3 ms·

Why do you (and others) lump GDPR with this law? There is nothing common to them. Other than people who actually profit of personal data, I have not met one pe

Why do you (and others) lump GDPR with this law? There is nothing common to them. Other than people who actually profit of personal data, I have not met one person who isn't in favor of the GDPR. This law is different.

lucio 8y ago
>Other than people who actually profit of personal data, I have not met one person who isn't in favor of the GDPR yeah! Also, only people who have something to hide are too attached to privacy /s
- beagle3 8y ago
  Every law is a balancing act. I note your /s, but still think its worthy of a response because many people accept this without sarcasm. GDPR prefers, in the grand scheme of things, the privacy and anonymity of 400M European to the bottom line of 50-100 companies, most of which aren't based in Europe. Lack of privacy hurts & benefits ... who, exactly? Mostly the same (except it's more like 1000-5000 companies, but still).
Ygg2 8y ago
There's one thing in common. Money required to obey them. And while GDPR can be somewhat avoided, how in the everloving name of Christ, can you avoid linking without horribly distorting the basic principles of the Web?
- beagle3 8y ago
  GDPR requires money to comply if you weren’t already compliant, yes - and at the extreme, it might even kill your business completely if your business isn’t gdpr compatible. But that’s a transient effect. It is similar to an ordinance saying “starting tomorrow, you may not dump your sewage in the sea”. It might cost you to get proper disposal services, and if your business was about disposing to the sea, you’ll probably have to close shop. But new houses wont dispose to the sea in the first place. And it will be better for everyone.
  - Ygg2 8y ago
    GDPR sure. But link tax and upload monitor? How do you avoid that? Never link to anything and never allow any uploads? What about comments, they could contain important excerpt from some book owned by EU publishers.

lucio 8y ago

>Other than people who actually profit of personal data, I have not met one person who isn't in favor of the GDPR yeah! Also, only people who have something to hide are too attached to privacy /s

beagle3 8y ago
Every law is a balancing act. I note your /s, but still think its worthy of a response because many people accept this without sarcasm. GDPR prefers, in the grand scheme of things, the privacy and anonymity of 400M European to the bottom line of 50-100 companies, most of which aren't based in Europe. Lack of privacy hurts & benefits ... who, exactly? Mostly the same (except it's more like 1000-5000 companies, but still).

Ygg2 8y ago

There's one thing in common. Money required to obey them. And while GDPR can be somewhat avoided, how in the everloving name of Christ, can you avoid linking without horribly distorting the basic principles of the Web?

beagle3 8y ago
GDPR requires money to comply if you weren’t already compliant, yes - and at the extreme, it might even kill your business completely if your business isn’t gdpr compatible. But that’s a transient effect. It is similar to an ordinance saying “starting tomorrow, you may not dump your sewage in the sea”. It might cost you to get proper disposal services, and if your business was about disposing to the sea, you’ll probably have to close shop. But new houses wont dispose to the sea in the first place. And it will be better for everyone.
- Ygg2 8y ago
  GDPR sure. But link tax and upload monitor? How do you avoid that? Never link to anything and never allow any uploads? What about comments, they could contain important excerpt from some book owned by EU publishers.