3 ms·
> When candidates position themselves too far left or right, they can lose the vote of centrists. So there’s a natural pull toward the middle of the political s
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> When candidates position themselves too far left or right, they can lose the vote of centrists. So there’s a natural pull toward the middle of the political spectrum.
This obviously doesn't work for first past the post. The two candidates with the most similar platforms will split the vote and lose to a third candidate with a different platform. The only way to prevent this is for the two candidates to each be far enough from the center that a more extreme third candidate would split more of the vote with one of the existing candidates than they would each have to split with each other, ensuring that the third candidate would not win and thereby deterring them from entering the race.
- repsilat 8y agoThis doesn't work. If a third candidate comes along and places themself anywhere along the beach that the two candidates are in the middle of, they'll lose to the candidate opposite. (I think the single-dimensional political axis is also just a simplification, and the theorem works in higher dimensions.) For a distribution of voters without statistic lumpiness or cross-correlation, I think the only way for a third candidate to win is to identify some neglected political axis. (Maybe the theorem holds if the voter population is convex?) I think the point you are trying to make is that voters don't just always choose the politician exactly closest to them -- they pick one with some likelihood based on its relative closeness. In that case the two identical centrist candidates will split the vote. Other circumstances the theorem has difficulty with are primary votes. If only left-leaning voters vote in left-party primaries, "centrist for lefty-party" candidates will win lefty-party primaries -- not "centrist for the electorate" candidates. The theorem only really holds for "strong parties" that can choose their candidates and their positions, not the weird US free-for-all where essentially every candidate is an independent.
- bo1024 8y agoI don't think that's a good analysis or refutation of what actually happens. What actually happens is the formation of political parties: All the candidates on the "left" would prefer that anyone on the "left" wins over someone on the right, so they merge into a single candidate in order to ensure they have the winner. The other "side" does the same. But then, given that there's only one candidate for each side, they get pulled toward the center as describe.
- JumpCrisscross 8y agoThe radicalisation in our system seems to result from the primary process, not the general election.
- ahartman00 8y agoThere are a few reasons: "Partisanship has been attributed to a number of causes, including the stratifying wealth distribution of Americans [2]; boundary redistricting [3]; activist activity at primary elections [4]; changes in Congressional procedural rules [5]; political realignment in the American South [6]; the shift from electing moderate members to electing partisan members [7] movement by existing members towards ideological poles [8]; and an increasing political, pervasive media [9]." This paper also attempted to quantify the polarization: "We define a network of over 5 million pairs of representatives, and compare the mutual agreement rates on legislative decisions between two distinct types of pairs: those from the same party and those formed of members from different parties. We find that despite short-term fluctuations, partisanship or non-cooperation in the U.S. Congress has been increasing exponentially for over 60 years with no sign of abating or reversing. Yet, a group of representatives continue to cooperate across party lines despite growing partisanship." http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0123507 http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal....