13 ms·
Facebook photo-scanning lawsuit could cost it billions
- mtgx 8y agoFacebook has a very Uber-like mentality in regards to breaking the laws to make a profit. In the EU it was opting people in by default for its automatic facial recognition feature only weeks before the GDPR.
- a_imho 8y agoI still can't decide whether FB (and others) think they can get away with being non compliant or just accepted violating GDPR is the cost of doing business.
- cromwellian 8y agoIs running a photo hosting service a violation of GDPR itself? That is, if I take a photo of someone else (not myself) and upload it without consent of that person to AcmePhoto.com, and AcmePhoto.com now has personal information stored about someone without their consent, is the site liable? Do I need to get the consent of every person of every photo I upload? Where do you draw the line? If the site processes the EXIF metadata are they in violation? If they use a neutral clustering algorithm to group visually similar images, are they in violation (be it humans, cars, or chairs)? if I take a visually clustered group of images and tagthem "a_imho", have I now made the site have biometric data related to you? I mean, a lot of people say "well, as long as you're in the spirit of the GDPR, don't worry", but lawyers don't care whether you're in the spirit of something, they only care if they can win a case, and when the law is vague, "spirit" seems like one judge could hang you, and another judge could free you depending on the luck of the draw.
- weinzierl 8y ago> if I take a photo of someone else (not myself) This is were you draw the line. Taking pictures of people without their consent (and a good reason) is a big no-no in most parts of the world. This is either because it's not considered appropriate or because it's condemnable [1] or both. It is also nothing new and not some effect of GDPR, but deeply rooted in culture. Germany, Austria, Switzerland, Italy long had strong laws regarding the right of persons to their own likeness. There is also a big rift, not only legally but primarily culturally, between Anglo-Saxon culture and mostly the rest of the world. GDPR and other laws concerning informational self-determination[2] never can be interpreted without context. They are always limited by other rights and freedoms, like the right of artistic freedom. So a lot depends on your intent and if you can justify what you do. I'm not saying this is all well and good. As kind of a street photographer wannabe I'm very sympathetic to the position that the UK and the USA take on this. I'm just saying that the rest of the world has very different ideas about this and this has consequences if you operate globally. [1] https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Commons:Country_specific_consent_requirements https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Commons:Country_specific_... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Informational_self-determination https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Informational_self-determinati...
- c12 8y agoThe link you referenced counters your point that its a big no-no in most parts of the world to take a photo of someone without their consent. In the majority of the countries listed on that wiki page no consent is required with certain exceptions. I'd personally say taking pictures of people without their consent is a big no-no in some parts of the world, but not all. I have never personally had any issues with my street photography in the UK, it boils down to being respectful and not behaving in a harassing manor. If there is a reasonable expectation of privacy then one should consider taking an unsolicited photo as an invasion of privacy.
- friendzis 8y agoAS far as I can tell, the law usually permits public photography simply because it is quite difficult to tell whether you are searching for a frame, using wide or zoom lens, etc.. So the "take photo" as in "press the shutter button" action is probably legal in most parts of the world, as you say. One will face consequences when they publish photos or transfer them to third party - more or less self incriminate.
- weinzierl 8y ago> The link you referenced counters your point that its a big no-no in most parts of the world to take a photo of someone without their consent. In the majority of the countries listed on that wiki page no consent is required with certain exceptions. I added the reference to the list as support for my thesis that it can have legal consequences, a fact that in my experience people from the USA or the UK are often oblivious about. Just because it is not forbidden doesn't mean it is acceptable though. I think it is no coincidence that we see strictest regulation in central Europe because these countries are around the border line between the different attitudes. Go farther east and there is no need to regulate the culturally obvious. > I have never personally had any issues with my street photography in the UK, Of course not, UK is one of the best countries for shooting street. > it boils down to being respectful and not behaving in a harassing manor. If there is a reasonable expectation of privacy then one should consider taking an unsolicited photo as an invasion of privacy. Absolutely.
- Grangar 8y agoA photo itself is not a violation. An identifying photo on the other hand could be.
- cromwellian 8y agoBut that's the rub. The system doesn't identify the photo, the user does. Imagine a photo service with Gmail-like filters, and I create a filter which says "If Photo Longitude/Latitude within this bounds, then photo is #GrangarsHouse". I've now turned a system with a general purpose EXIF metadata filter function into a system which can categorize locations that identify people's dwellings with high probability. "Identifying" a purpose could range from simply clustering visually similar photos using any number of non-machine-learning, non-biometrically-aware image processing algorithms, to using DNNs like FaceNet, or using the old eigenvector facial recognition algorithms of the 90s. As soon as I upload a photo I took of you to a photo hosting system that has any kind of search functionality at all, the risk is raised that you can be categorized and identified somehow. Really, "consent" was broken not by the company, but by the uploader. I really think the genie's out of the bottle on photos now. So many people are constantly photographing on their phones, and so many are uploading them to publicly accessible feeds all over the internet, that a federated crawler could already be built to track you, in fact, I think there's already some social media monitoring services that offer this. If you're out in public, you should pretty much assume you have no privacy with regards to your imagery, GDPR isn't gonna save you. You can control your own photos, but you can't control what other people do of photos taken of you.
- ghaff 8y agoI see people on this thread suggesting that it's the culture in many countries in continental Europe, for example, against having identifiable photos of them posted without permission. I'd suggest that there are probably billions of such photos online on Facebook, Flickr, and countless news sites, blogs, etc. I know I've posted plenty of them even just myself. I suppose you can object and campaign for the EU to setup its own Great Firewall or something along those lines and only allow companies to operate within its borders which adhere to stringent rules around posted imagery. Good luck with that.
- menacingly 8y agoI strongly agree with the "spirit" thing. I guess the "relax, bro, as long as you're thinking good thoughts you have nothing to worry about" crowd have all recently awoken from 60-year comas.
- fiblye 8y ago>I still can't decide whether FB (and others) think they can get away with being non compliant There's zero precedent to suggest that they won't get away with it. All Facebook has to do is go undercover with their data collection and hope that it's never revealed that they're still doing it, or when it does leak, they pay some fine equivalent to half a percent of 3 minutes' profits.
- bigbugbag 8y agoRGPD has a max fine of 4% of world revenue exactly because the previous maximum fine was a joke to google and facebook who just paid and went about their day. How yould facebook go undercover with their data collection ? every thing they do is provide an infrastructure for data collection.
- fiblye 8y agoFacebook will keep collecting data for organizations like the NSA and it's silly to think that they wouldn't. At best, they won't be sharing data or storing it in the EU. Most likely, they'll be gathering and sharing data with EU governments for surveillance purposes but not for public organizations. And really, my concern is more with governments building digital profiles of everyone rather than advertisers. Give it a couple years and there'll likely be a leak revealing that nothing has significantly affected the main meat of the mega corps' data gathering, someone will say "mistakes were made but we're looking into it", a year later some investigators will say that they can't really do anything because it's technically outside the scope of the law, and it'll vanish until another leak happens the next year.
- frockington 8y agoAnd who is going to enforce they pay that? If the EU tries to flex its muscles FB could just pull out. And highly doubt the EU is going to do anything controversial in the near future with the Union begining to fragment
- s73v3r_ 8y ago"And who is going to enforce they pay that?" The EU. Remember, Facebook is an Irish company, headquartered in Dublin.
- chinathrow 8y agoI agree. At this point, FB and others are just to big to be able to subject them to policy. Even how they handled the GDPR just right before May 25 is a joke. They have billions of cash on hand to fight all the lawsuits whicht might come. Nothing will change :(
- kinsomo 8y ago> I agree. At this point, FB and others are just to big to be able to subject them to policy. Even how they handled the GDPR just right before May 25 is a joke. They have billions of cash on hand to fight all the lawsuits whicht might come. I don't think we're quite to the dystopian vision of international megacorps being totally above the law, yet. No matter how much cash Facebook has to fight lawsuits, the government has more and actually makes the laws to boot. Facebook is also clearly a non-essential service, if it was run out of business, most people who don't have the last name of Zuckerberg would adapt and get over it in a couple of months.
- thinkcomp 8y agoHere's the docket: https://www.plainsite.org/dockets/2mwpixhn9/california-northern-district-court/patel-v-facebook-inc/ https://www.plainsite.org/dockets/2mwpixhn9/california-north...
- thinkcomp 8y agoHaving read through the latest filings, it looks like the District Court judge is pretty upset with Facebook and its tactics, and was willing to give no leeway to their request to stay the case as a result. He wanted a trial, and soon. One of the tactics that they used was going over his head to the Ninth Circuit to request a stay at the district level (https://www.plainsite.org/dockets/download.html?id=253527059&z=c4b1abb5 https://www.plainsite.org/dockets/download.html?id=253527059...), which the Ninth Circuit then granted (https://www.plainsite.org/dockets/download.html?id=253580963&z=36003e60 https://www.plainsite.org/dockets/download.html?id=253580963...). So then the district court judge had to effectively grant the stay anyhow, which he had just denied: "ORDER. In light of the circuit court's order, all remaining pre-trial and trial dates are vacated. Signed by Judge James Donato on 5/29/2018. (This is a text-only entry generated by the court. There is no document associated with this entry.) (jdlc3S, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 5/29/2018)" This is what having infinite cash buys you in the American legal system.
- jhall1468 8y agoAppealing to a higher court is literally how the system is intended to work and gas absolutely nothing to do with infinite money. The Judge ruled and the 9th overturned him. That means the system is working.
- IBM 8y agoNYT had a nice profile of one of the lawyers a few years ago [1]. It had this quote from Sam Altman: >Asked to sum up the tech community’s feelings about Mr. Edelson, Sam Altman, president of Y Combinator, a technology incubator that invests in very young companies, said the lawyer was regarded as “a leech tarted up as a freedom fighter.” He's the American Max Schrems. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/05/technology/unpopular-in-silicon-valley.html https://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/05/technology/unpopular-in-s...
- Overtonwindow 8y agoSounds like he’s affective and doing good work.
- tqi 8y ago*effective
- Overtonwindow 8y agoQuite right, thank you
- ginko 8y agoAre you implying Max Schrems is a leech?
- IBM 8y agoNope.
- vageli 8y agoIt's weird that they even included that quote where they did. It seems out of context given its pejorative connotation.
- egypturnash 8y agoThere is no part of this headline that does not make me happy. <3
- merrywhether 8y agoHow could Facebook ever lose this case in a country where Equifax faced no punishment? Regardless of what you think about Facebook, DeepFace is seemingly mostly theoretical harm whereas Equifax definitely provably harmed people’s privacy and then (initially) charged those same people to help them protect themselves (via credit freezes). Not saying I don’t want Facebook held to the law, just thought of the comparison.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> How could Facebook ever lose this case in a country where Equifax faced no punishment? The case hinges on a particularly strict Illinois biometric privacy law.
- faitswulff 8y agoThis is the same reason Google's Arts & Culture face-matching tool wasn't available in Illinois: http://abc7chicago.com/technology/why-googles-face-match-feature-doesnt-work-in-illinois/2959613/ http://abc7chicago.com/technology/why-googles-face-match-fea...
- toomuchtodo 8y agoAlso why Nest IQ (which uses biometric face detection) isn't available in Illinois.
- yojex 8y agoDoes anybody know if this affects the iPhone's Face ID in any way?
- toomuchtodo 8y agoIt supposedly does not, as the data is kept on the phone and Apple does not take possession of the data.
- 8y ago
- mehrdadn 8y ago> Donato previously rejected Facebook’s argument that the case had to be dismissed because the attempt to enforce Illinois law runs afoul of its user agreement that requires disputes to be resolved under the laws of California, where it’s based. Could someone please elaborate on this? I feel like I've seen clauses like this all over the place. Are they really unenforceable? What is the judge's reasoning?
- Sacho 8y agoIANAL, but his reasoning would probably be in the summary judgement denial that's on the docket: ORDER re Summary Judgment Motions ([257], [299], [307]). Signed by Judge James Donato on 5/14/2018. (jdlc3S, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 5/14/2018) Unfortunately, I don't really have access to PACER or money to gamble on opening random documents to see which one has the actual info. The US "public access to court electronic records" isn't very "public"-friendly. (docket listing kindly provided by user thinkcomp - https://www.plainsite.org/dockets/2mwpixhn9/california-northern-district-court/patel-v-facebook-inc/ https://www.plainsite.org/dockets/2mwpixhn9/california-north...)
- checkyoursudo 8y agoI haven't had to deal with choice of law stuff in maybe 15 years, but basically it's that choice of law clauses are not the equivalent of get-out-of-Illinois-free cards. Just because you want some place to have jurisdiction doesn't mean that any other jurisdiction is required to comply automatically. Choice of law ... law is not always straight forward. You shouldn't rely on it as any sort of guarantee that you'll get to be haled into court only on your home turf.
- cromwellian 8y agoClustering images by features seems to be pretty fundamental, and if it runs afoul of this law, then the law needs to be changed. I upload photos to Google Photos because I want them to be grouped and categorized so I can easily find them. That is, if I click on a picture of my daughter, or my wife, I want to see ALL pictures of I took of them grouped together. Looking at the text of the law itself, it seems to exclude photographs, here's the relevant section: " (740 ILCS 14/10) Sec. 10. Definitions. In this Act: "Biometric identifier" means a retina or iris scan, fingerprint, voiceprint, or scan of hand or face geometry. Biometric identifiers do not include writing samples, written signatures, photographs, human biological samples used for valid scientific testing or screening, demographic data, tattoo descriptions, or physical descriptions such as height, weight, hair color, or eye color." I'm not really sure what they mean by "face geometry" whereas at the same time, excluding photographs. Does this mean if my service measures the distance between the eyes, and the width of the mouth, and clusters photos by that, or by eye or hair color by using say, segmentation or histogram clustering, all of a sudden it's illegal? That would seem to be a fairly absurd and broad definition of biometric security information. In theory, I suppose, the computation of the features, could be done on the client, and then have the features cloud-synced and replicated to all clients, but this would make for a shitty search experience, especially if the machine learning or feature extraction technique improvements overtime, and all of a sudden, you've got to download 20,000 photos and recompute everything on your phone.
- smadge 8y agoThere’s a difference between offering facial recognition as a feature to users of the software and collecting biometric data as a additional revenue source. In one case the user owns their biometric data and is granting the company access to it for the limited use of tagging photos. In the other case the company owns the biometric data and is using it for god knows what.
- cromwellian 8y agoWhere's the evidence Facebook is using it for a revenue source?
- michaelbuckbee 8y agoThis is being done under the Illinois Biometric Privacy Act (2008), but Illinois and a number of other states also have some similar (and pretty forward thinking) rules in place regarding data breaches of biometric data [1] If facial recognition becomes legally recognized as a "biometric marker" (no reason it shouldn't) - I think we'll see all sorts of other suits come out of this. 1 - https://blog.varonis.com/us-state-data-breach-definitions/ https://blog.varonis.com/us-state-data-breach-definitions/
- frockington 8y agoIf facial recognition was considered a bio metric, would I Phone users have to click through a screen that says "I will not use this in Illinois". I don't see how this would accomplish much more than coffee causing cancer in the state of California
- michaelbuckbee 8y agoWhat it changes are the results of a breach / how the data is to be considered. It's the difference between "oh, we had a data breach" and "oh crap why is the Attorney General of Illinois calling our office." As an aside: Google's Arts and Culture app (that matches your face to historic artwork) doesn't show up in Illinois - the feature within the app for face matching is geolocated out. http://abc7chicago.com/technology/why-googles-face-match-feature-doesnt-work-in-illinois/2959613/ http://abc7chicago.com/technology/why-googles-face-match-fea...
- Retric 8y agoThe iPhone does not create the same issues with the law from what I understand so, no.
- ipsum2 8y agoI'm not worried about Facebook or Google, because they spend millions on lawyers, but this seems potentially terrifying for startups. Any U.S. state can make a law making some part of their service illegal, and someone can sue the startup even if their company wasn't operating in that state. A startup would need to know and obey all laws in all states, and have enough money to fight legal cases. I wonder if the golden age of startups is over. It would be impossible to navigate through these regulations if you just wanted to create a side project for fun.
- blackbrokkoli 8y agoWhile I see your point, as a EU citizen it baffles me how anyone is allowed to generate and store biometric data without consent and face no legal trouble - it's not like this is some nitpicking on a highly specific legal detail...
- ghaff 8y agoTo the degree a photo is biometric data--and it's hard to see how it wouldn't be by any reasonable definition--how can that be reasonably prohibited at this point in history?
- frockington 8y agoAs an American it baffles me that the EU has regulated themselves out of the growth that is occurring almost everywhere else. It's just a difference in cultural beliefs and preferences
- _o_ 8y agoWell actually this is the whole problem, US is obsessed with growth and I have seen great projects beeing shut down as there was no growth. They had steady flow of few millions of revenue but still were shut down. Development team and whole department could live for years but someone was looking at growth trough toilet paper tube. Same with Facebook, they could have a very decent product without beeing creepy but, again, "we need growth". I could argue that this will destroy the planet and its resources, it works like a cancer, consuming more and more resources untill the organism can no longer stand the pressure. My opinion is that US is using wrong metrics, the EU is still having the old school "... but do we live better" beside the "growth" (less than we had but it is still there). US lost that part and most of people live far worse than in EU (I have tasted your vegetables... not the one that are meant for the rich, the every-grocery-store ones. Yep, someone had growth, but you are eating tastless food).
- parvenu74 8y agoWhile I'm a big proponent of States' Rights and a strict reading of the 10th Amendment, in the case of Facebook which, by it's nature is not only national but international, I have a hard time understanding how a State law can have jurisdiction over Facebook in this case. It seems to me that Federal Law should have original jurisdiction by virtue of the Interstate Commerce clause in this case UNLESS it can be shown that residents of Illinois were targeted or all of the servers and logic for doing facial recognition, analysis, and storage of biometrics were in the State of Illinois. That said, I am not a constitutional lawyers...
- ceejayoz 8y agoThey've got jurisdiction over Facebook's relationship with Illinois residents. Same reasons Amazon has to collect sales tax in states they're not necessarily headquartered in. Facebook also has Chicago offices. http://www.chicagotribune.com/business/ori/ct-facebook-expanding-ryan-ori-20171009-story.html http://www.chicagotribune.com/business/ori/ct-facebook-expan...
- ghaff 8y ago>Same reasons Amazon has to collect sales tax in states they're not necessarily headquartered in. The current law is that they need to have some sort of physical nexus in a state such as an office or a distribution center. Which Amazon probably has in most states at this point and, in any case, they've agreed to collect sales tax in most if not all states. That said, the relevant Supreme Court decision (Quill) [ADDED: that doesn't require collection absent a physical nexus] is being revisited because of another case this term and the betting money seems to be on it being partially or completely overturned.
- frockington 8y agoSo could they just add a clause in the user agreements that states "You cannot use this if you live in Illinois" and be done with it?
- ceejayoz 8y ago
- sagebird 8y agoI wonder - to what extent does cooperating with gov’t on data collection act as insurance against being sued out of existence. IE - if you play nice and install a backdoor for nsa to query your data, will they influence trials? Obviously they would need to keep up appearances by allowing the trials to move naturally, but perhaps a well timed visit or phone call at the last minute could instruct a judge to go easy on damages — ostensibly for national security’s sake.
- wu-ikkyu 8y agoSomewhat related: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Nacchio https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Nacchio
- em-bell 8y agoWhat a total cluster f@. Facebook must have an army of lawyers to deal with both domestic and foreign lawsuits. This country's legal system is like a swiss cheese with holes everywhere. Dealing with states, federal governments and municipalities costs our businesses billions of dollars each year.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoNo, not following the law costs the businesses.
- binnesjohn 8y agoWhy you would not want facebook to scan all your photos ?