3 ms·
> Yeah, definitely. Especially for infrastructure. The problem is that this is entirely useless. There are basically two classes of software company. The fir
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> Yeah, definitely. Especially for infrastructure.
The problem is that this is entirely useless.
There are basically two classes of software company.
The first is the likes of Google or Mozilla. They, as a rule, do the right thing. All humans make mistakes but the mistakes are understandable and there isn't really much we can expect to incentivize them to do that they aren't already doing.
The second is Fly By Night IoT Device Corporation. They make garbage, it has a million vulnerabilities, but they're judgment proof. If you sue them they just file for bankruptcy. Many of them don't even exist within your jurisdiction and the ones that do are likely to have gone out of business by the time you get around to filing a lawsuit. You might as well pass a law imposing liability on raccoons for spilling garbage.
There is a much better solution to all of this. Fund a government agency to search for vulnerabilities in popular products and report the vulnerabilities to the developers. Then remove products from the market that have had known unpatched vulnerabilities for more than a limited amount of time, and require updates to be offered to any product sold in the past X number of years.
Because it's a lot easier to get a company to spend $5000 in developer time to fix their garbage than to get them not to avoid a twelve billion dollar lawsuit by filing for bankruptcy -- which only leaves all their customers in the lurch with hardware that will then never be patched.
- staticassertion 8y agoCisco is a Fly By Night IOT Corporation? Linksys?
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Cisco is a Fly By Night IOT Corporation? Linksys? Cisco hasn't owned Linksys in years and Linksys itself is tiny. This kind of liability absolutely could bankrupt them. And they're one of the major players. There are companies making this kind of hardware with like twelve employees. The barrier to entry is so low that even individuals commonly make one-offs from scratch for personal use.
- staticassertion 8y ago> Cisco hasn't owned Linksys in years I didn't say they did... I was providing two examples. I wouldn't call linksys tiny, either. You're assuming a lot about the costs of this liability for a made up law with no defined penalty. Maybe if companies building software can't afford to keep it safe... they shouldn't be companies? Is that so controversial?
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> I didn't say they did... I was providing two examples. But Cisco (i.e. Talos) are the ones finding the vulnerabilities in routers made by other companies in this case. > Maybe if companies building software can't afford to keep it safe... they shouldn't be companies? Is that so controversial? They still would be companies though. That's the point. If they expect to be out of business by then regardless, or they're outside of your jurisdiction, or they know they're judgment proof, it doesn't change their behavior. It's like trying to address homelessness by allowing the victims of panhandling to sue the perpetrators. There is no blood to be had from that stone. All you do is make the problem worse, because every company you destroy is a company which is no longer around to patch their installed base of devices. Meanwhile they're immediately replaced in the market by another company which is no better. Regulation and liability only works against monopolies and other huge companies. When you actually have a competitive market like this, you need to use the carrot rather than the stick.
- learc83 8y ago>Regulation and liability only works against monopolies and other huge companies. That's not true at all. Many industries that are very competitive and are full of small companies are effectively regulated. >There is no blood to be had from that stone. There's a simple fix to this problem. You require companies to carry insurance to cover the problems you're talking about. We do it with general contractors, doctors, tree removal companies etc... The regulation says it's illegal to manufacturer, sale, or distribute non-licensed routers, and part of the requirement for licensing is insurance. I'm not saying that this is necessarily the best course of action in this instance, but there are definitely time tested solutions for the problem you're describing.