3 ms·
Exactly, innovation happens in this space because high investment is protected by patents and licenses. If patents were the only thing promoting innovation, th
by mindcrime 8y ago
Exactly, innovation happens in this space because high investment is protected by patents and licenses.
If patents were the only thing promoting innovation, then nothing would have been invented before patents became available. We already know that isn't the case, so your argument that innovation is a direct result of patents is a bit questionable. OTOH, one could argue (without or without patents) that part of the impetus to innovate (for a company/firm) is "innovate or die". Eg, if your competitors are coming out with newer, better "things" and you aren't, then you are going to die. Or perhaps be reduced to the role of creating cheap knock-offs of inventions created by others, but "fast follower" strategy aside, being the knock-off vendor is usually not the desirable position in the race.
Not true, There is plenty of tech companies that create technology but do not manufacture. ARM Holding would be an excellent example. There is also plenty of companies that manufacture but do not design.
That's nothing about copy-catting though. That's talking about licensing / subcontracting just because a company doesn't want to do it's own fab work. That's totally reasonable, but it's a choice. In either case, original inventors OR licensed manufacturers, are going to have an advantage over copy-cats because they know the "thing" better.
Patent laws include expiring period. This period is designed to make R&D profitable but keep pressure for innovation.
Sure, and I'm saying that doing the equivalent of reducing that time to zero will do the most to create pressure for innovation.
Never mind all the problems with overly broad patents, fear of submarine patents, etc., and all the ways patents inhibit, rather than promote, innovation.
- Chyzwar 8y agoIt literally cost billions to make any innovation in silicon, pharmaceutics, automotive etc. > That's nothing about copy-catting though. That's talking about licensing / subcontracting just because a company doesn't want to do it's own fab work. That's totally reasonable, but it's a choice. In either case, original inventors OR licensed manufacturers, are going to have an advantage over copy-cats because they know the "thing" better. Licensing only work because you hold patents. Patents are what prevents others from copying ARM ISA. Companies can specialize in what they do best. > Never mind all the problems with overly broad patents, fear of submarine patents, etc., and all the ways patents inhibit, rather than promote, innovation. Patents can be easily invalidated if there is prior art. Patents are not what slows down innovation. Cost of human labor is the most important factor for innovation.