5 ms·
By the time we leave public school we've heard the "freedom" spiel thousands of times. We hear it from the news, every time we turn it on. Some people listen to
by jessaustin 8y ago
By the time we leave public school we've heard the "freedom" spiel thousands of times. We hear it from the news, every time we turn it on. Some people listen to the news primarily so they can hear the repetition of the comfortable old litany. A relatively recent innovation is talking about foreigners who "hate us for our freedom", rather than e.g. for our bombs falling on their homes.
It takes a lot of work to ignore reality so thoroughly.
- mrnobody_67 8y ago"It takes a lot of work to ignore reality so thoroughly." America seems to have done a good job indoctrinating the belief though, starting at a very young age. Even press freedom, is arguably relatively poor: https://rsf.org/en/ranking https://rsf.org/en/ranking Objectively, US is 45th on the list, below Lithuania, Czech Republic, Trinidad, Jamaica and Namibia. Not even top 20% in terms of press freedom! But if you ask most people, they would say US is #1 (or at least top 10) in the world.
- allthenews 8y agoWhat are the criteria used to rank journalistic freedom?
- admiralpumpkin 8y agohttps://rsf.org/en/detailed-methodology https://rsf.org/en/detailed-methodology Two clicks.
- burfog 8y agoAny press freedom list that would place the UK above the US is broken. The UK just arrested a reporter, then ordered a ban on all news coverage of the incident. Sweden being up at #2 is laughable nonsense. Germany should also be much lower. I think we can dismiss this one, sorry.
- tomjakubowski 8y agoUS courts have arrested plenty of reporters for contempt, in recent years too.
- burfog 8y agoFor an implied prior restraint on speech? Not so much I think. The UK arrests reporters for reporting. This isn't just about libel (also much more problematic in the UK) or revealing sources. It's about plain old honest reporting of factual events that occur out in public. A reporter reports on people heading into a courthouse, and he gets sent to prison for 13 months. The court then orders that nobody can report on the reporter's arrest either. If not for non-UK web sites ignoring the order, it would be a secret arrest.
- Latteland 8y agoBut this was ordinary contempt of court for not reporting about an ongoing trial until it was complete. It's a long standing govt right in the UK. Was there anything unusual about this case?
- tropo 8y agoIf it isn't unusual, then that only supports the idea that freedom of press is lower in the UK.
- Latteland 8y agoI think freedom of the press is lower there in the uk. Plus they it's too easy to win a suit for libel there.
- DrScump 8y agoIt's a long standing govt right in the UK. Well, there's a differentiator right there. In the USA, government doesn't have rights; it only has enumerated powers.
- jessaustin 8y ago"The press" is so thoroughly compromised here that "press freedom" can be a bit of a distraction. I watched a "national" newscast yesterday with my dad; it was 100% local-type "news": fires, car accidents, human interest, etc. Meanwhile we're in multiple wars and are theoretically in negotiations to avoid multiple other wars. Meanwhile the big banks we bailed out are bigger than ever. Meanwhile we have more people in prison than any other nation on Earth, in the history of Earth. Etc. Did some judge or other official order NBC Nightly News to do such a thoroughly shitty job? Of course not, but that doesn't mean they're aren't incentives of some sort coming from the State. If I want to know what our military or TLAs are doing, I don't consult an American source. This isn't a conspiracy; it is simply the case that American media conglomerates have decided they make more money catering to the shallow. It's not a problem for thoughtful news consumers: there are lots of other places for news. Perhaps I am naive, but I don't think our courts are so far gone that they're going to let anyone shut out TI, AJ, RT, various independent journalists, etc. Even if the courts did go along with such an effort, it seems doomed to fail. That isn't to say that journalists have nothing to complain about. Telling the truth isn't the way to succeed in this field, at this time.