4 ms·
I think interactive models are fantastic for learning about systems and how they work. The thing is, it's difficult to design and create these types of models,
by chrisco255 8y ago
I think interactive models are fantastic for learning about systems and how they work. The thing is, it's difficult to design and create these types of models, even today (2018). I don't know that we have created tools that empower non-programmers to build such complex models.
Even knowing and understanding programming, you'll have to spend a considerable amount of time to create such interactive media. This might be worth it if you have an online learning company and you're selling educational content for mass audiences. For the one off technical paper or write-up, the dozens to hundreds of hours it might take to produce interactive media (assuming you already have those hard-earned skills) describing your topic is too much for most.
- dc443 8y agoAgreed. His demos are always impressive, but my biggest worry for him is that he's stuck in demo-land. What's sorely missing is guidance (or code) that can help empower more people to create things like this. But the reality is probably simpler in the sense that complex things are just that: complex, and modeling them is at least as complex, so it will always be hard, and it's only the meta-ideas that can have lasting applicable value. And he's pretty great at disseminating his meta-ideas. As a non-academic and a web developer, if I were to publish some work of mine, I have always known that I would do it in the form of a webpage. That way, I can make it as dynamic as I need it to be.
- _pius 8y agoWhat’s sorely missing is guidance (or code) that can help empower more people to create things like this. http://worrydream.com/Tangle/ http://worrydream.com/Tangle/
- chrisco255 8y agoYeah but if you look at the code that drives those more complex examples, that is non-trivial for a non-developer.
- ljw1001 8y ago> complex things are just that: complex, and modeling them is at least as complex, so it will always be hard, I recall reading that a measure of the complexity of a thing (formally) is the shortest possible non-lossy description. This suggests that your insight is correct. The question is how much further can we go in automating parts of the descriptions.
- scroot 8y agoWhat if we expand what we mean by "programming" and who we call "programmers"? Decades ago Hypercard enabled regular users to create the kind of interactive media you've described, and to do so easily. There are several reasons it worked so well, but chief among them was the overall metaphor employed: cards, stacks, and everything that goes in (or on) them. These were intuitive to human thinking, and people were able to take advantage of it. So often computer/software/platform designers use inappropriate metaphors. If you want people to truly be able to "compute" dynamic media with your system, but you trap them in ideas of bits, bytes, words, or today's data structures, you have already lost. (You wouldn't ask a carpenter to build you a table using quantum mechanics). What's perhaps most depressing about all of this is that we had better systems (like Hypercard) two decades ago for allowing regular users to do this kind of stuff. Today it's more difficult.
- germinalphrase 8y agoAs an educator and non-programmer, I would love a "tool for making tools". I'm constantly introduced to new tools being made for me that don't actually solve my problems. Let me define what would make my work more efficient/effective.
- walterbell 8y agoWhich tools-for-tools have you tried? Any thoughts on LiveCode (https://livecode.com https://livecode.com, modern day Hypercard) or Jupyter notebooks?
- germinalphrase 8y agoI haven't tried either of those, but I'll give them a look. You believe a non-programmer could use them effectively?
- disqard 8y agoIf you happen to have time and are curious, I'd like to point you at BlockStudio [1], a text-free visual programming language that's aimed at beginners learning to code. Disclosure: It's my own research work, and definitely "work in progress". [1] www.blockstud.io
- TimTheTinker 8y agoSteven Wittens (author of the MathBox library) has some outstanding articles explaining math concepts with great interactive visuals. Best viewed on a desktop browser: "How to fold a Julia fractal": https://acko.net/blog/how-to-fold-a-julia-fractal/ https://acko.net/blog/how-to-fold-a-julia-fractal/ "To Infinity... And Beyond!": https://acko.net/blog/to-infinity-and-beyond/ https://acko.net/blog/to-infinity-and-beyond/