7 ms·
There's going to be a tipping point in the near future. When autonomous vehicles reach a big enough share of miles driven, there's going to be a snowball effect
by tootie 8y ago
There's going to be a tipping point in the near future. When autonomous vehicles reach a big enough share of miles driven, there's going to be a snowball effect. All of our roads and infrastructure are built for human drivers. Robot-only roads could far cheaper and more efficient. No more signs or lights. No more lanes. Not even partitions. You can dynamically adjust your 8-lane freeway to be 6 lanes one way and 2 the other and flip it morning and evening.
Once the tech is proven and accepted by enough people, it will become mandatory and we're going to rebuild everything with a much smaller footprint.
- mromanuk 8y agoAs a foreigner to the US, when I was visiting Burlington, MA. I found really odd that there was almost no sidewalks, so it was really difficult to walk by, everything was built for traveling by car from place to place (Which is not the case in the cities, That's the pattern in the suburbs) Following your thoughts, this patterns will extend and multiply, probably became even more hostile for pedestrians in some places.
- maxxxxx 8y agoI am worried about that too. Right now the biggest challenge for autonomous cars is to recognize obstacles like pedestrians. I wouldn't be too surprised if we would end up with a situation where it's up to the pedestrian to get out of the way of autonomous vehicles because they have always right of way.
- xapata 8y agoI hope the opposite. When humans don't drive, they won't mind the car taking an extra minute to drive around the other side of the building. There'll be more opportunity for pedestrian-only streets.
- rayiner 8y ago> There's going to be a tipping point in the near future. I'm not holding my breath. I grew up hearing people talk about how we would have Mars colonies by now. Imagine my surprise a couple of decades later when the shuttle program ended and the U.S. lost the ability to send people into space for a time. The way I see it, the clock is ticking. If self-driving cars don't reach a certain level of capability soon, I suspect they simply won't; the technology will have plateaued at a point where it will not be viable in the foreseeable future. It'll be like supersonic flight: full of promise in the 1960s and 1970s, but mothballed for decades after that waiting for some engineering breakthrough to make it commercially viable.
- czechdeveloper 8y agoI'm glad to see I'm not only one very conservative about real technology progress. I'd love to see star-trek future, but I just do not believe in it anymore.
- mdrzn 8y agoNever forget that you're on the Internet, using probably a device that 20 years ago would have been sci-fi, complaining that the future may not come fast enough.
- fullshark 8y agoI think the lesson is that we are terrible at predicting the future, not so much that technological progress doesn't exist.
- mistermann 8y agoSome technologies can't be derailed by human stupidity and selfishness, I'm not so sure driverless cars qualify as one of them.
- pjc50 8y ago20 years ago I was arguing with strangers on the internet over a dial-up modem. It's not so very different. Moore's law hs been quite magical but the real changes have been qualitative, like smartphones.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 8y agoIt was sci fi 50 years ago. By the time of the Newton (25 years ago) and iPhone was a predictable evolution of existing technology. So was the Star Trek voice command interface. The question is: are self deiving cars iPhones (where the technological curve played out as expected) or voice recognition (which never really got as good as people expected it would be).
- sandworm101 8y ago>> No more signs or lights. No more lanes. Not even partitions. You can dynamically adjust your 8-lane freeway to be 6 lanes one way and 2 the other and flip it morning and evening. Trains. Such concepts have been around for a long while in rail travel. Implementations never go smoothly. The reality of automating fast moving boxes full of living people are stark. Even where trains are driverless, with extensive signalling and redundant navigation systems, they don't get closer/faster than human operated trains. As systems grow more complex, to the point that failures are a regular occurrence, the dream of hyper-efficient automated travel disappears.
- mijamo 8y agoActually driverless trains DO get closer and faster. This is why some lines have been automated in Paris for instance, after manual driving reached the limit.
- sandworm101 8y agoSubways in some cities (I'm in Vancouver) do some of this. But they are low speed and are on dedicated track. Trains hauling freight and people between cities have to share track with other types of trains, on irregular schedules. That's what an automated road would look like: not one team of cars but a random collection of vehicles that must somehow share the same infrastructure. The number of vehicles per mile of track would also be exponentially higher than any subway system. Automated train systems are still monitored by humans. When things go wrong humans make the little changes to keep the system going. The computer doesn't decide whether to offload the passengers if a train is stuck, or make them wait for some other humans to fix the train. A team of humans can do this for a subway system with a few hundred cars on a dozen lines, but a few thousand cars on many hundreds of roads is another matter.
- relaxy 8y agoYou can not compare the times back then with what's happening now. Alot of things have changed. We are living in the information age, the science and knowledge growth is exponentional.
- seiferteric 8y agoMore like a sigmoid function.
- LastMuel 8y agoI have a slightly different take on what will drive adoption of these cars. Insurance. If there is a significant reduction of cost from an insurance perspective, the cost to insure a human-driven vehicle will increase substantially to the point that it will become a burden to own a vehicle that isn't driven by software. That is, unless the government feels the need to intervene here. But, business seems to have the ear of government a lot more than the citizens do now days.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoOr the cost will decrease because those who elect to drive when doing so is optional are statistically less likely to drive distracted or drunk.
- skywhopper 8y ago"Once the tech is proven" is the big caveat. This all is a fun thought experiment, but we are nowhere close to the future where this tech is reliable enough to fulfill all of these functions in an economically beneficial way. These companies exist because the VCs have money to burn, and self-driving [X] is the hot trend of the day, but for all the dreams to pay off the tech has to prove out, and I see no evidence in this article that these companies are any closer to solving the real problems of confronting real-world real-weather real-roads autonomous vehicles than anyone else. Not to mention the additional gaps in service. These robot cars can't bring my deliveries to my doorstep; they can't improvise when mapping data is outdated or invalid; they can't understand or react when the product they deliver is damaged or wrong. The only tipping point we're nearing is when people finally realize that 80% of a self-driving car may as well be zero percent, that the last 20% is way more complicated than anyone wants to admit, and that even to they extent they ever "work", flooding our streets with robot cars is not the ticket to utopia.
- iambateman 8y agoNo doubt the problems are difficult and time consuming. Self-driving vehicles is the culmination of thousands of technologies coming together. It’s complicated. And while it may take longer than everyone expects, the demand for a self-driven car is not coming from VC money. People, for the most part, would trade driving for the convenience of doing something else. I think the force of demand will bring about the technology, sooner or later. It’s difficult technology, but most people don’t think it’s impossible.
- simonh 8y agoI am absolutely with you on replacing family cars. The last 100m problem is really hard and isn’t going to get solved for many real world scenarios any time soon. However there are a huge range of driving situations in which the last 100m can be designed around self driving vehicles. Many trucking and general pickup/delivery end points could be designed this way. Even many taxi style services could use this approach, with designated parking points for self driving buses and cabs. So I can see near future self driving tech accounting for a significant fraction of road traffic over the next decade, given that it will take time to develop the infrastructure to match.
- bitL 8y agoThat's likely going to happen in some underdeveloped country with a government willing to take risks, not in developed, heavily regulated ones. And globalization might prevent it even there; something about Tower of Babel and all nations cloning the same thing that doesn't work well comes to mind. We probably need diverse cultures more than global ones for the sake of progress and original solutions, i.e. optimization exploring different local optima instead. I think China was experimenting by marking whole regions as following a certain development philosophy, i.e. this part behaves like Germany, that one like Russia, another one as UK etc.
- nkoren 8y ago(Adapted from a deeply-nested too-late-to-notice reply I made on another thread[1], but which I suspect more people would benefit from seeing) I am skeptical that AIs capable of piloting fully driverless cars are coming in the next few years. In the longer term, I'm more optimistic. There are definitely some fundamental breakthroughs which are needed (with regards to causal reasoning etc.) before "full autonomy" can happen -- but a lot of money and creativity is being thrown at these problems, and although none of us will know how hard the Hard problem is until after it's been solved, my hunch is that it will yield within this generation. But I think that framing this as an AI problem is not really correct in the first place. Currently car accidents kill about 1.3 million people per year. Given current driving standards, a lot of these fatalities are "inevitable". For example: many real-world car-based trolley problems involve driving around a blind curve too fast to react to what's on the other side. You suddenly encounter an array of obstacles: which one do you choose to hit? Or do you (in some cases) minimise global harm by driving yourself off the road? Faced with these kind of choices, people say "oh, that's easy -- you can instruct autonomous cars to not drive around blind curves faster than they can react". But in that case, the autonomous car just goes from being the thing that does the hitting to the thing that gets hit (by a human). Either way, people gonna die -- not due to a specific fault in how individual vehicles are controlled, but due to collective flaws in the entire premise of automotive infrastructure. So the problem is that no matter how good the AIs get, as long as they have to interact with humans in any way, they're still going to kill a fair number of people. I sympathise quite a lot with Musk's utilitarian point of view: if AIs are merely better humans, then it shouldn't matter that they still kill a lot of people; the fact that they kill meaningfully fewer people ought to be good enough to prefer them. If this is the basis for fostering a "climate of acceptance" then I don't think it would be a bad thing at all. But I don't expect social or legal systems to adopt a pragmatic utilitarian ethos anytime soon! One barrier it that even apart from the sensational aspect of autonomous-vehicle accidents, it's possible to do so much critiquing of them. When a human driver encounters a real-world trolley problem, they generally freeze up, overcorrect, or do something else that doesn't involve much careful calculation. So shit happens, some poor SOB is liable for it, and there's no black-box to audit. In contrast, when an autonomous vehicle kills someone, there will be a cool, calculated, auditable trail of decision-making which led to that outcome. The impulse to second-guess the AV's reasoning -- by regulators, lawyers, politicians, and competitors -- will be irresistible. To the extent that this fosters actual safety improvements, it's certainly a good thing. But it can be really hard to make even honest critiques of these things, because any suggested change needs to be tested against a near-infinite number of scenarios -- and in any case, not all of the critiques will be honest. This will be a huge barrier to adoption. Another barrier is that people's attitudes towards AVs can change how safe they are. Tesla has real data showing that Autopilot makes driving significantly safer. This data isn't wrong. The problem is that this was from a time when Autopilot was being used by people who were relatively uncomfortable with it. This meant that it was being used correctly -- as a second pair of eyes, augmenting those of the driver. That's fine: it's analogous to an aircraft Autopilot when used like that. But the more comfortable people become with Autopilot -- to the point where they start taking naps or climbing into the back seat -- the less safe it becomes. This is the bane of Level 2 and 3 automation: a feedback loop where increasing AV safety/reliability leads to decreasing human attentiveness, leading (perhaps) to a paradoxical overall decrease in safety and reliability. Even Level 4 and 5 automation isn't immune from this kind of feedback loop. It's just externalised: drivers in Mountain View learned that they could drive more aggressively around the Google AVs, which would always give way to avoid a collision. So safer AI driving has led to more dangerous human driving. So my contention is that while the the AVs may become "good enough" anytime between, say, now and 20 years from now -- the above sort of problems will be persistent barriers to adoption. These problems can be boiled down to a single word: humans. As long as AVs share a (high-speed) domain with humans, there will be a lot of fatalities, and the AVs will take the blame for this (since humans aren't black-boxed). Nonetheless, I think we will see AVs become very prominent. Here's how: 1. Initially, small networks of low-speed (~12mph) Level-4 AVs operating in mixed environments, generally restricted to campus environments, pedestrianised town centres, etc. At that speed, it's possible to operate safely around humans even with reasonably stupid AIs. Think Easymile, 2getthere, and others. 2. These networks will become joined-up by fully-segregated higher-speed AV-only right-of-ways, either on existing motorways or in new types of infrastructure (think the Boring Company). 3. As these AVs take a greater mode-share, cities will incrementally convert roads into either mixed low-speed or exclusive high-speed. Development patterns will adapt accordingly. It will be a slow process, but after (say) 40-50 years, the cities will be more or less fully autonomous (with most of the streets being low-speed and heavily shared with pedestrians and bicyclists). Note that this scenario is largely insensitive to AI advances, because the real problem that needs to be solved is at the point of human interface. 1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17170739 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17170739
- EliRivers 8y agoDystopian flipside; it then becomes impossible to use the roads (and thus, travel other than by foot, struggling through unmaintained footpaths and dirt trails; many places simply impossible to get to on foot) for anything not approved by society. Your insurance company gets a say in where you go to eat. Google and chums get a say in where you go to shop. You pay extra to get to your destination sooner. You ask to go to one bar but get dropped off at another; one that paid to have you delivered there. I wonder which of these will come true. Some of them, in part, I'm fairly confident of.