2 ms·
Besides for a few facts thrown around in the beginning, this is entirely an opinion piece. Even the facts in the beginning are presented in a misleading manner
by oh_sigh 8y ago
Besides for a few facts thrown around in the beginning, this is entirely an opinion piece. Even the facts in the beginning are presented in a misleading manner IMHO:
> The average American can’t scrape together $500 for an emergency. A third of Americans can’t afford food, shelter, and healthcare. Healthcare for a family now costs $28k — about half of median income, which is $60k.
The "source" in the first statement links to a google search for "american 500 emergency". Not a compelling source IMHO.
The source for the second statement seems to be legitimate, but the author claims that 'a third of Americans can't afford food, shelter, and healthcare', when in fact the source only claims that a third of americans may struggle to afford those things. There is a difference.
The final statement is conflating employer-paid healthcare costs with median income, as if that $28k is coming out of the $60k - when it is not - most of it is being paid by an employer.
And then the rest of the article is an opinion piece full of assertions and little evidence. Pretty low quality article for HN in my opinion.
- thiagocsf 8y agoI don’t think it matter that the 28k are paid by the employer and not from the 60k salary. Perhaps this person could be making 88k instead? Also, while you’re inbetween jobs, health care still costs 28k.
- oh_sigh 8y agoI agree. My point is that it is a misleading juxtaposition. I think most people who read that sentence would parse it as something like Americans income is 60k, and then after they pay for healthcare they have 32k or less left
- arcticbull 8y agoIt's really hard to make a direct comparison as in countries with socialized medicine, you don't really have co-pays, deductibles, caps, out-of-pocket maximums, etc. The implicit assumption you make is also that the average American gets their insurance through their employer -- they do, but that's not the whole picture. 55.7% of Americans get cover from employers, 16.2% from individual markets, 19.4% from Medicaid and 16.7% from Medicare. [1] After all, if people can't come up with $500 for emergencies, what's the chance they can come up with co-pays? This is measured in [2] and they conclude 41,000,000 Americans are underinsured. So they may not have 32K left, but they probably do have less than 60K left. In fact I'd imagine that the 55.7% who have employer-paid coverage probably make way more than the 44.3% who do not. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_insurance_coverage_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_insurance_coverage_in_t... [2] http://www.commonwealthfund.org/~/media/files/publications/issue-brief/2017/oct/collins_underinsured_biennial_ib.pdf http://www.commonwealthfund.org/~/media/files/publications/i...