3 ms·

It seems Watson was founded on the false premise that lots of hand coded things could be called an “AI”. It’s the victim of its own winter, because it was never

It seems Watson was founded on the false premise that lots of hand coded things could be called an “AI”. It’s the victim of its own winter, because it was never going to live up to its own hype.

oliviergg 8y ago
Interesting. Do you have some references about this 'hand coded things' ?
- waisbrot 8y ago
  "Hand-coded" may be an exaggeration, depending on your field. ML systems need good training data (where "good" might mean "extremely voluminous") and careful tweaking of parameters. I think an ML expert would call a system where a substantial amount of time is spent here "hand-coded".
AdamM12 8y ago
Yeah I kinda remember reading it being accused of being vaporware. Then I googled "Watson vaporware" and got the following [1]. Definitely think they are in that part of the hype cycle. [1] https://www.technologyreview.com/s/607965/a-reality-check-for-ibms-ai-ambitions/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/607965/a-reality-check-fo... edit: "trough of disillusionment" is what I was looking for
- darkerside 8y ago
  Interesting article, but I'd bet a big part of the reason physicians don't know it's that do much is dependent upon information that lives "out of the system". How much time will a patient spend on rehab, and will they actually perform the exercises effectively? What's their diet like, not just calories in but in terms of individual nutrients? How active is their lifestyle? Recovery time seems like something that should be knowable by educated doctors, but the best poker player in the world can't tell you what card is coming up on the river.
raverbashing 8y ago
I couldn't have put it better myself. Participating in Jeopardy was quite an achievement, but to extrapolate that system and selling it as a "solve all" is to over promise.
- jgalt212 8y ago
  To be fair, it did more than participate. It dominated.
dmreedy 8y ago
Do you imagine that other, more successful "AI" services from large companies do not involve a lot of hand-coded things?
- throwawayok 8y ago
  Yes. Well, at the very least, they don't involve only hand-coded things.
- thebluehawk 8y ago
  The ones that aren't hand-coded tend to act poorly, or racist, or worst.

oliviergg 8y ago

Interesting. Do you have some references about this 'hand coded things' ?

waisbrot 8y ago
"Hand-coded" may be an exaggeration, depending on your field. ML systems need good training data (where "good" might mean "extremely voluminous") and careful tweaking of parameters. I think an ML expert would call a system where a substantial amount of time is spent here "hand-coded".

AdamM12 8y ago

Yeah I kinda remember reading it being accused of being vaporware. Then I googled "Watson vaporware" and got the following [1]. Definitely think they are in that part of the hype cycle. [1] https://www.technologyreview.com/s/607965/a-reality-check-for-ibms-ai-ambitions/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/607965/a-reality-check-fo... edit: "trough of disillusionment" is what I was looking for

darkerside 8y ago
Interesting article, but I'd bet a big part of the reason physicians don't know it's that do much is dependent upon information that lives "out of the system". How much time will a patient spend on rehab, and will they actually perform the exercises effectively? What's their diet like, not just calories in but in terms of individual nutrients? How active is their lifestyle? Recovery time seems like something that should be knowable by educated doctors, but the best poker player in the world can't tell you what card is coming up on the river.

raverbashing 8y ago

I couldn't have put it better myself. Participating in Jeopardy was quite an achievement, but to extrapolate that system and selling it as a "solve all" is to over promise.

jgalt212 8y ago
To be fair, it did more than participate. It dominated.

dmreedy 8y ago

Do you imagine that other, more successful "AI" services from large companies do not involve a lot of hand-coded things?

throwawayok 8y ago
Yes. Well, at the very least, they don't involve only hand-coded things.
thebluehawk 8y ago
The ones that aren't hand-coded tend to act poorly, or racist, or worst.