4 ms·
> Authentic relating uses exercises, or games, to teach the skills necessary to quickly create deep, meaningful human connection. You can not create deep meani
by megous 8y ago
> Authentic relating uses exercises, or games, to teach the skills necessary to quickly create deep, meaningful human connection.
You can not create deep meaningful human connection quickly. It's just a game with emotions. A game plenty of organizations and cult gurus abuse for money and power.
If a person feels safe he might talk about things he would not otherwise. Yes. But deep meaningful connection requires both people knowing each other for a long time, spending a lot of time together and living through a lot of different situations, both hard and easy, dead serious and playful.
- stared 8y agoHighly related (no pun intended): "How to make a friend fast" based on research https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14731181 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14731181 When it comes to me, I learnt about the positive aspect of vulnerability from Mark Manson's "Models". It's one of the two key points of this book, after "non-neediness".
- megous 8y agoWhat positive aspect was it? I have a tainted view of vulnerability as I saw it preached for years by someone who turned out to be a world class opportunist and manipulator. Some youtube personality I'll not mention the name of, because he seems to thrive on negative publicity these days. It's one of those human ideas that a zebra would not understand as Sapolsky would say. Try explaining to a zebra benefits of being vulnerable. :)
- rusk 8y agohe seems to thrive on negative publicity these days. Can only be that Canadian guy ... Try explaining to a zebra As pack animals, intra-zebra emotional intelligence is essential for maintaining the cohesion of the herd. Looking from the outside it's hard to see this as all we see is the daily struggle for survival.
- qgaultier 8y agoIn my case, it is easier to be open with people I hardly know. All my fiends and family do have strong opinions and outdated views of myself. Talking to a stranger who is willing to listen is easier and deeper.
- megous 8y agoThat's a good point. On the other hand strangers are easier to manipulate, because they don't really know each other. The connection is all just words and projection of their personal life experiences onto each other. (at first) If they're opposite sexes there's risk of infatuation. So it's easier to be open, it all may feel great, but has its own challenges.
- le-mark 8y agoI think this is an interesting line of thought. I'm almost 50, reasonably accomplished in my career, financially successful, respected by my peers, but whenever I'm around my older sisters, I'm right back in that annoying, barely tolerated little brother reality. I don't much care for it, which is why I don't have much of a relationship with them, haven't for years. Anyway I've thought this for years, is there a name for it, or some other deeper meaning? Familiarity breeds contempt, maybe?
- thrav 8y agoAre you saying you act that way, or they treat you that way? People, for many reasons, automate other people in their minds. They define them, and aren’t willing to adapt their definition. They want the world to remain as they think it is, so they continue to treat it, and you, like it was. Sounds like they’re clinging to a sense of superiority in an effort to delude themselves that you aren’t all that.
- rusk 8y agoI think there's some subtlety to the language here. Based on what I understand the author is talking about I specifically think the term "create" in particular might be inexact. "create" implies making something from scratch but I don't think that's what's intended. "establish" might be better since what is sought is to bring to life the deep and meaningful human connection that is already there. What I mean is, is that as humans we all share the human experience and we all have more in common than we differ. The purpose of this school of thought seems to be to help build on that and open our minds to that.
- megous 8y ago> as humans we all share the human experience and we all have more in common than we differ Reading the opening paragraph again, the author basically claims the training aims at improving curiosity and empathy and that these are necessary (not sufficient) to create a deep and meaningful connection, but leaves how that happens to the reader. I tried to find more information about AR and found AR international training website, where they (do not really) describe their approach. They seem to be inspired by Fritz Perls and his Gestalt therapy, but that's itself a complicated view of human psychology. It's not clear what parts of Gestalt psychology they accept. It's all just too vague. I wouldn't call it a school of thought. Gestalt certainly is though! They also seem to overpromise a bit, to say the least, in introductions to their trainings. It's ridiculous actually for a weekend workshop. https://www.authenticrelatingtraining.com/level-1 https://www.authenticrelatingtraining.com/level-1
- trevyn 8y ago>You can not create deep meaningful human connection quickly In your experience, perhaps. Other people have different experiences, and some of these experiences you might find surprising! :-)
- bryanlarsen 8y ago"You can not create deep meaningful human connection quickly" You're likely correct, but it takes more than time to make deep meaningful connections. It also requires skills like empathy, which can be taught.
- everdev 8y ago> You can not create deep meaningful human connection quickly. It depends on your definition of quickly. With authentic relating games, I've had some deep, impactful experiences with people I'd only known for a couple days. There is a theory that you have to slowly take emotional steps with people over a long period of time before you get to the "good stuff", but in my experience that isn't the only way. If the two people are open, vulnerable and conscious in their intentions you can take some pretty big leaps instead of all those small steps.
- theycallhimtom 8y agoI think you and the article disagree about what "deep, meaningful human connection" means. I don't want to quibble about definitions so I'll just share my experience with circling (one form of authentic relating). In circling you just talk about how you're feeling in the moment. So a newcomer might share that they're anxious. Someone might ask them how that feels physically in their body (butterflies in the stomach etc). Someone else might share their reaction (I'm feeling protective of the new person). So what do I get out of it? When people share their feelings I generally feel a lot of empathy for them. It's also interesting when people have different reactions to what's going on in the circle. They share those reactions much more openly than people normally would. I leave feeling like I understand the other people at some deep level. But I don't know where they work, what their hobbies are, if they're in a relationship, etc. I trust that in circling I can be vulnerable with them and they won't hurt me. But I haven't built up trust with them in other areas (loaning money, etc.). Compare that to meeting a stranger (we both read the same blog) for a beer. I know his hobbies, his career aspirations, what he thinks about politics, etc. The feeling of connection is very different compared to someone I met circling.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]