3 ms·
> Things like this are the reason I stopped contributing to Wikipedia. People with no knowledge or expertise are able to change facts at will, maliciously or ot
by ajross 8y ago
> Things like this are the reason I stopped contributing to Wikipedia. People with no knowledge or expertise are able to change facts at will, maliciously or otherwise.
Have you stopped reading Wikipedia though? That seems like the real test. Who cares if you "contribute"? Is it your go-to source for random research or is it not? It is for me. If it's not for you, then what is?
"Things like this" are just evidence that encyclopedias are not reliable sources for items[1] involving controversy or interpretation. They never have been and they never will be. That's what analysis is for. The job of the encyclopedia, if it's done right, is just to document the existence of an argument and the lack of consensus (and in the modern world link to the relevant conflicting sources). And... it seems like Wikipedia did its job here?
[1] Like the apparrently apocryphal inspiration for The Human Stain -- honestly this seems like a genuine item of controversy here. Artists are not, in general, considered authoritative sources for their own works and for good reason. History is filled with great works where the author lied about them a little.
- reaperducer 8y ago> Have you stopped reading Wikipedia though? Almost entirely, yes. The only thing I use it for now is looking up wether certain celebrities are alive or dead. Who cares if you "contribute"? Wikipedia should care when anyone with above average knowledge of a certain field is turned away. The result is people filling those gaps with less-accurate information. My point is that if I've given up contributing to Wikipedia, then it's not a stretch to think that people even better/smarter than me have, as well. Wikipedia's arrogance and other flaws are making it a repository of mediocre information, not the best available information. Which brings us back to the bus stop analogy. Artists are not, in general, considered authoritative sources for their own works and for good reason You should tell that to whomever it is that organizes the hundreds of thousands of guest lectures from artists that are held around the world each year.
- ajross 8y ago> Almost entirely, yes. The only thing I use it for now is looking up wether certain celebrities are alive or dead. But where do you look up where crabs sit relative to scorpions and spiders in arthopoda? Or when Kubernetes was released? Or for a quick refresher on who exactly Samson was in scripture? Seriously, those are just my wikipedia hits for the last few hours. I mean, yeah, I could surely find that info elsewhere. But I click on the wikipedia link because I know it's going to give me good information in a format I understand and can rely on. > You should tell that to whomever it is that organizes the hundreds of thousands of guest lectures from artists that are held around the world each year. How is that responsive? "Have something important to say" and "should be trusted above all other sources" are rather different criteria (and, to be clear: make up pretty much a precise microcosm of our current argument!). Listen to artists, their opinions are important. They still occasionally lie about their own junk and those controversies deserve documentation too.
- forapurpose 8y ago> I know it's [Wikipedia is] going to give me good information It's not good information, though. You don't know if it's good or bad, which rationally makes the info almost useless for anything serious. In fields I have expertise in, it's often wrong, politically biased, has serious omissions, or elevates trivia to importance. > where do you look up where crabs sit relative to scorpions and spiders in arthopoda? Or when Kubernetes was released? Or for a quick refresher on who exactly Samson was in scripture? Encyclopaedia Britannica is a great source IME (though maybe not for Kubernetes), written by experts. If you hit the paywall, then pay (good info isn't free and free info isn't good); or if you are desperate find the page in your favorite search engine and open it from there. There are many other authoritative sources in their fields. The one thing Wikipedia is good for is the footnotes, which will identify many of them for you.