5 ms·
Websites can be "documents" or they can be "apps". It's great that we now have the option to build the latter, but far too many things that should be simple doc
by _bxg1 8y ago
Websites can be "documents" or they can be "apps". It's great that we now have the option to build the latter, but far too many things that should be simple documents (news sites, I'm looking at you) are trying to be apps, and it's virtually always a worse user experience, setting aside the cost in load time, memory, and battery usage.
I'm saying this as a JavaScript developer.
- TulliusCicero 8y agoThe market has spoken. No seriously, if it sucks so much, why haven't users responded by going somewhere else, thus incentivizing sites to behave well?
- digi_owl 8y ago> The market has spoken. That is one tread bare cop out. When the choice is to go without completely, few will do so (and those that do will often get marketing blitzed as "luddites").
- _euvw 8y agoOr: the market does not (always) work. This too is an option.
- TulliusCicero 8y agoAgreed, and my comment was partially as a response to the anti-regulation demo here on HN. But, it's still something worth probing into: if it really does make the user experience worse -- and I agree it does -- why haven't people punished those sites by going elsewhere? My best guess is that it's like bad customer service: it bugs people, but it's not really the differentiating factor when choosing a product/service provider.
- mmt 8y agoDon't be so sure people aren't going elsewhere. Besides craigslist, there's also the not-Internet option, which I think many of us on here forget, possibly largely because it's so seemingly difficult to measure (in our skewed experience). I've met many young people who still default to pen-and-paper for things like note-taking. It's tempting to dismiss them as luddites, but I can't exactly blame them, given how much I know about just how user-hostile modern computer software and hardware can be.
- DmenshunlAnlsis 8y agoPeople who say this, do you realize that if the market were left to its own devices cars would still be deathtraps without seatbelts? The market isn’t magic, and the market we actually have is far from free.
- white-flame 8y agoA properly working market requires informed decisions. Internet privacy invasions are not something that people are well-informed about at a practical level. So GDPR is actually helping to restore the market.
- TulliusCicero 8y agoSure, but people are saying that it makes the UX really obviously terrible too.
- white-flame 8y agoI agree, but the providers are financially incentivized to make the UX worse via all this stuff, which reduces the number of providers offering a non-terribled UX. In becoming ad revenue maximizers, taking for-granted assumptions on audience, this situation doesn't optimize for serving the audience well. And since their models are to provide content in bulk, it keeps users served "well enough" to keep coming back, as opposed to less-funded alternatives which might provide a better UX, but don't provide the bulk content that monied sites can. Fundamentally, people visit sites and endure bad UX if the content is there to draw them. The utility cost of bad UX often isn't the dominating factor.
- TulliusCicero 8y ago> the providers are financially incentivized to make the UX worse via all this stuff Yes, but again, that's only true because apparently the UX isn't actually bad enough to push away a significant chunk of their userbase. > Fundamentally, people visit sites and endure bad UX if the content is there to draw them. The utility cost of bad UX often isn't the dominating factor. Agreed. But you could also interpret this as, "people don't mind this type of UX that much".
- massysett 8y agoThey have. Growth is not through the WWW. Instead, it's through phone apps. The news experience through websites is so bad that I don't read news on the WWW anymore.
- acchow 8y agoThey do and they have. A ton of old media companies are going bankrupt. USA Today definitely would not have survived another 5 years with 25 second page loading times. Or at least, such an old website wouldn't have generated enough revenue to survive long term (and USA Today would put their content on something else like Apple News, Youtube, etc)
- mikec3010 8y agowhy do you assume it's a market in the first place?
- niutech 8y agoThis is what project AMP is all about: to make websites lightweight again, using radical but effective means. You can feel the difference in desktop Chrome using the AMP Browser Extension: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/amp-browser-extension/mccnchmofleakpdohkmljohfckgpdehb https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/amp-browser-extens...
- thirdsun 8y ago> This is what project AMP is all about: to make websites lightweight again, using radical but effective means. It's also completely unnecessary. Those radical means that lead to lightweight websites are plain HTML and CSS with as little JavaScript as necessary. I don't see the point of adding all that bloat, just to have it removed by a third party like Google.