4 ms·
That was an interesting way to kill a few minutes. My conclusion is that throughput is basically a function of space the intersection takes up. Also water is
by dsfyu404ed 8y ago
That was an interesting way to kill a few minutes.
My conclusion is that throughput is basically a function of space the intersection takes up. Also water is wet.
Sure given a fixed space you can optimize type to maximize throughput. If you really care about maximizing throughput with minimal complexity (the more rapid fire merges and lane changes you have the greater the chance of an accident that bottles up the whole system) big rotaries seem to be the way to go (above/below grade structures and traffic signals are a lot more expensive and cost more to maintain than some raised medians to divide right turn lanes).
- nostrademons 8y agoIn general, but there were some exceptions. The various roundabout solutions (rotaries, dumbbells, cloverleafs, etc.) seemed to punch under their size, while the continuous-flow intersection moved a lot of cars in a space not much larger than a traditional 4-way intersection. Also, the video showed how effective getting the signaling right can be: intersections with dedicated left turn lanes (with the TPME mod) outperformed stock traffic lights by almost 50%. The 4-lane road with dedicated left turn lane outperformed a 6-lane road without protected lefts.
- mjevans 8y agoMy own observations were that roundabouts tended to perform better than intersections with time division utilization and also didn't require any signaling infrastructure. Modifications to roundabouts that added dedicated bypass routes for higher traffic / shorter path (merge to closest output without being part of the main queue) were inexpensive upgrades. The same general observation also applied to higher scale variations where the core loop was either factored out entirely (every route has a dedicated path); applying more complexity (expensive) lead to better results. Of course the real world has different needs than this over-simplified simulation. Terrain and political situations impose limits on usable work area while use patterns can vary widely. Worse solutions that used to work in the past can be woefully incorrect as the world around them changes. The example that comes to my mind is the pattern in urban areas, especially like Seattle with heavy geographic constraints that make alternate routes untenable, where the old "most commuters go in to the city in the morning and leave in the evening" break entirely as jobs flee the expensive urban core and leave workers trying to traverse the choke points where cross traffic was never designed in.