4 ms·
>And since I take the position not as an a priori principle but based on my empirical experiences of what kind of theorising has been effective or ineffective,
by foldr 8y ago
>And since I take the position not as an a priori principle but based on my empirical experiences of what kind of theorising has been effective or ineffective, it isn't self-defeating at all.
That is the same defense Ayer used. It doesn't amount to much, since if you don't mean to say that non-empirical statements are meaningless in some kind of objective sense, then saying that they're meaningless is just a highfalutin way of saying that you personally disapprove of them.
- lmm 8y agoNon-empirical statements are meaningless in the same sense that fairies don't exist. It's not a priori impossible that a non-empirical but constructive/valuable/useful statement could exist - a black swan - just as it's not impossible that a fairy could exist - but it seems very unlikely and I'd put a very low weight on someone's claim to have seen one, given how often such claims have turned out to be false. When I dismiss something as non-empirical, that's the same kind of dismissal as saying something's a conspiracy theory - formally I'm not claiming that it's outright impossible, just unlikely (though in everyday language I might say "impossible", just as we do for conspiracy theories or fairies).
- foldr 8y agoThe strained analogy with fairies is obscuring your point. You seem to be using "meaningless" in a very unusual sense. Whether or not non-empirical statements can be constructive or valuable is a separate question. Mathematics is non-empirical and strikes me as pretty constructive and valuable. But those terms are, ironically, so vague as to be almost meaningless in any case.
- jabgrabdthrow 8y agoMaybe conspiracy theory is a bad example because they’re true often enough to not be like fairies or black swans at all. Domestic mass surveillance is a debunked conspiracy theory, remember
- marcv81 8y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_swan https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_swan
- jabgrabdthrow 8y agoDo you think you contributed to the conversation or that anyone might have been missing part of the picture but you pointing out that black swans are a literal thing that are not uncommon unlike fairies that don’t exist or “black swans” (like “bull runs”) that are by definition extremely rare? I once said “there’s no such thing as a bull run” in some context with a group of friends. Do you think you would have chimed in to say that there’s a big one in Madrid every year?
- benl 8y ago> "Non-empirical statements are meaningless" This is a non-empirical statement, given that you probably don't believe that you can demonstrate the truth of it empirically. Putting it another way, perhaps you might agree with the following statement? "All legitimate knowledge is gained empirically." But how do you know this? Did you reach this conclusion empirically? So there must be some things that you know through non-empirical means.
- lmm 8y ago> But how do you know this? Did you reach this conclusion empirically? Yes I did, that was my point. I haven't solved and am not claiming to have solved the problem of induction - the generalisation from "a bunch of empirical knowledge turns out to be valuable/effective/legitimate and all the supposed non-empirical knowledge I've seen turns out not to be valuable/effective/legitimate" to "all valuable/effective/legitimate knowledge is empirical" rests on potentially shaky ground. But that's a problem that already exists when making ordinary, object-level generalisations about the universe; it doesn't render the conclusion any weaker than ordinary scientific conclusions.
- foldr 8y agoThat's only an empirical generalization if you can cache out "valuable/effective/legitimate" in genuinely empirical terms (at minimum, in terms of observer-independent observations free from value judgments).
- lmm 8y ago> That's only an empirical generalization if you can cache out "valuable/effective/legitimate" in genuinely empirical terms (at minimum, in terms of observer-independent observations free from value judgments). I can cash it out empirically as "generates accurate empirical predictions and suggests fruitful avenues for future investigation" (fruitful in the sense of ultimately leading to more detailed and accurate empirical predictions). That the measure of a theory is the accuracy of its predictions is of course a subjective human position (there are an infinity of possible measures on which to evaluate theories, and a priori no reason to prefer one over another), but again that's (a cautious Neurath's boat extension of) the common-sense way that we all evaluate theories in practice in everyday settings.