3 ms·
No, they're really cooked up by accountants and tax lawyers. In the UK the situation works like this: You, an accountant or tax lawyer or more likely firm empl
by tialaramex 8y ago
No, they're really cooked up by accountants and tax lawyers. In the UK the situation works like this:
You, an accountant or tax lawyer or more likely firm employing both, come up with a scheme for avoiding tax that you think might be legal. You can charge people money for teaching them this scheme and helping execute it. Now, you tell the government about the scheme. The tax man can say "Yup, that's legal, all good" (and maybe tell the government the tax laws need changing if it wants to stop this next year) or they can take your clients to court and if a court agrees, require them to pay the extra taxes. You don't care, you got paid either way - the law doesn't chase you so long as you report the clever scheme.
- xioxox 8y agoExcept the tax man doesn't approve schemes. See https://www.gov.uk/guidance/disclosure-of-tax-avoidance-schemes-overview https://www.gov.uk/guidance/disclosure-of-tax-avoidance-sche.... They may come along later and take you to court if they decide to.
- toss1 8y agoSimilarly, in the US, there's a structure called a "Private Letter Ruling", where an accountant/attny can request a private ruling about the tax treatment for a transaction/structure/etc.. IIRC it costs about $25K, and if they say it is compliant, you can go with it.