3 ms·
So how exactly it's O.K. for customers if their privacy is breached by mom&pop businesses but not O.K. if it's breached by businesses that have 50K or more user
by mrtksn 8y ago
So how exactly it's O.K. for customers if their privacy is breached by mom&pop businesses but not O.K. if it's breached by businesses that have 50K or more users?
It's common theme here on HN to think that users are just some kind of resource and the regulations are anti-climactic things that slows down the party.
Seriosly, As a user, I don't want my information to be sold to random people that I have no information about even if the seller is a tiny business because my feelings are not against the business but against the practice. The size of the violator is irrelevant to me.
If not breaching my privacy and my rights makes your business unprofitable, then simply you don't have a business.
Users are people, not just pageviews or hits or goals - despite what your analytcs software says.
- JamesBarney 8y agoIf you die in a fire or building collapse it's equally bad whether that building was a large commerical building or a single family. But we have two sets of building code rules because the regulatory burden is very different. The cost of complying with lots of regulation are fixed, and don't necessarily scale linearly with the size of the company. So to prevent these laws from wiping out small businesses they usually phase on these rules with increasing size.
- organsnyder 8y agoWhich locality are you talking about? Building codes vary quite a bit from one region to another. I'm pretty sure my municipality (Grand Rapids, MI, US) does not have differing commercial building codes based on the size of the organization utilizing the space.
- JamesBarney 8y agoNot the size of the organization using the building but the size of the building.
- JamesBarney 8y agoI wrote organization but I meant to write building
- rdlecler1 8y agoFalse equivalency.
- JamesBarney 8y agoExplaining why it's a false equivalency would be more helpful and create better discussion.
- Matticus_Rex 8y ago>If not breaching my privacy and my rights You can respect everyone's rights and privacy and still be noncompliant, because most of the work of complying with the GDPR for most businesses is in the documentation, customer misinformation, and legal CYA work.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> So how exactly it's O.K. for customers if their privacy is breached by mom&pop businesses but not O.K. if it's breached by businesses that have 50K or more users? One of these has systemic effects, the other does not. (I don't think small businesses should be totally unregulated. But the administrative burden should be considered, to prevent discouraging new entrants and promoting incumbency bias. GDPR does not take this into account.)
- kazinator 8y agoWould you say shoplifting is okay, too? Damn it, the law shouldn't apply all the way down to individuals, over trifling matters and quantities! If you're harmed by a privacy leak, do you care whether that was perpetrated by a site that has 50 users, or 500,000? Oh, it was a small mom and pop site that passed on your personal info, so that made it okay; sorry! Next time, only deal with a big time operator.
- mrtksn 8y agoThis argument is disturbing for two reasons 1) You claim that GDPR has a big administrative burden to small businesses but that's not the case as long as your business model is not based on invasion of privacy. If it is, well, tough life! 2) It devalues the individual, it's ridiculous. Small restaurants need to follow hygiene standards just as the big chains, despite the fact that your local burger shop won't cause health problems on the same scale of McDonald's. Do you know why? Because individuals matter too. Can't be bothered to clean your kitchen? Don't run a restaurant. Can't be bothered to take care of your visitor's data? Don't run an online business. The society or any individual doesn't owe you a profit or a business.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> You claim that GDPR has a big administrative burden to small businesses but that's not the case as long as your business model is not based on invasion of privacy Have you ever dealt with a regulatory enquiry? Even if you have done nothing wrong, they are harrowing, time-consuming and--occasionally--costly. > Small restaurants need to follow hygiene standards just as the big chains Look at the food codes in most large cities. Multi-location chains have stricter standards than single-venue restaurants. This is because (a) multi-location complexity introduces new vectors for harm (and lets it scale faster) and (b) people are willing to accept greater risks from small purveyors.
- ascar 8y agoIt's not just small businesses. The serious effort to fullfil this legislation and the constant threat that you still don't is simply too much for small non-profit organizations and personal websites. A lot of one person blogs that are inactive but a valueable source of information have been taken down because of that. I also stopped hosting demos of my side-projects (just for github or cv links), because following this law for this kind of service is just unreasonable. And I do not even have to cause any kind of harm to be fineable in Germany.
- dorfcakeling 8y agoIf your demos required storing or using someone else's personal information, taking them down was the right thing to do (assuming you weren't going to put effort in to become compliant). If they didn't, you panicked and took down potentially valuable data of your own volition.
- ascar 8y agoJust adding a legally correct data protection and privacy policy is often too much of a burden. Even for otherwise fully GDPR compliant websites. Especially as I can not be sure if it is legally correct without consulting a lawyer (that's one of the big pain points for non-profit and private websites). One of my demos required multiple roles for the service and hence had authorization and authentication build in. I.e. it was storing email addresses (though I happily handed out prepared near full-admin accounts to everyone interested). It was on a subdomain with robots.txt set to disallow, so very little chance someone would find it by accident. Still making this GDPR compliant without consulting a lawyer was too much effort and risk for me. I'm not even sure without consulting a lawyer, if a fully static pure html website would be DSGVO (the German GDPR) compliant without adding a privacy policy to it. After all I could still be tracking users by HTTP/TCP/cookies and would have to inform the visitor, if I do or don't.
- gcthomas 8y agoThe Information Commissioner's Office (the regulatory body in the UK) says: Who needs to document their processing activities? There is a limited exemption for small and medium-sized organisations. If you have fewer than 250 employees, you only need to document processing activities that: are not occasional; or could result in a risk to the rights and freedoms of individuals; or involve the processing of special categories of data or criminal conviction and offence data. GDPR is designed to be easy for small organisations to adhere to. No documentation needed if you have only small, non-sensitive data flows. IANOL, of course.
- iaml 8y agoFor me, main problem is not the compliance itself, but the legal part of it. If GDPR had clearly stated it ok to dismiss all these "nightmare letters" unless they come a set of official emails that handle it, and if/when such official letters come it would only be required from me to point to my legal pages and/or give access to the code/db to show I'm compliant, it would all be a-okay.
- rdlecler1 8y agoOkay, so add one more caveat—the business has more than 50,000 users OR it sells your data. Perhaps the vast majority of businesses affected by GDPR are not selling your data.