This is a great example. But I still have a bone to pick with the edited user story. It's not really a user story and crosses the line into implementation. I'd

This is a great example. But I still have a bone to pick with the edited user story. It's not really a user story and crosses the line into implementation. I'd propose a further revision: "As a user, I'd like the home page to reflect a consistent set of branding guidelines so it reinforces the company's identity for me." Logo display isn't covered by the branding guidelines? The company doesn't even have a branding guide? Now you've uncovered a deeper problem. Fix that and hopefully you'll avoid a lot of aimless subjective debates over cosmetic issues in the future.