4 ms·
Javascript will be the Next Big Language
- dangoldin 19y agoHe makes a good argument but I'm curious as to what everyone else thinks - I just don't see JS as powerful enough.
- martythemaniak 19y agoWell, powerful enough in what sense? If you are talking about power in the pg sense (http://www.paulgraham.com/power.html http://www.paulgraham.com/power.html), then JS is indeed very powerful - properly written it can be very succinct and expressive and and has had many great features for a long time. With ES4 (due out later this year I think) the language should really come into its own. Where JS isn't powerful is things related to where and how it runs - performance in the browser is not great and the API is practically the HTML DOM and a few other objects. I think the author's strongest point is that when it comes out, ES4 will need some type of branding/marketing campaign - perhaps a new name, then getting all browser vendors to use the same name (ie, no more confusion around JavaScript 1.6, 1.7, JScript 5 etc). Perhaps even go further and asking all vendors empasize the commonality - Javascript can become ES4Web, ActionScript ES4Flash, Rhino ES4Java etc. My names suck but you get the point.
- SwellJoe 19y ago"With ES4 (due out later this year I think) the language should really come into its own." In general, I kinda feel like ES4 is a step in the wrong direction. It takes a very concise, but powerful, language, and makes it far more complex without really adding any additional functionality. But I agree with you about where and why JavaScript is weak. The browser is a pretty horrible environment from a language power standpoint (it's a sandbox that historically had zero access to the world except through the DOM, which is pretty awful). If JavaScript was commonly used on the desktop in standalone form, like Perl/Python/Ruby/Lua, it would hold up just fine to comparison. Prototypal inheritance is cool. It's got closures. Syntax is mostly very simple and clean (and the only real terrors are the Java-isms that a few idiots rudely shoved into the language). It has first class functions. I can't think of anything that I really feel is lacking in the language--it's occasionally more verbose than I'd like, due mainly to the DOM and the way the DOM is used, but the good libraries out there (jQuery, ExtJS, Dojo, etc.) are pretty much all the evidence I need that the language is really extensible and really powerful, and they make almost all of the uncomfortable verbosity disappear.
- irrelative 19y agoJavascript is a great language, and it will never replace ruby, python, java, or any other languages mentioned. Let's get right to the core of the problem: prototypical based inheritance is worse than class based inheritance. It's nothing like what all other languages are using, it's a pain to use and it's less powerful. That's the only language feature that is wildly inconsistent from other popular languages. Rhino's been around for long enough that if javascript was going to be the next big language, it should be used by lots of smart hackers as a scripting language. And yet, they keep turning to Ruby and Python and concurrent functional languages. Maybe with the next version of js (which is will support classes and some other nice features), javascript will become big. Until then, I'm not holding my breath.
- jamesbritt 19y ago"Let's get right to the core of the problem: prototypical based inheritance is worse than class based inheritance." Can you defend this?
- michaelneale 19y agoWhen I use it, it always feels like you are forcing OO on something that would rather stay functional. I would agree it seems artifical, but then maybe its just familiarity.
- wanorris 19y agoIn my experience, JavaScript has tremendously powerful capabilities both in terms of OO and in terms of FP, and if you can get comfortable with it, you can mix the idioms seamlessly. Using something like the Prototype library helps -- it adds power for metaprogramming as well as for more practical things like DOM and event manipulation. Once you figure out OO idioms you like using, the main limitations are random annoyances like the lack of a clean idiom for linked lists and the fact that the JS spec doesn't require tail call optimization, so some functional idioms are going to be dog-slow.
- 19y ago
- jrockway 19y agoWho cares what the "next big language" is? Learn a language you and your coworkers like, use it, get good at it, improve it, etc. That's much more productive than switching languages every week because some blog told you to.