4 ms·
Where did you travel in the states?
by oh_sigh 8y ago
Where did you travel in the states?
- HarryHirsch 8y agoCan't speak for him, but long ago I took the wrong exit from the highway, ending up in North Philly. Merthyr Tydfil has nothing on North Philadelphia.
- thiagocsf 8y agoHow does it compare to Port Talbot?
- HarryHirsch 8y agoPort Talbot can't have improved with they closed the steelworks down, but it can't possibly compete with Philly, the level of decay is unimaginable to a person from Western Europe.
- Maarten88 8y agoI had the same experience, I was mostly in big, rich cities like NY, SF, LA, Seattle. From other travelers I heard when you travel deep into South Central US, you can find full-on third world scenery. It is shocking how many poor people are begging on the streets, in a country that is, on average, richer than where I live.
- ravitation 8y agoThe difference between urban and rural America is that in urban America you have the juxtaposition of wealth and poverty and in rural America you just have poverty.
- dustincoates 8y ago> From other travelers I heard when you travel deep into South Central US, you can find full-on third world scenery. Respectfully, the people who told you this were either vastly exaggerating or had zero sense of perspective. You're not finding houses in "South Central US" (not sure exactly what that refers to anyway) without running water or dirt floors. I actually grew up in the small town South and knew plenty of people who commuted into town from the country. Some were poor, sure, but "full-on third world scenery." Come on...
- ravitation 8y agoWell, unfortunately, having running water and having drinkable running water are not synonymous in the United States. Also, third world countries are not just countries without running water and dirt floors...
- dustincoates 8y agoNot at all, and I thought about being more explicit, but we both know that the gp wasn't referring to upper class third world neighborhoods.
- IOT_Apprentice 8y agoFirst world was non-communist NATO aligned countries. Communist countries were 2nd world, non-aligned with either were 3rd world. That said, American having protectorates where citizens don't have power, drinkable running water or cities where there is no drinkable running water are poor examples for a nation with such resources as the US.
- ravitation 8y agoI know the etymology of third world, but it's meaning has also changed significantly since the end of the Cold War... I was referring specifically to American cities (cities in America, not American "protectorates") that don't have drinkable running water...
- arcticbull 8y agoHmm, I'm not so sure that's true. From [1] there are about 500,000 people spread over almost 2,300 'colonias' in Texas who live without basic services like running water or sewer. There's by some measure 1.7 million of them over the US [2]. The photos from that article are very much what is described. There are incredibly poor parts of the US where people really do live in third-world conditions -- though that's definitely the exception. Even within major cities like SF, we battle with the 'encampments' and I routinely walk by planters filled to the brim with heroin needles. Some of my walks home I see people with open wounds, lying on the sidewalk, with obvious mental illnesses muttering to themselves. You definitely won't find this in Europe, and I've certainly not seen something comparable growing up in Canada. There's huge wealth disparity here and massive distrust of the government, which together mean those most in need are not looked after. I believe in income and wealth inequality but only when coupled with social mobility and only when the worst off can live meaningful, healthy lives. I definitely have perspective, having lived in Canada, Saudi Arabia, Australia and the US. I've also traveled all over Europe and Asia. [1] https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/03/the-americans-without-running-water/471909/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/03/the-ame... [2] https://www.huffingtonpost.com/george-mcgraw/live-without-running-water-in-america_b_8011310.html https://www.huffingtonpost.com/george-mcgraw/live-without-ru...
- Frondo 8y agoWhat's amazing to me is how many people are so quick to dismiss the kind of poverty we have in the U.S., just because people in the poorest developing nations have it worse off. Why this status quo is one anyone would want to defend is so beyond me, I feel like we're on different planets.
- maym86 8y agoTook the Amtrak across it stoping in a lot of places over 2 months. Most shocking was Memphis. It seemed incredibly poor. A lot of closed businesses and many people on the streets. I live in the Bay Area now and SF Civic Center is still incredible given all the money in the area.