8 ms·
Having fewer kids, or no kids at all, is actually the single biggest way to reduce impact on Earth. Also, as can be seen on the graph of the article, the major
by pier25 8y ago
Having fewer kids, or no kids at all, is actually the single biggest way to reduce impact on Earth.
Also, as can be seen on the graph of the article, the major problem is actually beef, and not meat in general.
Something the article doesn't mention, and maybe the paper doesn't take into account, is distribution. Fruits and vegetables can have a bigger footprint than certain meats because these can be transported off season from very long distances.
http://the-ecotarian.com/stories/2016/2/26/environmental-impacts-of-food-2-transport http://the-ecotarian.com/stories/2016/2/26/environmental-imp...
- mnem 8y agoThe paper did include transportation in the evaluation: "Studies included provided ~1050 estimates of postfarm processes. To fill gaps in processing, packaging, or retail, we used additional meta-analyses of 153 studies providing 550 observations. Transport and losses were included from global data sets"
- pier25 8y agoThanks for pointing that out.
- mkempe 8y agoEven more radically than having "no kids at all", one could also commit suicide in order to immediately and more completely "reduce impact" -- as the end-goal seems to be. Can you explain how that is not the logical conclusion? Along those lines, some radical environmentalists have been advocating mass slaughter of the human species.
- 86767858587 8y agoBy analogy, say your goal is to eliminate income equality. In order to maximize your chances of your actions favoring that outcome, is the logical conclusion that you should find a job paying in median wage, that you spend your income in median consumption, and that you invest the remaining in median savings? As much as we're raised to believe that being an example of the ideal you want to see will somehow manifest the necessary changes to get everyone else there, it doesn't really work that way. Since the whole point of society is a system of reinforcing incentives to stabilize the power structures of the status quo and not engender revolution, by choosing non-participation in the destabilization of the existing order by being the most mediocre rather than playing the part at the extremes of the spectrum as parasite or exploiter, you end up perpetuating the inequality you sought to fix by more thoroughly lubricating the cogs of checks and balances. An environmentalist's duty is to harm the Earth to their fullest lifelong potential to more thoroughly and completely kill off the humans of future generations before the Earth actually suffers beyond its capacity to repair. Now that you got this far in reading: Poe's Law :)
- pm90 8y agoKilling oneself is not nearly the same as deciding to not have children. The latter is a choice which will not harm you or your health.
- mkempe 8y agoThe stated purpose is "reduce impact", not "avoid harm to myself".
- pm90 8y agoThere are many implicit assumptions to any statement. Don’t like this wasn’t one of them.
- tagh 8y agoYour logic is correct when we exclude all context and reasonable assumptions. We could also end poverty by killing the poor.
- mkempe 8y agoYour analogy would be valid if someone had previously claimed that the single most effective way to end poverty is to prevent the poor from having children. Then one could explore the logical conclusions of their advice.
- yesenadam 8y ago"Actually". Ever wonder why you feel the need to insert that into your sentences? Moving on... 1. How about killing yourself? One might, if one was truly serious about reducing impact, or perhaps just to prove there is a "bigger way". 2. I don't know the name of that fallacy. You could pedantically object to any headline/finding in similar terms. "Smoking causes cancer" .. "As can be seen in graph X, the major problem is actually cigarettes, and not smoking in general."
- tagh 8y agoI understand what you're getting at with the fallacy (lets call it 'winning by not fighting'), but I don't think it applies here. There is too much difference between ending your life and choosing not to create another. Also related is the difference between not having children (logical end: no more humans) and having one child fewer than you would under better circumstances (logical end: decrease in population until circumstances improve). That said, I'm biased because I don't want any kids right now. If I had one, suicide would probably follow anyway.