5 ms·
Targeted ads are like a cancer on the web front-end. It started out unnoticeably with one mutant script infecting a page, and now we’re at the point where the m
by pavlov 8y ago
Targeted ads are like a cancer on the web front-end. It started out unnoticeably with one mutant script infecting a page, and now we’re at the point where the majority of client network traffic from accessing a news article goes to ad peddlers and trackers — the cancer has overtaken the host.
A chemotherapy that starves the cancer’s food supply by 25-40% overnight sounds like a success to me.
(Edit: USA Today decided to actively remove the cancer tumors and created an adless site for EU visitors. The results are amazing: load time shrunk from 45s to 3s, network requests from 500+ to only 34! Source: https://twitter.com/fr3ino/status/1000167643431784449?s=21 https://twitter.com/fr3ino/status/1000167643431784449?s=21 )
- raverbashing 8y agoNot to mention the ads keep following you after you buy the thing. And this is not only because of lack of information. Checks out a cellphone from Amazon, buys the cellphone, still get ads saying "you might like this cellphone"
- duncanawoods 8y ago> Not to mention the ads keep following you after you buy the thing. There may be sense to this madness. I believe rate of returns is increasing as online sales takes over. The only way to actually see and touch many electrical devices is to buy and return them e.g. there is no store in my major UK city that has premium non-mac laptops on display. It means you might buy and return 3 devices to find the one you want to keep. If the return rate is 30%+ then a completed purchase really is a strong indicator that might purchase the same thing.
- syllogism 8y agoScoff. 30%? There's no way a rate of returns is anything like that. Just think of the volume of post that would be going out of suburban post centres! The delivery network obviously doesn't look anything like that. I think it's much simpler. The chance that any person is say, buying a fridge at any point is very low. If you're 99% sure that person has already made their purchase, that means there's a 1% chance you're wrong, and they're still looking! That's a much better signal than any other signal you're going to get.
- jdietrich 8y ago>Just think of the volume of post that would be going out of suburban post centres! The delivery network obviously doesn't look anything like that. According to this article in the Toronto Star, online return rates are around 20%, rising to 30% in the holiday period. https://www.thestar.com/business/2017/01/15/online-shopping-drives-surge-in-holiday-returns-and-what-happens-next-may-surprise-you.html https://www.thestar.com/business/2017/01/15/online-shopping-...
- elorant 8y ago30% is not sustainable for any business. You have to take into consideration that once a product is returned then the merchant has to sell it as a used one with a significant discount. Selling 30% of your inventory at discount means you're doomed.
- jtbayly 8y agoAmazon Warehouses is the official Amazon seller of used (returned) goods. However they also sell returned items to others. There are multiple huge warehouses where I live filled with (mostly) returned products being auctioned off to the public by a middleman. The volume is astounding.
- clappski 8y agoThe only place I’ve seen powerful/prosumer non-Mac laptops that you can play with in store in the UK are big department stores - e.g. John Lewis. Actually, PC World had demo machines out to play with last time I was in there, but very few in comparison to the tech department of the department stores.
- repsilat 8y agoA simpler explanation might be "They don't know you bought the thing." Either because they're different retailers, or because the data are hard to put through from the checkout to the marketing department. Maybe it's hard to connect Google's idea of who a user is with the store's user accounts. Maybe the ad-buying algorithm is suuper simple, and getting a dev to "do it better" isn't worth the cost. If it's just "this person searched for car rentals two days ago, let's show them car rentals today," that seems simple enough to make money over "no targeting," with obvious and acceptable failure cases like "already booked a car" and "phone got stolen, should show ads for pawn shops instead."
- bko 8y ago> Targeted ads are like a cancer >> Not to mention the ads keep following you after you buy the thing If you don't want irrelevant ads for items you already purchased following you around, then you want better targeting. I think many people just don't like ads at all. If I had to live with ads, I'd prefer to have relevant ads, but that's just me.
- digi_owl 8y agoI don't mind ads as a concept. I do very much mind ads that stick a massive zombie in my face when i happen to be browsing a url listing that may hold something about games.
- coffeedrinker 8y agoI hear this argument a lot but I disagree. While some advertisements can alert you to a product that will be helpful, many have the psychological intent of producing dissatisfaction and are an attempt to compel you to purchase something you do not need and your life probably would be better off without. Advertising is deliberately about producing discontent and it makes people more unhappy and more dissatisfied with their lives. I would rather see ads that I can immediately dismiss than have ones that make me start desiring that which I don't really need.
- bko 8y agoSo you're just against advertising. That's fine but I don't think there is an alternative business model that doesn't rely on advertising to feed the current demand of entertainment. I hope I'm wrong and people like you who find advertising distasteful can have access to the wealths of society with some alternative form of funding
- headsoup 8y agoBut if I want relevant ads don't I want them relevant to things I'm searching for anyway? I.e. advertise things on sites (and sections) where I'm looking for that category anyway. There's no need for 'targeted' ads that follow me around if the ads are in the places I expect when looking for something. Content providers should be ensuring they display quality and relevant ads, not relying on 'other' services to come find the consumer.
- freeflight 8y agoNPR even went as far as offering a text-only version of their site: https://text.npr.org/ https://text.npr.org/
- Tomte 8y agoThey have had that for some time now. It‘s unrelated to the GDPR. Also, lite.cnn.com
- ohtwenty 8y agoThat's been up for quite a while, actually, to help low-bandwidth and screen-reader users. What's new is that they're redirecting to it if you're EU (like myself) Edit: It's a pity there's no real archive in the text version, as far as I've been able to tell. No way to scroll down to yesterday's news or anything.
- pluma 8y agoI'm loving that the privacy policy linked on text.npr.org links EU users to a URL on the non-text version which is again just showing a prompt. The actual text-only version of the EU privacy policy is the one linked from that prompt, not the text site. I'm pretty sure that wouldn't satisfy the requirements for the privacy policy being easily accessible if this were an EU company.
- nkkollaw 8y agoAmazing. But that's why everyone uses ad blockers. It's just unusable otherwise
- smackay 8y agoYou still have the issue that the content must be of a form that a) attracts advertisers and b) attracts readers, so ad-blockers are only partially effective, you are still consuming content that is written with (consumption of) advertising in mind. I don't think there is any solution for that when visitors to the web site are the primary source of income for the individual or organisation behind it. All schemes, even Basic Income for journalists, are flawed in some way if you rely on single sources for what you would consider authoritative sources of information. A return to the Coffee Shop model, as advocated by The Economist, seems to be the most viable, given current human nature. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_coffeehouses_in_the_17th_and_18th_centuries https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_coffeehouses_in_the_17...
- Ileca 8y agoBut is everyone really using ad-blockers? I thought it was obvious, like you, I mean, why wouldn't people use ad-blockers and keep living inside a garbage typhoon? Then, I saw some "studies" [1] saying the total of users relying on ad-blockers is ridiculous, like not even 1/5. It's baffling but seems like most people are still struggling against pop-ups. [1] https://pagefair.com/downloads/2017/01/PageFair-2017-Adblock-Report.pdf https://pagefair.com/downloads/2017/01/PageFair-2017-Adblock... (If this study lies, what wouldn't surprised me to the slightest, it would be by inflating the numbers, considering they sell counter-measures.)
- usrusr 8y agoWow, that America Today stunt is really impressive, feels almost surreal. Great way to fill the time until things sort out and they eventually devise a way of compliant monetization.
- digi_owl 8y agoWhy i have been using noscript for ages, and why i feel quantum is barking up the wrong tree.
- C14L 8y ago> "How fast the internet could be without all the junk!" Or, in other words: if journalists didn't have to eat.