5 ms·
When I first created a Venmo account, I was shocked to see users' payments flowing through my feed and immediately found a way to make my payments private. But
by gnicholas 8y ago
When I first created a Venmo account, I was shocked to see users' payments flowing through my feed and immediately found a way to make my payments private.
But I could never find a way to effectively unlink the social media account (FB) that I had used to find my first friend/payee. I think I unlinked the account, but I still see payments from all the people that Venmo made me follow as a result of linking the now-unlinked FB account.
I haven't used the app in a long time, and I wonder if this mass-unfollow feature has been added. I know they think that people open Venmo to check their feed, but some people find the public feed creepy, and it makes me use the app less in favor of alternatives.
- strifey 8y agoI recently went through and unfollowed 100+ people because there's still no mass-unfollow feature :(
- dfee 8y agoI had no idea you could make your payments “private” by default. Indeed you can, and you can mark all past payments as private by going (on iOS) to: Settings -> Privacy -> Private and Settings -> Privacy -> Past Transactions -> Change All to Private I always had feared I’d forget to set my transactions as private.
- ilamont 8y agoI was also shocked, and immediately set it to private. I registered using an email address (as I do for practically every online service I use) so I don't have to deal with the Facebook dimension. However, for the handful of people I regularly send money to, I can see all of their transactions on the home screen, including business fees (which reveals the freelance rates they charge), family loans, etc. I take it they have not limited their transactions to "private". Regardless, I am amazed that Venmo/PayPal thought sharing payment activity would be a good idea.
- yaur 8y agoIf it is not private it's a valid thing to use for ad targeting.
- rconti 8y agoI'm utterly perplexed that Venmo is even a thing. When I first started hearing about it maybe 5-6 years ago, I just figured, I already have PayPal and Square Cash, I'm too old, nobody I know uses Venmo, why bother. I've mostly ignored that it existed except occasionally hearing (usually younger) folks talking about it. A couple of months ago I was telling some people at work that I'm too old for it, and Square Cash works well enough for me, and commented that I can't see how a newcomer could be any easier than just having the money go directly into my bank account. When a coworker informed me that Venmo payments stay in your account, my exasperated reply was "wait, it's WORSE than Square Cash? It's like going back to PayPal?" Well, you can imagine how incredulous I was when I found out that Venmo IS PayPal, just with different branding. For the past 5 years I've been assuming Venmo is something new and cool that "the kids" are using, but I'm too out of touch to bother, and suddenly I find out it's a rebranding of PayPal with all of the drawbacks of it. It blows my mind that something caught traction that is functionally worse than the competitor of the product it's a rebranding of!
- triangleman 8y agoWell it's PayPal without the fees.
- rconti 8y ago"Friends and Family" payments are also without fees. I can't think of any fees I've ever paid to PayPal other than for eBay transactions and the like -- though it's of course possible Venmo has different rate structures and thresholds.
- thirduncle 8y agoIs it? My understanding is that (other than the brand and parent ownership) as services they're quite different.
- rconti 8y agoMaybe from a UI standpoint, but all of the competitors are pretty similar. Minus network effect, of course. Nobody in my network uses Venmo, for example, but apparently I'm an outlier. With all of them, you can find a way to use it for free. Eg, if the service you use doesn't support free bank transfers, you link it with a debit card for free transfers. https://www.digitaltrends.com/mobile/paypal-vs-google-wallet-vs-venmo-vs-square-cash/ https://www.digitaltrends.com/mobile/paypal-vs-google-wallet...