6 ms·
Even if you delete it from disk and remove from memory, you may be required to remove it from offline backups too like tapes and other media.
by mc32 8y ago
Even if you delete it from disk and remove from memory, you may be required to remove it from offline backups too like tapes and other media.
- 4ndrewl 8y agoNot true.
- mc32 8y agoHas that interpretation changed? I recall reading that in some circumstances it could. Or was that misinformation?
- Silhouette 8y agoNo-one actually knows. What constitutes erasure and how to deal with all the edge cases around backups, archives, unstructured data and so on is one of the big ambiguities under GDPR, and one of the areas most in need of (but mostly lacking) actionable guidance from official sources.
- pkaye 8y agoI'm surprised with the law being around for 2 years nobody has received the official guidance needed.
- Silhouette 8y agoThe law might have been around for 2 years, but in practice many smaller organisations didn't find out about it until a few months ago. Much of the official guidance is more recent even than that. And much of that guidance doesn't really help anyway, because it is often almost as vague and/or incomplete as the original regulations themselves. Questions about numerous everyday issues that will affect literally millions of businesses across the EU are still lacking useful answers.
- dan-0 8y ago> Not true. ... unless you plan to use the backups. Then you have to have another service that tracks entities to delete when a backup it's restored... and back that up separately.
- drtillberg 8y agoIf you back up a list of things to delete is that GDPR compliant? Ponder.
- dan-0 8y ago> If you back up a list of things to delete is that GDPR compliant? Ponder. There's little to ponder, that's why I mentioned "entities" rather than "user data." Use unique keys to reference the data rather than sensitive identifiers. The nontrivial part is storing your backup of entities to be deleted in a way that doesn't get destroyed at the same time as the event that forces you to revert to a backup. This now requires a separate storage, backup, and retrieval mechanism to maintain compliance.
- erichocean 8y ago> Use unique keys to reference the data rather than sensitive identifiers. This is terrible advice. All identifiers are PII and covered by the GDPR, not just the "sensitive" ones.
- jdietrich 8y agoThe GDPR does not use the term "personally identifying information" anywhere in the text. Using that term suggests that you either haven't read the text or haven't understood it. "Personal data" (the term actually used in GDPR) means any information relating to an identified or identifiable natural person. The GDPR specifically states that the regulations do not apply to anonymous data. A list of unique keys marked "never restore this data from backups" is not personal data. The data associated with those identifiers is not personal data if it cannot be associated with an identifiable natural person. https://gdpr-info.eu/art-4-gdpr/ https://gdpr-info.eu/art-4-gdpr/ https://gdpr-info.eu/recitals/no-26/ https://gdpr-info.eu/recitals/no-26/ Quantum has produced a very useful white paper on GDPR in relation to backup and archive systems. https://landing.quantum.com/GDPR_WP_0118_RP.html https://landing.quantum.com/GDPR_WP_0118_RP.html
- daveFNbuck 8y agoYou don't necessarily have to delete stuff from cold storage right away. You just need to have a process to remove deleted PII when you retrieve/rewrite your backups.
- contravariant 8y agoThis might be a bit of a weird question, but how do you remember which information needs to be deleted when you're at the point where you need to use backups?
- johnbellone 8y agoYou would keep a list of unique identifiers (opaque) that were deleted and filter data out prior to rewriting/restoring it. It’s cumbersome but not impossible.
- ww520 8y agoSo basically more work.
- lovich 8y agoNo shit, you could save a ton of work by just ignoring a ton of things society and the government have decided are necessary for a business to operate inside of that society?. Why not throw your trash on a neighbor's lawn? Why not enslave your workers so you don't have to deal with turnover and hiring replacements? Why dont you stop paying taxes so you don't have to do work to get the same amount of income as you would without taxes? All of those things would be less work, right?
- axlprose 8y ago>Why not throw your trash on a neighbor's lawn? Why not enslave your workers so you don't have to deal with turnover and hiring replacements? Why dont you stop paying taxes so you don't have to do work to get the same amount of income as you would without taxes? None of those examples make sense from a classical economics perspective, nor would they be considered sustainable from a game theoretic perspective either. Meanwhile, not complying with the GDPR doesn't seem to have any obviously severe economic/game-theoretic consequences if you're not based in the EU, or don't already have a large profitable presence there. So it's a bit disingenuous to just lump it in with all those other behaviors.
- alexbeloi 8y agoPresumably you are also required to delete it from any training data for an ML model, does that make any models trained on previous set of data illegal to use?
- henrikeh 8y agoAre the weights in the NN “relating to an identifiable person who can be directly or indirectly identified in particular by reference to an identifier”? If not, then it isn’t personal information.
- ww520 8y agoAnd remove it from the off site backup, like AWS, which helpfully makes copies of the backup data, and you have to remove it from all of them.