3 ms·
This is pretty much word-for-word what I think about the blacklisting of Huawei, except with an additional twist: we know there are objections to their corporat
by ggm 8y ago
This is pretty much word-for-word what I think about the blacklisting of Huawei, except with an additional twist: we know there are objections to their corporate governance model because it is believed to include investment/board direction from ex-PLA seniors and therefore is held to be too close to a state-actor, and not transparent. But do we get told technical real, live, believable information about the risk side of their fiber or technology which is the headline reason? No. we do not. we get five-eyes FUD.
I want to see the technical paper too, but for Huawei.
- nl 8y agoI think Huawei is a pretty different case. We know from the Snowden leaks that the NSA had access to (Huawei founder/CEO, and ex-Chinese intel employee) Zhengfei's email back from 2010. They also got access to Huawei's source code repository. By 2012 US five-eyes allies were banning Huawei from critical infrastructure projects[1]. Doesn't take a lot of reading between the lines there to speculate that they really did find some stuff. [1] https://www.redherring.com/hardware/huawei-blacklisted/ https://www.redherring.com/hardware/huawei-blacklisted/
- lawnchair_larry 8y agoThe problem is if we speculate by reading between the lines, we still have nothing.
- ggm 8y agoNo. this is exactly wrong. speculation is useless. We know on equal terms, Cisco and Juniper probably had backdoors because of the NSA. Do we stop using them? The joke here is, that the Chinese don't share intelligence with anyone else: arguably, if they do see our packets, less people see them because the NSA share with their strategic partners, and with the FBI!