5 ms·
And we're back to the question at least as old as ancient Rome: Quis custodiet ipsos custodes? ("Who will guard the guards themselves?") The very structure of
by toss1 8y ago
And we're back to the question at least as old as ancient Rome:
Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?
("Who will guard the guards themselves?")
The very structure of large accountancy needs to be overturned, as today, the primary incentive for the big 4 is to preserve their client relationships -- that is the side on which their bread is buttered. This means applying their stamp of credibility, not finding and highlighting troubles, especially fundamental/systemic/existential troubles...
- Retric 8y agoIt's great to find problems, just share them over a golf game and not an official report.
- toss1 8y agoAnd when the problems have systemic implications, and are the result of policies/actions from those at the top, with whom the accountants are golfing? This was the point of the article -- accountancy was supposed to provide a guard function -- checks and balances. Now, it is merely a compromised credentialing service.
- Spooky23 8y agoDon't forget the accountancy-created problems, like the various exotic means used to avoid taxation. It had always seemed odd to me that a company providing advice about essentially laundering money at scale also is the arbiter of truth for accounting principles!
- duncan_bayne 8y agoHow are exotic tax reduction schemes caused by accountants? That's like saying fires are caused by firefighters. They're a consequence of compulsory taxation.
- toss1 8y agoNo, they are not a necessary consequence of compulsory taxation. There is no necessity to create any exotic tax reduction scheme. They are created by over-financialized MBAs trying to evade their company's obligations to society. If you have a real plan for to effectively run a complex society without compulsory taxation to implement necessary collective goods (roads, policing, schools, defense, etc., etc, etc), I'm all ears, and I'm sure so are many others. Until then, your comment is purely specious.
- duncan_bayne 8y agoMany people would dispute elements of your "necessary" lists, especially Austrian economist and Objectivists (I'm in the latter camp). Also, many people have proposed alternatives for funding legitimate Government functions without coercion, and relying on charity for the rest (like education) in cases where people can't afford them.
- toss1 8y ago"Many people"... OK. Sure the "Austrian economics" crowd is out there. Yes, they have a point about avoiding hyperinflation, but also often oversimplify. In what country has a modern complex society been actually run without actual coersive tax? In what society have complex and costly ventures like an entire modern education, defense road system been done with it? Any real, hard examples? Abstract ideology is lovely, but is not a practical govt that manages to build the basis for an advanced and advancing society
- duncan_bayne 8y agoConsider where this logic would take you if you applied it to all spheres of life. There would never be experimentation, innovation, or in fact development of any kind. Coming back to the Objectivist angle, there's a great passage from Atlas Shrugged that covers this: ===== "Then what on earth do you know about Rearden Metal?" "That it's the greatest thing ever put on the market." "Why?" "Because it's tougher than steel, cheaper than steel and will outlast any hunk of metal in existence." "But who says so?" "Jim, I studied engineering in college. When I see things, I see them." "What did you see?" "Rearden's formula and the tests he showed me." "Well, if it were any good, somebody would have used it, and nobody has." He saw the flash of anger, and went on nervously: "How can you know it's good? How can you be sure? How can you decide?" "Somebody decides such things, Jim. Who?" "Well, I don't see why we have to be the first ones. I don't see it at all." "Do you want to save the Rio Norte Line or not?" He did not answer, "If the road could afford it, I would scrap every piece of rail over the whole system and replace it with Rearden Metal. All of it needs replacing. None of it will last much longer. But we can't afford it. We have to get out of a bad hole, first. Do you want us to pull through or not?" "We're still the best railroad in the country. The others are doing much worse." ==== In general this feels like a class of logical fallacy, of the form "no-one has attempted to achieve X, so X must be undesirable" but I can't find it in any lists. edit: To make it clearer, take your post, and substitute slavery for coercive taxation. Your argument immediately appears specious, because with the benefit of hindsight we know that large, complex, modern societies did just fine after abandoning slavery. But people argued against emancipation in just that way at the time.