3 ms·
I guess my brain is too small to grok this all in one go but are you saying that Russia is applying pressure to Apple (what pressure?) that prevents Apple App
by lifeisstillgood 8y ago
I guess my brain is too small to grok this all in one go but are you saying that
Russia is applying pressure to Apple (what pressure?) that prevents Apple App Stores in all countries from accepting a new update of Telegram
I don't get this - why is Telegram not releasing updates in a UK or Japanese region? What pressure (besides the local russian court system) is being applied here
---
In general yes I expect that app stores are the / a weak point in mobile encryption messaging, but it is only at the level of major player threat model. These things are good enough for use against all but a State level actor targeting you specifically (at which point leaving the country is probably good, if tardy, advice)
- JumpCrisscross 8y agoWe don't have any evidence, apart from Durov's allegations, that Telegram's situation with Apple has anything to do with Russia.
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoSo this is Telegram saying "oh we forgot to update for GDPR because err ... umm ... err ... Russia!"? I mean we presumably do have Russian court Records from April, records that the Roskomnadzor went to court for encryption keys, and that there have been "shutting down entire segments of the Russian internet. Many small organizations, including language schools and museums, have been blocked as collateral damage." And evidence there was a demonstration with paper aeroplanes? I am happy to accept that Durov has an axe to grind but Russia does look like a good suspect to start looking at first.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> So this is Telegram saying "oh we forgot to update for GDPR because err ... umm ... err ... Russia!"? There are reasonable explanations between "Telegram is directly responsible for the delay" and "Russia made Apple hold up the app worldwide." > Russia does look like a good suspect to start looking at first Start. The discussion I'm seeing treats this as a foregone conclusion. That's all I'm cautioning in respect of.
- shkkmo 8y agoThere is certainly evidence that Russia has a problem with Telegram. There is also evidence that Russia is trying to get Telegram removed from the app store. What we don't have any evidence for is that these are in any way related to Telegram's inability to get updates approved by Apple. This is speculation based on the above claims which do have evidence.
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoFair enough - this is essentially my own question above - what pressure can be applied by Russia to Apple to prevent App Store UK getting updates? If you have a legal dispute in country A does the prevent all counties getting updates?
- zzzcpan 8y agoMaybe they found an excuse to disable updates, but they don't want to be seen helping Russia. This only works if updates are disabled for the app entirely.
- Muromec 8y ago> Fair enough - this is essentially my own question above - what pressure can be applied by Russia to Apple to prevent App Store UK getting updates? They can fine the company, ban import of Apple products into the country, block access to App Store, etc. Yes, that same agency. It doesn't even matter which regional section of App Store Telegram would use to publish app - users in need can switch between them and censorship agency can't see which part of App Store you are connecting to. So Russian censorship agency's end goal should be to remove Telegram from all regional sections of App Store and use whatever legal or not-so-legal excuses to do so. Agency in question (Роскомнадзор) is notorious for their bullshit excuses to ban imports of food from Ukraine during all the trade wars even before all European food was legally banned for import.
- vbezhenar 8y agoCan you really switch between stores? I think you would need UK credit card for that.
- codedokode 8y agoRussian officials said that Apple must remove Telegram from App Store otherwise its work can be "disrupted" in Russia.
- DyslexicAtheist 8y agoanytime someone says "only nation player threat model" I say in my mind "and also internal threats". I believe this gives a more complete picture of the actual risk.
- eganist 8y agoUsually true, but not consistently. There are applications which by design have accounted for internal threats but not state actors strictly because of the motivations of the threat actors themselves. To drastically simplify it: - Internal threats are usually motivated by finance/challenge/spite. - State actors are usually motivated to counter perceived national security threats regardless of whether they're short-term or long-term. The result is a preparedness to spend resources orthogonally as compared to the potential impact of the threat to anyone other than the state but which may be directly correlated to the perceived risk to the state itself. In simpler terms: risks exploitable by internal threats versus state actors do not assuredly overlap, and a lot of it is because risks exploitable by possessing knowledge might not be the same as risks exploitable with gobs of money.
- mhneu 8y agoGobs of money and also legal control of the companies' markets. Controlling Apple's various markets gives nations a lot of power that is tough to get even with lots and lots of money (yes, see Piketty, but it's rather inefficient to buy politicians even if some billionaires are working on doing so.)
- zzzcpan 8y agoRussia is even making public threats to block Apple services for everyone in Russia because of Telegram. Do you not consider this a form of pressure? I presume earlier Apple just gave in a bit to the pressure and stopped updates to help them censor the app.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- codedokode 8y agoMaybe Apple just doesn't have a system to block updates in one specific country?
- v_lisivka 8y agoYeah. One finger at a time, until all 21 fingers will be inside.