6 ms·
Interestingly enough, this starts to bring up questions that have previously only been super active in science fiction circles, particularly, Star Trek: If you
by ocdtrekkie 8y ago
Interestingly enough, this starts to bring up questions that have previously only been super active in science fiction circles, particularly, Star Trek: If you can perfectly recreate something down to the molecular level, what actually has value? (Assuming, someday, that synthetic versions are excessively cheap, in Star Trek's case.)
If you can replicate cooked food perfectly, will people still claim that "real" food, grown, slaughtered, and cooked, is "better" or tastes "more authentic", despite no technical difference?
Synthetic diamonds could, in fact, be in every way "better" (though hilariously, De Beers suggests a synthetic diamond "may not be forever"), but I won't be surprised if authentic diamonds remain the "real ones" long term. (After all, as we know, diamonds actually have no real value, it's all marketing.)
- digi_owl 8y agoI seem to recall that Deep Space 9 touched in this in various ways during its run. Keep in mind that it was the first series that was fully made without Roddenberry input.
- vidarh 8y agoTNG, Voyager and Deep Space 9 all at various points made an issue of how the replicated food was not quite the same, without really trying to explain why (a lot of the issues with our mass produced food is exactly that: it's been modified to suit mass production, transport and storage, and often to be cost reduced as well; you'd expect most of those issues to disappear once you're using a replicator). But you're probably right that DS9 made a bigger deal of it, especially with Sisko's dad and his restaurant featuring more than once, as well as various luxury products fetching high prices, when you might otherwise assume such high prices would quickly ensure they'd get replicated.
- Karunamon 8y agoTNG touched on it I think - Deanna once tried to have the computer replicate her a chocolate sundae or some such, and it was implied if not outright said that the normal sundae was modified to be more nutritious. I’d imagine tweaking the “junk” out of desserts would make them taste different even if you have molecular control over the results. Yup, found the clip here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBWpVjzJXIs&feature=youtu.be&t=30s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBWpVjzJXIs&feature=youtu.be...
- logfromblammo 8y agoYou'd think that LaForge, or at least Crusher the younger, could do a hoppin' side-business with just one replicator hacked to bypass the nanny functions that turn alcohol into synthahol and chocolate into cocoa-flavored nutriment. I saw that in the new Lost in Space series, where the 3D printer refused to print a firearm in an emergency, and thought to myself, "ohhhh no you di'n't!" In my mind, I was already patching out the DRM function, or adding stray non-functional voxels to fool its pattern-matching. That was one of the things I disliked most about TNG, where humanity intentionally crippled itself by installing nannybots everywhere. DS9 brought some of the dirty reality back, with Ferengi-run gambling and holo-prostitution and cops that were actually people. Or goo pretending to be a person, anyway.
- Izkata 8y ago> TNG, Voyager and Deep Space 9 all at various points made an issue of how the replicated food was not quite the same, without really trying to explain why I believe there's a good hint when you combine some stuff from across TNG/DS9/VOY: Replicator patterns are relatively low-resolution for storage. They only go to the molecular level, not the subatomic/quantum level [0], and even then occasionally have issues [1]. And even if you had a high-quality pattern stored, the replicators themselves are built around that low quality, hence why the genitronic replicator was needed for Worf's spine [2]. Transporters are built on the same technology, but work at the much higher resolution necessary to break down/rebuild a person. However, the amount of memory needed for that is insane [3], hence the specially-designed pattern buffers, which under normal circumstances degrade very quickly [4]. [0] http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Cold_Fire_(episode) http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Cold_Fire_(episode) [1] http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/The_Enemy_(episode) http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/The_Enemy_(episode) [2] http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Ethics_(episode) http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Ethics_(episode) [3] http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Our_Man_Bashir_(episode) http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Our_Man_Bashir_(episode) [4] http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Relics_(episode) http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Relics_(episode)
- cfadvan 8y agoNot really, because “real” diamonds have very little intrinsic value. Now if we could cheaply manufacture Platinum, or your example of perfectly cooked food, your point would start to be relevant here. As it is, diamond is already a very artificial market.
- falcor84 8y ago>Not really, because “real” diamonds have very little intrinsic value Well, you're quite exaggerating here. Diamonds actually have some very useful physical properties, in particular regarding their hardness, thermal conductivity and optical properties. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Material_properties_of_diamond https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Material_properties_of_diamond
- brandonjm 8y ago> “real” diamonds have very little intrinsic value >> Diamonds actually have some very useful physical properties. Physical properties shared and almost always improved upon by their synthetic counterparts. Someone using diamonds exclusively for their optical properties or hardness would probably prefer a synthetic diamond due to the lack of impurities.
- cfadvan 8y agoThey do, but their ubiquity makes them cheap. Coal has useful properties, as does pig iron, but it’s only valuable in bulk. Think of diamond as “white coal” and you’re there.
- meric 8y agoA gift from your Ship’s captain - it won’t be of value to anyone else but has intrinsic value for you.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ISL 8y agoFurthermore, at room temperature, diamond is not forever. Graphite is. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allotropes_of_carbon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allotropes_of_carbon
- bmpafa 8y agoIf I ever decide to propose to someone, I'm citing you on this point.
- ta76567656 8y agoEnergy.
- xxxdarrenxxx 8y agoYou are biased indirectly towards labor. Let me give you a machine. Do you know the molecular makeup for mom's sphagetti. Do you know the design of a car, a microprocessor, a jumbojet. In such era there will be a polar shift with art, music, design degrees etc. being the prestige ones. Psychology potentially as disorders often have "abstract" cognitive "human" patterns at play heavily tied to primary emotions but moreso things like empathy, jealousy, shame, hope, pride etc. which are scientifically still somewhat magical, but can be very real roadblocks.
- martin1975 8y agoA knock-off will always be a knock-off because it lacks the authenticity mark of its creator ... in the case of diamonds, it's time. In the case of hackintoshes, it's Apple... Prada shoes, the seal of Mario Prada... etc.
- remarkEon 8y agoI think this theme was first explored in depth in Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep. Having a "real" animal was a status symbol.
- xamuel 8y agoSame author, earlier exploration: The Man in the High Castle (1962) explored it in the context of otherwise-identical objects, one of which was involved in some historic event, the other of which wasn't
- remarkEon 8y agoYou're right! I need to read that one again...
- KozmoNau7 8y agoWas this what they covered in the TV show with the fake antiques? They didn't dwell too much on it, I really should read the book.
- xamuel 8y agoIIRC in the TV show there's a scene where the Americana shopkeeper (Mr. Childan) shows someone two identical cigarette lighters, one of which was in the pocket of FDR when FDR was assassinated (Man in the High Castle takes place in an alternate timeline). In the novel, this is actually done by the owner of the fake-gun-factory, and it gets a longer treatment.
- KozmoNau7 8y agoI remember that scene. Now I have even more reason to read the book :)
- 52-6F-62 8y agoThis is the only version I've known— I haven't read the book. I highly recommend this story to anyone who's even slightly curious.
- stuntkite 8y agoStar Trek frequently discussed things being slightly off when replicated. Troy wanted "real" chocolate when in a seriously bad mood. Picard kept cases of real caviar for special occasions. I mean, it's a writing trope designed to point out that they are far away from home and play with the concept that scarcity creates value and thus is interesting to human(oid)s. The ideals of a moneyless society by virtue of just being in the freaking future in TOS and then later because of replicators in TNG and beyond had to be adapted for the multicultural bazaar on Deep Space Nine by introducing Gold Pressed Latinum. Something that replicators couldn't reproduce. I think that is an interesting thought experiment. The only currencies on a federation ship are friendship and duty, but once you add in a mix of cultures and the complexities that develop because of their clashing goals and desires, you need a scarce item to keep accounts. We've done it over and over throughout our human society. My favorite is the Rai Stones[1] from the island of Yap, where they can't even be moved for the most part. The transfer of ownership is purely a social construct. Diamonds are interesting and I think unparalleled in their arc as a store of value because of how technology is eroding and changing that. Not just the ability to produce them, but information technology swaying trends relating to their status and ethical usage. You can't tell a blood diamond from anything else once it's mixed with others. Some people see diamond jewelry to be akin to wearing fur. Some other people still find the suffering that came from their extraction to be part of the value. Not going to debate the morality of that issue, but I've heard it expressed more than once. Suffering will always be more bespoke even if the item can be identically reproduced. Some might prefer to soften "suffering" to "effort", but I'm unaware of an ethical diamond mining operation. Like lab grown meat, a strong case can me made that once we can make the thing in the lab at scale it is absolutely unethical to extract it from the earth at scale for vanity. No excuses. In some ways suffering as a store of value is sort of like the social construct of a rai that floats with the idea of the item. Maybe we can build a crypto supply chain technology to verify chain of custody on natural diamonds so you can correctly track the bodies on it and their value in relation to your net worth. I'm only sort of being glib here, making it an accurate record would undoubtedly make them less romantic prizes. Surely the tools and equipment to create synthetic diamonds will continue to drop in it's price to own and operate. It will be interesting to see how De Beers handles the first online custom gem shop where you can set your specs via your browser and have your gem grown to order, cut, and drop shipped for the price of a latte. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rai_stones https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rai_stones
- code777777 8y agoIs a vmotion'ed VM the same as the original one? Is it kind of like a transporter?
- swyx 8y agothe authentic story matters. http://sethgodin.typepad.com/seths_blog/2018/05/putting-a-value-on-a-story.html http://sethgodin.typepad.com/seths_blog/2018/05/putting-a-va...
- dreamfactored 8y agoIt's just the path to commodity that every product follows. That's inevitable with gems now that synthetic stones are equivalent, so the choice facing De Beers is to stick with expensive mined stones and die out while the market evolves, or to get a big chunk of the action. The only thing is that to pull it off they had better be ready to cannibalise the existing business and let it go. They need a very long term plan which doesn't always revolve around the next few quarters which might be a tough sell with shareholders.
- Tyr42 8y agoCompare synthetic vanilla flavouring vs plant based. Same molecule, but big price difference.
- wbeckler 8y agoFor most food uses, salt gets a similar treatment.
- ehsankia 8y agovinyl vs flac. film vs digital. Not quite 100% identical, but yeah.
- tpolzer 8y agoHave you ever compared Vanillin to real fresh Vanilla yourself? Yes, it replicates a large part of the flavor, but certainly not all of it.
- GordonS 8y agoSomething is different though - vanilla flavouring doesn't taste nearly as good as real vanilla. I guess the vanilla contains a spectrum of substance, whereas the flavouring only contains the main one?
- astura 8y agoYes Vanilla is actually vanilla - it's a complex substance. Artificial vanilla is just one component of vanilla - vanillin.
- KozmoNau7 8y ago>"If you can perfectly recreate something down to the molecular level, what actually has value?" The raw materials themselves, I think. After all, you have to supply the basic building blocks to replicate objects. That's why there is the feed in The Diamond Age, bringing the raw materials, plus vacuum and power. Until you can artificially create heavy elements, their rarity will determine their value. >"If you can replicate cooked food perfectly, will people still claim that "real" food, grown, slaughtered, and cooked, is "better" or tastes "more authentic", despite no technical difference?" Yes, absolutely. At least certain segments will, witness how people fawn over "artisanal craft" this-and-that. More effort goes into the production, so there is more of an emotional connection. The mass produced item could be superior to the hand crafted item, but the latter will feel more "real" to a lot of people. Even more so if they craft it themselves. It's just how we're wired, I think.
- gonvaled 8y ago> The raw materials themselves, I think. After all, you have to supply the basic building blocks to replicate objects. That's why there is the feed in The Diamond Age, bringing the raw materials, plus vacuum and power. In the True Synthetic Era, the only input needed is energy, which can be cheaply collected from natural sources until they are exhausted.
- KozmoNau7 8y agoThat is the ideal, but it will also require absolutely ridiculous amounts of energy to synthesize heavier elements.
- martin-adams 8y agoThe problem is that value for the unseeable differences is simply a human idea. Why would the paint arranged on a canvas by a famous artist have more value than the same paint arranged on the same canvas by myself? Value comes in the appreciation of the art. So diamonds that have been created over billions of years probably has more appreciation than ones created in 500 hours, even if they are exactly the same at the molecular level.
- sethgecko 8y agoThis video that was uploaded yesterday explains very well how humans inherently value scarcity, even from a very young age. It could be shells/weird looking stones/trading cards/gold/cryptocurrency. If it is rare humans will value it. If you could create diamonds at will in a lab the price of it's price is bound to go down significantly, it's not just a matter of supply and demand. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZKwqNgG-Sv4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZKwqNgG-Sv4
- DINKDINK 8y agoEpistemologically, it can never be proven that a clone perfectly replicates an original. It can only be proven that a clone perfectly replicates the original in the dimensions you’ve analyzed (inductive process). Exactly why a model will never replicate reality.
- ksherlock 8y agoThat question is active here, too; What color are your bits? (Those bits look evergreen to me.)
- acomar 8y ago> Interestingly enough, this starts to bring up questions that have previously only been super active in science fiction circles, particularly, Star Trek: If you can perfectly recreate something down to the molecular level, what actually has value? (Assuming, someday, that synthetic versions are excessively cheap, in Star Trek's case.) This is really getting at a core contradiction in how we analyze value. On the one hand, you have something's monetary value. This is the exchange value - the value you can get, denominated in a currency, via a sale. On the other hand, something you need has value because it fulfills a role when you use it. This is use value. We don't consider use value at all when talking about the value of a good and consider the exchange value to be paramount. But this makes no sense. When you're starving, a loaf of bread is quite literally worth your entire world. When you have plenty of food, one more loaf of bread is worth almost nothing at all. When you need to get around, one car is extremely useful. Hundreds of cars together are essentially worthless, except perhaps to rent to others (literally rent-seeking). If you can recreate something down to its molecular level, and produce arbitrarily many copies, then it's only value can be its use value. And use value is difficult to quantify as it's tied to the subjective experience of need. > If you can replicate cooked food perfectly, will people still claim that "real" food, grown, slaughtered, and cooked, is "better" or tastes "more authentic", despite no technical difference? I suspect that some amount of this comes from our attempts to justify the price we pay. It costs more, and so it must be worth more. We invent reasons in our minds to justify the dissonance. Though, if you experience something better, there isn't really any argument that can satisfactorily say that you don't, since experience is subjective, anyway.
- janekm 8y agoThe concept is literally as old as apple pie baked by grandma rather than in a factory.