4 ms·
I don't understand how E=mc^2 can not be in the data. If it's a universal law, isn't it in more (all) data than any pattern that isn't universal?
by perl4ever 8y ago
I don't understand how E=mc^2 can not be in the data. If it's a universal law, isn't it in more (all) data than any pattern that isn't universal?
- qop 8y agoData has to be obtainable and is often dimensional. How would you have measured the speed of light in the forties? Even having lots of test cases, you wouldn't be able to deduce something like that with test cases alone.
- petermcneeley 8y agoSpeed of light has been experimentally determined long before the 40s. The discovery of the speed of light being constant lead to the special relativity (aka before GR which is the E=mcc). http://www.speed-light.info/measure/speed_of_light_history.htm http://www.speed-light.info/measure/speed_of_light_history.h...
- tlb 8y agoThe speed of light is easy to measure. What's hard is measuring the change in mass when something gains or loses energy. A large nuclear reactor running for a year only loses a few grams of mass-energy -- you can't measure it accurately enough or be sure that the mass didn't go somewhere else like into the cooling water.
- AstralStorm 8y agoTechnically with billions of events you can. This is how LHC and other particle accelerator data is analysed. The interesting part is detecting systematic errors. (Human equivalent is "are my senses lying right now".)
- maxander 8y agoThe article is making a simpler point than that. If I show you the table: A B C 1 4 3 20 45 15 8 15 7 And so on for some arbitrary number of rows, you can look at the table all you want but you will not perceive "A+C=B". It's just not written there. To get A+C=B you have to generate something else in addition to the table, namely a hypothesis- but this is a creative act, not an empirical one.
- tlb 8y agoIf you connect A and B as the input to a linear neural net, and train against C, it'll very quickly arrive at weights of [-1, +1] and be able to correctly predict C given A and B. Whether or not it represents it in notation humans are familiar with, it has learned it for the practical purpose of being able to compute the function.
- goatlover 8y agoBut how would a neural network know to connect data for mass with data for the measured speed of light? Why would a neural network be looking for an equation for energy conversion in the first place? If you just provide tons of raw data from instruments, what does that mean? What do yo do with it? Sure, a human can clean the data and put it into a format that gives meaningful results. But if we're just talking about an AI learning from raw data with no supervision, where does it even start?
- mannykannot 8y agoAs someone who finds this interesting but does not know enough to take a position, I think a bigger question would be how does it come up with the abstract concept of energy? I am aware that Alpha Go Zero came up with various strategic abstractions of the game that are recognized by competent players, and some novel ones, but I do not know where this program and its self-play training stands in the dichotomy of this debate.
- goatlover 8y ago