8 ms·
No. Fixing the housing problem will take overriding the NIMBYs that are limiting housing density, which the mayor doesn't have the power to do.
by crooked-v 8y ago
No. Fixing the housing problem will take overriding the NIMBYs that are limiting housing density, which the mayor doesn't have the power to do.
- threatofrain 8y agoBut do landowners have majority voting power in SF? If not, then maybe some people aren't voting to their interests.
- matte_black 8y agoThey do.
- plankers 8y agoI'd say that's a pretty safe bet. The mad levels on income inequality are doing their part to obscure exactly what people's interests are in both the short- and long-term.
- asdsa5325 8y agoThey do among people who actually vote, but not among all people able to vote.
- rsync 8y ago"But do landowners have majority voting power in SF? If not, then maybe some people aren't voting to their interests." It is implied (and sometimes expressed) that "NIMBY" outcomes in elections like this are illegitimate and not "true" democratic outcomes. I reject this notion. I am very much in favor of urban in-fill in San Francisco and increased density in many parts of the city - but not at the expense of democratic processes.
- matte_black 8y agoAgreed, if you are going to have democratic processes you must be willing to accept their outcomes, even when the results are not in your favor or grossly against your interests.
- conanbatt 8y agoI can't verify with real numbers but my mental model is that votes on housing are not representative of the population. SF has a very high foreigner population that cant vote. They are moslty renters. US renters also might not live enough time in the city to register, be politically active, or end up moving due to lifestyle or economic reasons. And of renters you will have those that have rent control, which end up in tandem with owners about de-regularization. Im sure that if you put up a vote landowners and rent-controlled renters have a concentrated interest, and renters and foreigners dont have representation even if they are the majority. If you took all renters of SF in the last 6 years you might get a higher number than landowners but they cannot fight it politically. So I adhere to the notion of unrepresentative democratic outcomes.
- rhizome 8y agoUS renters also might not live enough time in the city to register As of 2017, California has same-day voter registration. They can register on voting day.
- conanbatt 8y agoThey need to be inthe city on voting day, and whatever the vote is they dont have the same level of intensity of interest than the homeowners. Lets look at the big picture: if everyone that lived in san francisco in the last 10 years voted to build more or to stop building, what would be the resulting of such a vote? I think the answer is obvious. And the fact that it isnt, is just lack of representation.
- rhizome 8y agoWell, now you're moving the goalposts, but doesn't everybody have to vote where the voting devices are? Beyond that, your hypothetical is pretty loaded.
- conanbatt 8y agoOf the group of people available to vote in the city, homeonwners will have a higher participation than renters that can vote. Becuse the latter need to match their residency with the vote, and even then, they dont know as much of the issue as the local, and even then, they dont have the same interest. (the time horizon of a renter could be 2 years, of a landlord its decades). Thats why I devised that mental exercise: if you gathered up all the poeple that lived over 1 year in san francisco in the last 10 years, which one do you think is in the majority? pro-supply, con-supply?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Kalium 8y agoThey do, but there's a wrinkle. Specifically, it's not fully correct to equate NIMBYs and landowners in SF. SF has plenty of renters who are also NIMBYs, having been convinced that the only way to preserve their lifestyle is to oppose everything.
- nerfhammer 8y agoYou're forgetting that something like 75% of SF has rent control and are thereby excluded from the main reason to care. EDIT: 75% of rental units & 45% of total
- kelnos 8y agoIt's 45%, as stated by the article. Let's not let hyperbole go too far.
- refurb 8y ago45% of all housing stock, but 75% of all rental units.
- hcknwscommenter 8y agoBut they should care. Rent control is like gold hand cuffs. Eventually you face a very high chance of being trapped in a dammed if you stay (wrong location, not enough room, etc.) and dammed if you move (huge increase in rent) situation. Building more housing, in sufficient numbers, should alleviate this problem.
- Redoubts 8y agoLocal elections have pathetic turnout, usually 10 to 20%
- DrScump 8y agoThat effectively means that one's vote counts fivefold to tenfold as much... which makes not voting, while complaining about the results, exceptionally perplexing.
- thx11389793 8y agoIt was disheartening to see Jane Kim vote against sb827. The detractors moaned that it would usurp local authority over development. As someone who has to put up with the effects of insane housing policy, I'd rather see the state step in here. The local governments and NIMBYs are already failing us.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoPeople decades ago said exactly what you're saying and that's how we got local regulation. It turns out local regulation just entrenched the problems more deeply. I've yet to hear a good reason why recursion is going to solve the problem instead of entrench it at the next level up.
- djajshgsjja 8y agoHousing supply is in part a collective action problem. Lots of people will benefit from development somewhere else, but lose out from the local effect of development down the block. If the net effects of a development are positive, but the negative effects are concentrated whether local power can block the development, less development will happen and people are worse off overall.
- jakelarkin 8y agonit: Jane Kim a SF supervisor did not have a vote a California State Senate bill
- nbantique 8y agoBut she changed her position and held rallies opposing 827 saying allowing more housing near public transportation was not the answer nor going vertical. She says “we are not against housing" and "this is not the right way to build” but her actions prove different. I have not seen any solutions from her
- thx11389793 8y agotrue, thanks for the correction.
- vkou 8y agoNIMBYs are not the sole problem. Vancouver and Seattle, and their suburbs have had a lot of construction happening for the past decade, yet housing costs in both cities have spiraled out of control.
- Kneedler 8y agoDunno about Vancouver, but NIMBYs are a huge problem in Seattle. Jump into the comment section of any local neighborhood news blog post discussing development and you'll see what I mean.
- Maybestring 8y agoIn King county, there has been lots of construction in the last decade, but not enough to keep pace with immigration.
- Silfen 8y agoNIMBYs are a huge problem in Seattle. Depending on how you count, roughly 80% of the city is zoned single family[0]. Construction isn't happening fast enough. In 2016 Seattle only gained 0.4 housing units for every job[1]. [0]https://fancybeans.com/2018/01/24/65-57-35-how-much-seattle-land-is-zoned-single-family-really/ https://fancybeans.com/2018/01/24/65-57-35-how-much-seattle-... [1]http://blog.employmarket.com/2017/03/13/2016-metro-area-employment-growth-and-housing-permits/ http://blog.employmarket.com/2017/03/13/2016-metro-area-empl...
- luddaite 8y agoI recently heard homeowners referred to as a cartel on a podcast. It was definitely thought provoking. Is there any way to create a home ownership system where existing homeowners are discouraged from making it harder for other people to get homes?
- nerfhammer 8y agoRepealing prop 13
- vorpalhex 8y agoCartels use violence to gain profit. Homeowners invest their own money, at significant interest rates, to obtain a place to live. They do of course have an interest in protecting that investment - with increased density comes increased crime, stressed parking, and other problems. To call homeowners a "cartel" as if they're extorting their local community for protection money is inherently misleading.
- nerfhammer 8y agoA cartel just means colluding to limit supply to increase profit for cartel members. There is nothing in the definition of a cartel that requires violence or illegality. For instance, Canada has a legal maple syrup cartel: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federation_of_Quebec_Maple_Syrup_Producers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federation_of_Quebec_Maple_Syr...
- tialaramex 8y agoNot just supply, cartels are a group working together to manipulate markets in a variety of ways, also including: Hold prices for their own suppliers artificially low by agreeing a price cap and refusing to pay more. They rely on suppliers having nowhere else to sell. e.g. British supermarkets have been repeatedly accused and sometimes IIRC convicted of operating a cartel to demand unfairly low prices from food producers. Agree to split geographies so that there's effectively no competition to supply and each member of the cartel has local monopolies in all or most territory. This should be familiar to US folks who want High Speed Internet outside of a major city. All agree never to offer a product which would hurt the overall market but be profitable for the first to offer it. Some have claimed the long delay in electric cars coming to market is evidence of this sort of cartel. Cartels are illegal in much of the world (but ordinary laws don't apply to sovereign entities). If you're ever part of some big industry insider meeting and the lawyers make everybody agree not to talk about prices, future products or other commercial issues it's not because they're commercially sensitive, it's because your executives could do jail time if a court decides your group is a cartel.
- joshe 8y agoThe mayor has several levers to speed the construction of housing. More housing would get built with a pro housing mayor.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoBut would it be effective housing, or just more housing that sits dark because it was bought as a way to park cash?
- pascalxus 8y agoAnd even if he could override NIMBYs, the number of laws and processes and procedures in place that prevent more building are absolutely staggering. Not to mention, the middle class is leaving. By the time we get rid of all the crazy regulations, the middle class will be gone and there will be no one left to build this stuff up ~ someone's got to wield the hammers (labor cost will be too high).
- bcoates 8y agoI don't live in SF but it looks like the planning commission is appointed by the mayor.
- Kalium 8y agoSF has a lot of bodies with veto powers over any building project (like neighborhood councils) and there's a lot of legal levers to pull. There's a lot more to it than just the city's planning commission.
- diogenescynic 8y agoWe need to reform that. There are too many ways for NIMBYs to throw obstacles in front of new development, which hurts everyone, and helps mostly the rich who already own property.
- Kalium 8y agoWe do! Unfortunately, reforming it is actually surprisingly difficult because NIMBYism is pretty popular.
- DrScump 8y agoWhat is the legal foundation of these "veto powers" to which you refer?
- wankerrific 8y agoRight on cue - YIMBY/SFBARFers respond to any HN headline with the words San Francisco and Housing with their strawman argument "NIMBY'S". Nevermind the fact that the question here is about homelessness which is exacerbated when you lobby to mow down affordable SROs and rent controlled housing so some developers can rebuild luxury condos in their place. How exactly will that help the homelessness problem?
- briandear 8y agoMore housing (even luxury) increases supply thus lowers prices. That means that someone living in a studio might move to a 1 bed, leaving the studio vacant, thus increasing supply as people move up — a process that is only possible with a greater supply. And rent control actually leads to shortages as mobility is reduced because of people staying in places longer than they would have otherwise. It also disincentivizes creation of new housing. Greater supply is needed. That’s the bottom line.
- vicnov 8y agoTHIS. Every time I hear "we need to protect poor from eviction by evil tech workers" I want to scream. Yeah sure.. tech workers who make 150k+ are dreaming about moving in a shitty house in East Bay. Boulding more affordable housing looks great in a political ad, but does not do shit to resolve the crisis
- joshe 8y agoYou really can build enough housing to lower prices. Tokyo has. You can get a small Tokyo studio apartment for $700 per month. [1] This is because they build housing. San Francisco, London, New York, and Seattle all don't build housing and prices go up. [2] If housing were easier to build people would build more affordable housing. No developer cares if they build expensive housing or affordable housing, they are maximizing return on investment. Turning a 1 story house into a 3 story house for a 30% return makes developers just as happy as developing 20 luxury condos for a 30% return. And even those luxury condos provide housing for people who would otherwise buy old condos and renovate them. As long as the housing is more dense and there is more of it, prices will come down. [1] https://resources.realestate.co.jp/buy/average-rent-in-japan-by-prefecture/ https://resources.realestate.co.jp/buy/average-rent-in-japan... [2] https://www.ft.com/content/023562e2-54a6-11e6-befd-2fc0c26b3c60 https://www.ft.com/content/023562e2-54a6-11e6-befd-2fc0c26b3...