're saying doesn't make sense. > An analogy: you're essentially saying that it's "the best thing to do" to date a vampire and let them suck out all your blood, because if there were a better partner for you to date than a vampire, surely such a partner would be more attractive than the vampire is, and would try harder to date you than the vampire is. Companies aren't people. If the board of investors wants to sell to a vampire it means that they're actually gaining the most value by selling to that vampire themselves. People need to stop looking at companies as monolithic wholes and actually as the sum intentions of the owners of the companies, the investors.
- derefr 8y ago> People need to stop looking at companies as monolithic wholes and actually as the sum intentions of the owners of the companies, the investors. This was my point. A vampire, mythologically, can compel a human to obey it: despite the human realizing that it'd really be a dumb idea to let something suck out all of your blood, it's still just really hard to resist letting the vampire do that. There is, I suppose, what might in modern language be called a "superstimulus"—something which causes some part of your brain to override the rest, despite the rest of the brain screaming "no." Likewise, these hedge funds offer the ultimate opportunity to make a change that is good for investors at the expense of employees. The investors are the part of the brain that is compelled; the employees are the rest of the brain, screaming "no." I've never heard of a co-op agreeing to be acquired by a hedge fund; have you?
- mlindner 8y ago> This was my point. A vampire, mythologically, can compel a human to obey it: despite the human realizing that it'd really be a dumb idea to let something suck out all of your blood, it's still just really hard to resist letting the vampire do that. There is, I suppose, what might in modern language be called a "superstimulus"—something which causes some part of your brain to override the rest, despite the rest of the brain screaming "no." You're viewing this as somehow negative. The investors gain by selling, they don't lose. There is no "sucking of blood" that occurs. > Likewise, these hedge funds offer the ultimate opportunity to make a change that is good for investors at the expense of employees. Employees are often part shareholders at these companies. They gain as well. > I've never heard of a co-op agreeing to be acquired by a hedge fund; have you? Try a google search, http://www.bbc.com/news/business-41344946 http://www.bbc.com/news/business-41344946
- robotbikes 8y agoJust found out about the co-op group in the UK from reading this article. It seems like they are a member based co-op vs. an employee owned one and it looks like they were shedding their banking division to isolate the loss from the whole financial collapse. It does seem like employee owned companies would do more to preserve their jobs vs. scrap the business for short term profit. So while one could argue that some sort of reform of this would help buffer the pain being inflicted on employees moving towards more egalitarian models of ownership would seem to be a better goal in the long run.
- paulddraper 8y agoI mean, the vampire is paying you...so it's really more like selling plasma or organs or something.
- TheCoelacanth 8y agoThe analogy falls apart completely unless you attribute some inherent value to a corporation's existence like you would to human life. What value does a corporation have beyond the economic value that it produces?
- derefr 8y agoA good corporation is a bunch of gelled teams who are at home with one-another and enjoy working together. Destroying the corporation usually results in the dissolution of the component teams, one way or another. That's the real loss—not just in terms of human happiness, but also in terms of per-capita economic productivity. It's like rewriting software: by starting from scratch, even with the same libraries, you're throwing away all the hard-fought knowledge of the optimal arrangements of, and interactions between, those components. And, since people find their own optimal arrangements/interactions over time, rather than being placed into such arrangements by some sort of "org-chart architect", there's no one with a top-down view who can salvage the most useful arrangements/interactions at the destination. A hedge fund might take a particular gelled team and sell them off "as a unit" to some company; but what that company will be getting is a box of lego with no instruction manual for how it goes together.
- lurquer 8y ago> A good corporation is a bunch of gelled teams who are at home with one-another and enjoy working together. Destroying the corporation usually results in the dissolution of the component teams, one way or another. A gelled team that works well together making obsolete copiers or film cameras is a waste of resources.
- skookumchuck 8y agoThat's correct. When a company's assets are worth more than the company as a business, it is appropriate to reallocate those assets to something more productive.
- sytelus 8y agoNo, it's not. Virtually every startup has assets (i.e. employees) worth more than company business (i.e. zero revenue). It is super important to distinguish between dieng company vs sick company vs growing company. If there was someone who killed every human for their teeth and bones when they fail to be productive because of sickness , you won't consider that as wise business choice.
- skookumchuck 8y agoThe investors certainly believe the company is worth more than the money they are investing, or they wouldn't invest. (Revenue isn't how a business is valued anyway, even in a mature business.) A startup's value is based on future anticipated ROI. My point stands.
- calpaterson 8y agoYes, the GP is right and I think you are talking at cross purposes. In finance, employees are not considered assets and companies with no revenue are not necessarily considered to have no value.
- avs733 8y agoto use an analogy... What is the difference between a natural death, physician assisted suicide, a government sanctioned execution, manslaughter, and murder?
- dbuder 8y agoCompanies should die off from competitive pressures. It is hard to build a company and many thousands of people rely on a company like Xerox for their welfare. I think there is a problem with the wanton destruction of companies so that a small group can take dicerolls on whether or not capital can pay down debt over the short to medium term. I'm all for activist investors, but Icahn has always been more of a vulture. His self dealing in the TWA fiasco was particularly egregious.