10 ms·
But do landowners have majority voting power in SF? If not, then maybe some people aren't voting to their interests.
by threatofrain 8y ago
But do landowners have majority voting power in SF? If not, then maybe some people aren't voting to their interests.
- matte_black 8y agoThey do.
- plankers 8y agoI'd say that's a pretty safe bet. The mad levels on income inequality are doing their part to obscure exactly what people's interests are in both the short- and long-term.
- asdsa5325 8y agoThey do among people who actually vote, but not among all people able to vote.
- rsync 8y ago"But do landowners have majority voting power in SF? If not, then maybe some people aren't voting to their interests." It is implied (and sometimes expressed) that "NIMBY" outcomes in elections like this are illegitimate and not "true" democratic outcomes. I reject this notion. I am very much in favor of urban in-fill in San Francisco and increased density in many parts of the city - but not at the expense of democratic processes.
- matte_black 8y agoAgreed, if you are going to have democratic processes you must be willing to accept their outcomes, even when the results are not in your favor or grossly against your interests.
- conanbatt 8y agoI can't verify with real numbers but my mental model is that votes on housing are not representative of the population. SF has a very high foreigner population that cant vote. They are moslty renters. US renters also might not live enough time in the city to register, be politically active, or end up moving due to lifestyle or economic reasons. And of renters you will have those that have rent control, which end up in tandem with owners about de-regularization. Im sure that if you put up a vote landowners and rent-controlled renters have a concentrated interest, and renters and foreigners dont have representation even if they are the majority. If you took all renters of SF in the last 6 years you might get a higher number than landowners but they cannot fight it politically. So I adhere to the notion of unrepresentative democratic outcomes.
- rhizome 8y agoUS renters also might not live enough time in the city to register As of 2017, California has same-day voter registration. They can register on voting day.
- conanbatt 8y agoThey need to be inthe city on voting day, and whatever the vote is they dont have the same level of intensity of interest than the homeowners. Lets look at the big picture: if everyone that lived in san francisco in the last 10 years voted to build more or to stop building, what would be the resulting of such a vote? I think the answer is obvious. And the fact that it isnt, is just lack of representation.
- rhizome 8y agoWell, now you're moving the goalposts, but doesn't everybody have to vote where the voting devices are? Beyond that, your hypothetical is pretty loaded.
- conanbatt 8y agoOf the group of people available to vote in the city, homeonwners will have a higher participation than renters that can vote. Becuse the latter need to match their residency with the vote, and even then, they dont know as much of the issue as the local, and even then, they dont have the same interest. (the time horizon of a renter could be 2 years, of a landlord its decades). Thats why I devised that mental exercise: if you gathered up all the poeple that lived over 1 year in san francisco in the last 10 years, which one do you think is in the majority? pro-supply, con-supply?
- rhizome 8y agoOf the group of people available to vote in the city, homeonwners will have a higher participation than renters that can vote I've never heard this before. Cite?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Kalium 8y agoThey do, but there's a wrinkle. Specifically, it's not fully correct to equate NIMBYs and landowners in SF. SF has plenty of renters who are also NIMBYs, having been convinced that the only way to preserve their lifestyle is to oppose everything.
- nerfhammer 8y agoYou're forgetting that something like 75% of SF has rent control and are thereby excluded from the main reason to care. EDIT: 75% of rental units & 45% of total
- kelnos 8y agoIt's 45%, as stated by the article. Let's not let hyperbole go too far.
- refurb 8y ago45% of all housing stock, but 75% of all rental units.
- hcknwscommenter 8y agoBut they should care. Rent control is like gold hand cuffs. Eventually you face a very high chance of being trapped in a dammed if you stay (wrong location, not enough room, etc.) and dammed if you move (huge increase in rent) situation. Building more housing, in sufficient numbers, should alleviate this problem.
- Redoubts 8y agoLocal elections have pathetic turnout, usually 10 to 20%
- DrScump 8y agoThat effectively means that one's vote counts fivefold to tenfold as much... which makes not voting, while complaining about the results, exceptionally perplexing.