3 ms·
Euclideon are scammers not because they have nothing, but because they don't have what they claim they have. They claim to have revolutionary technology; they h
by jerf 8y ago
Euclideon are scammers not because they have nothing, but because they don't have what they claim they have. They claim to have revolutionary technology; they have something so well-understood that even I, merely an interested layman in the field of graphics, understand what they have just fine, very nearly well enough to just sit down and implement the core data structure right now, with no sign I've ever seen that they have anything beyond that. They claim to be able to animate in realtime, despite the fact that one of the tradeoffs of the tech is that becomes impossible in the sense we mean it. (You can animate much like a cel-based cartoon, but it can't be very interactive except on very restrictive conditions, ones that virtually no modern graphics user could accept.) It's delta between the rather pedestrian tech they have and the wild claims they make that is the scam, not what they do have.
I've heard it claimed that the whole company is basically a Germany-specific tax dodge method. I have no independent verification of this, but it fits the facts I have about their behavior.
- dkersten 8y ago> not because they have nothing, but because they don't have what they claim they have Absolutely. > animation Yep, from what I’ve seen of their holoverse ganes, that’s exactly what they’re doing and the results are, predictably, not particularly impressive. When compared to state of the art notion captured animation we have in modern games, it’s really not very good at all. > data structure It may be just their hype as opposed to actual facts, but they certainly make it sound a bit more sophisticated than a “traditional” spatial-index tree data structure in the sense that they claim they can stream just the voxels that are on screen at any given moment from a huge on disk dataset. But we both know they’ve been known to exaggerate, so you could very well be correct. > It's delta between the rather pedestrian tech they have and the wild claims they make that is the scam, not what they do have. That’s a very good point and I certainly agree.
- jerf 8y ago"It may be just their hype as opposed to actual facts, but they certainly make it sound a bit more sophisticated than a “traditional” spatial-index tree data structure in the sense that they claim they can stream just the voxels that are on screen at any given moment from a huge on disk dataset." To be honest, while I don't have that much difficulty imagining that they can stream voxels off a disk (since it's a straightforward application of the oct-tree structure; you get a good 50% of the way there just by writing a naive octtree larger than memory and letting the OS swap algorithm do its thing, with some slight preloading), none of the demos they've ever showed should require anything to be streamed off the disk. Everything I've seen would firmly fit in memory of very modest desktop systems of the time of the demo. It's possible you can zoom in farther than they demonstrate, but, I mean, it's a demo. I'm allowed to expect they're showing off the best. This is another one of the reasons people like me call them scammers; the first few graphics demos they put out weren't even that impressive. They were ugly and lacking in detail. They weren't even the kind of ugly you get when you have an impressive graphics tech and the person showing it off has no visual design chops, they were just plain ugly. Had the demos gone around the internet, but stripped of the hype they were accompanied with, nobody would have given them a second look. Any contemporary nVidia demo put out to demonstrate their graphics card look wildly better. The demos where they scan real scenes and display them work much better. The weirdest thing of all to me is that they don't lean into that and just make that their business, but no, they won't shut up about how awesomesauce their stuff will be for games, even when they have a perfectly sensible application developed. Bizarre stuff.