3 ms·
From http://online.sfsu.edu/repstein/GEessays/goldenricehoax.html http://online.sfsu.edu/repstein/GEessays/goldenricehoax.html "In order to meet the full needs
by hellowrld 8y ago
From http://online.sfsu.edu/repstein/GEessays/goldenricehoax.html http://online.sfsu.edu/repstein/GEessays/goldenricehoax.html
"In order to meet the full needs of 750 micrograms of vitamin A from [Golden] rice, an adult would have to consume 2 kg 272g of rice per day. This implies that one family member would consume the entire family ration of 10 kg from the PDS [?] in 4 days to meet vitamin A needs through "Golden rice".
This is a recipe for creating hunger and malnutrition, not solving it.
Besides creating vitamin A deficiency, vitamin A rice will also create deficiency in other micronutrients and nutrients. Raw milled rice has a low content of Fat (0.5g/100g). Since fat is necessary for vitamin A uptake, this will aggravate vitamin A deficiency. It also has only 6.8g/100g of protein, which means less carrier molecules. It has only 0.7g/100g of iron, which plays a vital role in the conversion of Betacarotene (precursor of vitamin A found in plant sources) to vitamin A. Superior Alternatives exist and are effective.
A far more efficient route to removing vitamin A efficiency is biodiversity conservation and propagation of naturally vitamin A rich plants in agriculture and diets."
-Vandana Shiva
- kazinator 8y agoNote that this 2.2 kg of rice by dry weight!!! Rice something like triples in weight when cooked, so we're talking almost 7 kg of cooked rice.
- maxerickson 8y agoA later golden rice has a bit more than 20x the beta carotene. So like 100 grams of rice by dry weight, a modest single serving (300 or 400 calories).
- Turing_Machine 8y agoWhat you have posted is a link to a second-hand opinion piece that was copied from an old Tripod site. Here's a peer-reviewed journal article that provides real data: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2682994/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2682994/ Note that they found that a) Vitamin A is readily absorbed from the golden rice and b) their estimate is that 50 grams of golden rice per day would be sufficient to provide the RDA for a child.
- makomk 8y agoThat piece was probably written about the original version of Golden Rice developed 18 years ago which was being pushed as the solution to Vitamin A deficiency despite having about one-thirtieth the beta-carotene content of the current variety. When you yourself wrote that "Golden rice has been around for 18 years now, but "activists" have prevented its widespread use. That's 12 million preventable deaths." elsewhere in the discussion, it exactly was this much less effective version of Golden Rice you were claiming that anti-GMO activists killed millions by blocking the use of, not the one used in the linked study. Also, the ease of absorption is annoyingly dependent on the rest of the person's diet (particularly having enough fat and iron in their diet, if I recall correctly). The meals used in that study may well be close to the best case scenario; people with vitamin A deficiency don't generally get that way by having access to well-balanced meals.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]