3 ms·
Sane defaults, rather. It is annoying how stuff on Facebook is by default shared with "Public", how applications install malware/adware by default, any adverti
by Fnoord 8y ago
Sane defaults, rather.
It is annoying how stuff on Facebook is by default shared with "Public", how applications install malware/adware by default, any advertising-related opt-out.
Only positive thing I can say is "they're not the only ones". But that doesn't make it right (Whataboutism).
Sad truth is, the software developers or the companies hiring them get away with such immoral choices.
- SilasX 8y ago>It is annoying how stuff on Facebook is by default shared with "Public", It does? Mine currently defaults to "friends", and I'm pretty sure the default is just "whatever your last choice was" -- if I set my last one to public, then next time the default value is public.
- Fnoord 8y agoYes, that's the default when you start (which is bad). The default is furthermore like you said "whatever your last choice was". Which is bloody annoying. As if some terribly dumb AI is trying to understand what my motive is. If I always post for X, and then make an exception, then I don't want that exception again next time. Why would I? So if I always post "for friends", for example, and then one time I post "for family" then I don't want next time only "for family" but I want it to be what my default is: "for friends". Because my behavior is like that. At the very least I could receive some kind of feedback in the form of a confirmation (because it sees I'm deviating from my normal behavior). Its like if I go to the bakery and always buy hazelnut meringue but then one time I buy a cherry pie cause of some special occasion. I don't want them to assume that next week I'll again take a cherry pie. I want them to be like "oh its that fellow who basically always has hazelnut meringue". Sure, if I'm starting to buy cherry pies regularly it is a different story. But my usage pattern on posts on Facebook was pretty damn clear: 90-99% for friends, rest for family. Although, yeah, it usually bit me when I mistakenly posted on "friends" instead of "family" which the above example doesn't cover. Though I thankfully didn't use Facebook that much and not that I personally care specifically about Facebook anymore; I removed everything from my Facebook except my friend list, and I won't use it much anymore. I'm also really not sure if I'm alone on this issue or if people are generally annoyed by this behavior. I assumed the latter but your post suggests otherwise.
- SilasX 8y agoI think you're being too hard on FB for that. It's pretty common for UIs to be "sticky" in that sense, because, as a (pre-AI-hype) heuristic, it's generally accurate. If anything, the AI-driven UI is the one that would realize you probably don't want the cherry pie again.
- Fnoord 8y agoSticky just feels oddly underoptimized for such an AI-based platform. But lets imagine a different situation. Imagine this was a BB and I was an admin, and I was suddenly switching from the admin forum to a non-admin forum. I'd certainly wanna get that very clear to me, right? Perhaps not the best example though. Even if decision-based AI is not preferable they could also just after such a deviation instead of assuming one or the other use it to ask me. Like a heads up.
- stordoff 8y ago> The default is furthermore like you said "whatever your last choice was". Which is bloody annoying. As if some terribly dumb AI is trying to understand what my motive is. If I always post for X, and then make an exception, then I don't want that exception again next time. I'm not sure I agree - if I change a setting, I want it to _stay_ changed (and if it's a one-time change, it's easy enough to change back). Imagine approaching it from the other angle - it's easy to see the headlines "Facebook trying to revert your privacy settings" (especially I imagine more people will be making changes to be more restrictive--from whatever Facebook's defaults are to what they are comfortable with).
- Fnoord 8y ago> I'm not sure I agree - if I change a setting, I want it to _stay_ changed (and if it's a one-time change, it's easy enough to change back). Me [generally] too, but I don't post often, so say my last post was to family only, and then a week later I post and I don't check the setting. > it's easy to see the headlines "Facebook trying to revert your privacy settings" Fair enough, thanks for that angle. How about some feedback right after you selected that, that it became default, and that you can revert it? Or is my use-case really that specific? I don't know.