3 ms·
Are you seriously comparing the operating margins of profitable companies to a company that has yet to make a profit based on its operating activities? (Sellin
by gamblor956 8y ago
Are you seriously comparing the operating margins of profitable companies to a company that has yet to make a profit based on its operating activities? (Selling credits doesn't count, that's a one-time stunt.)
The numbers for Ford, GM, and Fiat Chrysler include all of their global activities, including their sales of lower-margin cars, compliance cars (i.e., no-margin or negative-margin vehicles, massive R&D, international operations, etc.). You are literally trying to compare the gross margin on a single Tesla model to the overall operating margins of entire companies...that's not even apples to oranges. That's comparing apples to zucchinis.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoI'm making observations with all publicly available information I can get my hands on. I'm not saying Tesla's margins are 30%. I am saying that if they're able to attain their production goals, it's likely they will hit their target margin, which are above legacy automakers.
- rohit2412 8y agoYou do understand that Tesla's gross margin that you are arguing around don't include R&D, and I'm not sure if covers SG&A too. While the numbers you cited include every expense.
- toomuchtodo 8y ago“So how does Tesla actually do on a per-vehicle basis? To that, we turn to the quarterly reports. Before Model 3 production became significant — aka, just S and X sales — Tesla was earning a 25% non-GAAP margin / 27,9% GAAP margin in their automotive division. These are very healthy margins. As Model 3 production ramped up — and famously encountered difficulty — Tesla’s gross margins fell, bottoming out at 13,8% non-GAAP and 18,3% GAAP, before rising back to 18,8% non-GAAP and 19,7% margin.” https://m.dailykos.com/stories/2018/5/29/1767826/-The-War-on-Tesla-Musk-and-the-Fight-for-the-Future https://m.dailykos.com/stories/2018/5/29/1767826/-The-War-on...
- greglindahl 8y agoAnd you can't compare these numbers to other car makers, because they include all the lifecycle costs for each car model, including the design, production line spin-up, etc. If you're an auto startup, computing numbers the Tesla way makes sense: Tesla is growing rapidly and will outgrow its current high fixed costs. If you're an established automaker that's not growing, adding in everything makes sense.