3 ms·
I work in an industry that is in EXACTLY that situation -- Carbon Fiber Composites (I've also read Atlas Shrugged). Ayn Rand's description sounded great when I
by toss1 8y ago
I work in an industry that is in EXACTLY that situation -- Carbon Fiber Composites (I've also read Atlas Shrugged).
Ayn Rand's description sounded great when I was a teenager.
Living it for real, I know it is utter bullshit.
Carbon Fiber Composites are far stronger, stiffer, and lighter than any steel, and less expensive in small volumes. It's more expensive in large volumes, but R&D is mitigating that.
Yes, managers and even engineers have a bias against it because it is new and untested, takes more work to include in designs.
Yet, it is being steadily adopted.
---------------
In terms of govt, sure, a small govt with voluntary contributions sounds great. Until you realize (which you haven't) that this is setting up EXACTLY the commons problem: it is in everyone's interest too support the government, but in every individual's interest to freeload or over-use and under-pay. Eventually even the goodest of the do-gooders will be sick & tired of being mooched off of, and you're back to anarchy. If you doubt this, go look at the population of any commercially viable fish; ask how they're doing.
The fact of the matter is that if you ACTUALLY think through any of these ideas, they are hollow. That is the reason they have never been implemented.