3 ms·
People arguing about slavery in the US did have the ability to observe that other societies had abolished it and been successful. And we today have the ability
by perl4ever 8y ago
People arguing about slavery in the US did have the ability to observe that other societies had abolished it and been successful. And we today have the ability to observe other societies that don't have a stable monopoly of force and taxing power and see them in perpetual chaos, where competing groups with different sources of revenue struggle to become governments. It doesn't make any sense to say nobody has ever tried anarchy, because (a) it's all over the place, and manifestly involves poverty and misery, and (b) it was the original state of humankind, so we know it is possible and that government as we know it develops from it.
- duncan_bayne 8y agoSorry if I wasn't clear; I'm not arguing for anarchy, I'm arguing for small Government tasked solely with protecting the rights of its citizens, funded by voluntary taxation.
- toss1 8y agoThe same argument still applies. It is NOT impossible for people to make progress. It just takes more than a set of half-baked ideas. The ideas must be fully thought through to their consequences, with second- and third-order consequences, adjusted so that they will actually work with real human nature factored in, tested, adjusted, then rolled out. In this sense, although I am strongly attracted to Libertarianism and often use it as my default starting point, I recognize that it is like Communism in that it is completely impractical and won't happen in a real world (actually, communism has a better chance with modern tech solcing central planning, blockchain micropayments, smart contracts allocating resources, LOL, bs...).
- perl4ever 8y agoIf government funded by "voluntary taxation" isn't anarchy, I'm not sure what else it could be. It seems to me obvious that either there is a monopoly on coercive power or there is not, and "voluntary taxation" means there is not. Which means you have multiple gangs or insurgencies.