2 ms·
I don't know. I do know that progress, though slow, was being made without violence. The Irish were given Home Rule by the British HoC in the 1910s. Surely this
by anigbrowl 8y ago
I don't know. I do know that progress, though slow, was being made without violence. The Irish were given Home Rule by the British HoC in the 1910s. Surely this kind of progress would have continued. In contrast, violence was avoided at other times (the UVF arming to reject Home Rule).
It was not being made without violence. The British didn't give Irish Home Rule out of the goodness of their hearts - what an absurdly paternalistic argument, and one which ignores all the violence involved in upholding a particular political order.
As a parallel in this thread, people are wringing their hands about the violent potential of BLM but none of those people seem put out by the extensive use of violence by police on a daily basis, because that seems like such a part of social infrastructure that many have become blind to it..
- aaron-lebo 8y agoThere was violence at times, but Home Rule was granted before the revolution. I'm against violence across the board, for the record. The problem with violence against the police is it doesn't improve your position, it only confirms negative biases people have of the movement. It's counter-productive.
- anigbrowl 8y agoYes, and that ongoing violence was a major factor. You can be against violence across the board, but so what? That's an easy posture to take if your interests aren't directly threatened. On the other hand, telling people they can't use violence to defend themselves against an asymmetrically powerful oppressor implicitly cedes victory to whatever state actor is prepared to employ it. This tends to work out badly for the subjugated population. Violence is undesirable but you're arguing against people engaging in any kind of self-defense.
- musage 8y agoHe does make an arguable point in good faith though, and it's sad to see that greyed out. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_oJ9w0x_dzo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_oJ9w0x_dzo
- icebraining 8y agopeople are wringing their hands about the violent potential of BLM but none of those people seem put out by the extensive use of violence by police on a daily basis, because that seems like such a part of social infrastructure that many have become blind to it. "The headlong stream is termed violent But the river bed hemming it in is Termed violent by no one." -- Brecht