3 ms·
Could someone please ELI5 how programmatic ads could be compliant with GDPR? I can vaguely imagine how Google could be compliant. But generally, there are just
by mirimir 8y ago
Could someone please ELI5 how programmatic ads could be compliant with GDPR? I can vaguely imagine how Google could be compliant. But generally, there are just so many players. How could PII transfers even be tracked?
- ec109685 8y agoYou can capture consent on your first party site (enumerating each of the networks and letting user opt out) and pass that to advertising networks: http://advertisingconsent.eu/ http://advertisingconsent.eu/
- danieldk 8y agoI think the more difficult part is that you also have to be able to retract consent. So a first-party site has to offer this possibility as well and pass that to the advertising networks, which will have to remove the relevant data. Of course, this is technically possible. But apparently everyone has been sleeping during the two-year grace period.
- mirimir 8y agoRight, tracking will be tedious. That's a lot of transactional data, I think.
- Tomte 8y agoI don't think that ought to be possible (i.e. it's probably legal today, but shouldn't): if I'm giving consent to be tracked by company A, that does not extend to company B. And blanket consent like "ok to be tracked by whoever" should be illegal. Drain the swamp!
- mirimir 8y agoAs I understand it, ad networks integrate PII from many sources. From first-party sites, yes. But also using third-party cookies. And, at the point where a user is asked for consent, how can the eventual path of PII sharing be predicted?
- ChuckMcM 8y agoIt is unlikely, these ad networks are going to have to do a pop up each time they added another ad buyer to their network to allow you to opt in. It really couldn't happen to scummier people in many ways. I expect there are exists some reasonable third party ad aggregation and distribution networks but given the low bar to entry and ease with which the advertiser can be defrauded out of a few thousand dollars, the number of scummy ones dominate by a large margin. Interesting times for ad tech, that is for sure.
- craigsmansion 8y ago> how programmatic ads could be compliant with GDPR? One way would be to: - store all user data client-side, stuff it in a cookie. - Guess this user data, associate particular articles with particular data, e.g. X % chance of being male/female, probably likes cars, probably likes the colour "yellow", even if some of this data has been given to you directly by the user. -"Clean room" ad selection. Have the ad selection algorithm run on the same server/network that serves the content and retrieve desired ads directly without exchanging any user data. Advertisers provide matrices of desirable matches of available ads to match against. Matches won't be as precise, available data will be very limited, and if a user clears the cookie, you'll have to start from scratch again. This way: - you know nothing about the user, except for what could be inferred from their reading behaviour on a single site. - even that limited data never reaches advertisers, so it can't be collated and aggregated in a pernicious way - users are in complete control of their own data. If they clear their cookie, there's nothing left on the publisher's side. -if you shield and rotate your ip logs, they're nothing more than addresses that requested some page at some time. None of the data is combined in an attempt to identify a user, other than possibly in a security context. So yes, it should be possible even if it needs a more careful approach and more deliberation with regards to user privacy, but that's a main point of the legislation.
- skrause 8y ago> - store all user data client-side, stuff it in a cookie. That's still a tracking cookie, not allowed under the GDPR without explicit consent.
- craigsmansion 8y ago"Tracking Cookies are a specific type of cookie that is distributed, shared, and read across two or more unrelated Web sites for the purpose of gathering information or potentially to present customized data to you." You still make a valid point though, but my guess is it's not going to be considered pervasive tracking, where a data subject loses hold of their information, and will be considered in-line with the spirit of the GDPR, since it addresses the excesses the law set out to regulate: the wide-spread leaking and sales of profiling data.