3 ms·
This is a good example of someone who can't explain a simple concept. The author uses pages and pages when a very simple explanation would make a lot more sense
by gwbas1c 8y ago
This is a good example of someone who can't explain a simple concept. The author uses pages and pages when a very simple explanation would make a lot more sense.
I think a lot of new technology is explained this way, and that's why some people think certain new technologies have magical properties.
Referring to cruise control as a "robot" is, in hindsight, idiotic.
- analog31 8y agoIn the author's defense, virtually nobody understood feedback control systems in 1958. Most people still don't, but describing it as a computer may make it easier to understand today. Also, it looks like Popular Science hasn't changed.
- hartator 8y agoActually thought it was well written, except the women comment, and it was doing a good job of explaining how the technology worked. Pointing to the same limitations cruise controlle is facing today, hills feeling uneasy, too fast, or too slow as there is no context, etc.
- csours 8y ago> Referring to cruise control as a "robot" is, in hindsight, idiotic. Much like 'AI' the definition of 'robot' shrinks to the pool of things which technology has not conquered. That is to say - Speech Recognition is not AI, Image Recognition is not AI, etc etc. As soon as it has its own name, we no longer call it AI or robotics.
- engi_nerd 8y agoThe concept is simple to you because cruise control is such a common feature in cars that you only notice its absence. You understand exactly what a cruise control does and how to control one. Now consider being in the 1950s -- probably you had never even imagined the concept of a device that automatically regulated the throttle position of your car. And also imagine that your overall knowledge base was much less -- the average person of 1950s western civilization was exposed to much less information on a daily basis than the average person of 2018. One of the base definitions of the term "robot" is "a machine capable of carrying out a complex sequence of actions automatically". Given that definition, I hardly think that calling a cruise control a "robot" idiotic. But what we call robots are far more complex and integrate narrow AI, so our threshold for calling something a "robot" is much higher than what would have passed for a robot in the 1950s.