5 ms·
I mostly agree with both of your points, but I also think "we have it much better" depends on which "we" you're talking about. Our practices are better for peop
by sanderjd 8y ago
I mostly agree with both of your points, but I also think "we have it much better" depends on which "we" you're talking about. Our practices are better for people trying to break in and worse for seasoned professionals. It's more time consuming (and less well-paid) to become a nurse, but once you have done so, you don't have to do it again every time you switch jobs.
- kingbirdy 8y agoI am very happy to take a month of brushing up on algorithms and so on every few years as I want a new job as opposed to an additional several years of school.
- draw_down 8y agoHow is that a response to GP’s point?
- e40 8y agoIn the example given, a nurse wouldn't need additional schooling to switch jobs.
- szermer 8y agoEveryone in the medical profession needs continuing education (CE) credits. Not much different from certs that support folks need to obtain if they work government/ DoD positions. https://www.nurse.com/state-nurse-ce-requirements https://www.nurse.com/state-nurse-ce-requirements
- vonmoltke 8y agoCE classes for nearly all professions are a joke compared to the shit software engineers are expected to go through to rehearse for interviews. As for government work, I'm not sure where you got that idea from. I did government work for 14 years and never needed any certifications. If I had, the company would have paid for it and it would have been on company time.
- sanderjd 8y agoImagine CE credits for things like distributed systems and machine learning as you move along in your career: wouldn't that be more useful than brushing up on that Trie algorithm you'll never implement?
- fjsolwmv 8y agoSure. So get that executive masters or Coursera certificate, and then spend an hour convincing an employer that you actually learned something in your course.
- sanderjd 8y agoIt would be great if the continuing education most of us actually enjoy doing were a valuable thing to do. As it is, if you want to switch jobs, it's much more valuable to study old things that help with whiteboard interviews than to spend time learning new things.
- e40 8y agoThe issue is changing jobs, not keeping up with credits for your current job.
- taude 8y agoDo you have a family and other dependencies where taking a month off isn't really tenable after you leave your 20s, or whenever you settle down? It seems kind of absurd to take a month off every few years just to practice for a new job, whether the skills you're practicing are relevant or not to said job performance.
- jaredklewis 8y agoTo me it doesn’t seem any more absurd than front loading 3 or more years of expensive professional school as do many other professions like lawyers, architects, and doctors. Just pretend you went to law school and have to make monthly loan repayments each month. Put that money in bank account and you will have more than enough savings to take off work for a month every few years. Median wage for programmers is nearly double the US median household income and has few barriers to entry. If the only downside is having to take a month off work every few years, I’m not complaining.
- sanderjd 8y agoThe model I envy isn't lawyers, it's PEs. Their professional degree isn't exorbitantly priced and the education is very useful for the career rather than busy work (by the accounts of those I know). Once the credential is earned, it is widely respected. Edit to add: In general, I don't think our system has to be worse than all others for it to be worthwhile to consider what might be better.
- jaredklewis 8y agoSure, but doesn’t it require 4 years of school + 4 years working under a licensed PE, then state exams? It is a very different set of trade offs than what we have in CS, where companies are more than willing to take a chance on bright people with non traditional backgrounds, including people that never went to college or dropped out. As a lifelong self-learner, I’ve certainly appreciated the lack of “credentialism” at tech companies. The one part of the PE thing that I would like to see borrowed is the exams. If all companies are just running everyone through the same kinds of general CS problems anyway, might as well save everyone time and improve consistency by making a standardized test.
- sanderjd 8y agoI'm sure I felt like this when I was jazzed at how easy it felt to get my first good job with just a BS. After a few times through the job switch ringer at this point I'm rather bored of it and would much prefer to have a widely respected professional accreditation to point to instead of all the repeated pointless work. But I don't think the extra-school way (like in my nursing school example) is the only way to achieve that; what I would personally like to see is an apprenticeship / craftsman model. I think a PE requires both a master's degree and apprenticeship. Maybe we could do the latter without the former? But this is idle wishing: the current system likely has to much inertia for real change at this point.
- southern_cross 8y agoMy wife is a long-time hospital nurse, and she will be the first to tell you that hiring a nurse today is a much more tedious and time-consuming task than it was back in the day. Entry-level educational requirements are higher now, for one, and the whole hiring process at her hospital (which used to be relatively quick and straightforward) is now both tedious and time-consuming. Not surprisingly, this leads to an on-going shortage of nurses, with significant job-hopping from one hospital floor to another, from one facility to another, or from one organization to another. And surprisingly (or maybe not) the "new and improved" hiring process hasn't necessarily led to an improvement in the overall candidate pool, and in at least some cases has caused a noticeable decline. As to "you don't have to do it again every time you switch jobs", nurses are often required to go through continuing education just to keep their licenses current. But making the jump from one type of nursing specialization to another, or even upgrading from an RN to a BSN (often required today if you want to keep your job - probably the exact same job that you've already been doing for ages) can be quite grueling - almost like starting over. In one recent case, a well-respected fellow nurse upgraded her education only to be to told that even that was no longer considered sufficient. She was already doing management-level work but didn't yet have the official title or the pay, and was told that she needed to go up an additional level in education in order to get that, so she just bailed - decades of experience walked out the door for no good reason.
- commandlinefan 8y ago> license current I continue to be shocked that software developers aren't licensed at least like RNs or CPAs are.
- NTDF9 8y ago>> I continue to be shocked that software developers aren't licensed at least like RNs or CPAs are. What a great idea! Let's call it a degree
- Rychard 8y agoAccording to the Stack Overflow's 2016 Developer Survey [1], "56% of developers in fact do not have a college degree in computer science or related fields" Admittedly, the data is a few years old (and I didn't want to pull the same data from the 2018 survey), but such a requirement would put many people out of a job. I also haven't seen any concrete data that would support any correlation between the efficacy of a software engineer and whether they had obtained a college degree, so this seems like a poor metric. I share your incredulity regarding the lack of any sort of "occupational license" for the industry, though I remain unconvinced that instituting one would have a positive effect. [1] : https://stackoverflow.blog/2016/10/07/do-developers-need-college-degrees/ https://stackoverflow.blog/2016/10/07/do-developers-need-col...