49 ms·
I wish Apple would make a sort of Raspberry Pi like board with an A series chip, ethernet, HDMI, GPIO, SD Card, etc... for $50-$100 that runs Linux. I would al
by jandrese 8y ago
I wish Apple would make a sort of Raspberry Pi like board with an A series chip, ethernet, HDMI, GPIO, SD Card, etc... for $50-$100 that runs Linux.
I would also like a flying unicorn.
Seriously, a high power SBC at a reasonable price point would be insanely useful for projects like portable MAME cabinets, video transcoders, scene displays, etc... I love the Pi but it's so old tech, especially the video cores, that it's annoyingly limited for some applications. Worse, the competitors with faster cpus often have worse video acceleration support, making them worse for this than the underpowered Pi.
- ingenieroariel 8y agoHave you looked at raspberry pi clones built around FPGAs?
- bonestamp2 8y agoI didn't even know these existed! From a googling I can only find hats/daughter boards for existing raspberry pis. Is that what you mean or are there ones that are all in one?
- FPGAhacker 8y agoIt's not a pi clone, but google snickerdoodle board.
- ingenieroariel 8y agoI own a parallela with a Zynq1020 fpga and a form factor similar to a raspberry pi. Here is somehing that costs around a hundred dollars (a bit higher) called Zynqberry. https://shop.trenz-electronic.de/en/TE0726-03M-ZynqBerry-Zynq-7010-in-Raspberry-Pi-form-factor https://shop.trenz-electronic.de/en/TE0726-03M-ZynqBerry-Zyn...
- abakker 8y agohttp://papilio.cc/index.php?n=Papilio.Hardware http://papilio.cc/index.php?n=Papilio.Hardware
- H1Supreme 8y agoSurely there's got to be something like that available already. I'm mostly dealing with low powered M0/M4 boards, but the selection in this range is massive.
- jandrese 8y agoThere's an absolute ocean of old obsolete ARM cores clocked slowly. The difference in performance is so vast it would be hard to compare with an A11 chip, especially once you include graphics acceleration in the mix. Apple has been doubling down every year on the "we can make it go faster", and the rest of the ARM chip makers have responded with a "meh". It's so bad that people get really excited for a Samsung chip that is no slower than a two generation old A series chip.
- svantana 8y agoPerformance is highly dependent on task and graphics is extra tricky to compare, but looking at geekbench, it seems the Samsung S9 is about halfway between iPhone 7 and 8/X. So half a generation behind is more accurate.
- deaddodo 8y agoWell, the price is wrong, but nvidia's Jetson platform is very powerful compared to the *board SBCs: https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=march-2017-arm&num=2 https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=march-20...
- pizza234 8y agoJetson CPU performance is on par with chips like the RK3399 or the Exynos5422, which are 4/5+ times as fast as the RPi 3b (I owned RPi 2/3b series, and the Exynos). Note that the first benchmark in the mentioned article is an outlier.
- deaddodo 8y agoNo, it's not. Having worked with the Jetson platform extensively, the TK1 was equivalent to a 5422 (because they're both built on the vanilla A15 architecture). However, the TX1 and TX2 ("Denver" cores) are closer to (though, still slighty behind) the current SD 835: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l6y4atVl-mc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l6y4atVl-mc And when it comes to GPU compute, it's much more powerful than all the alternatives.
- stefan_ 8y agoApple chips famously have Imagination GPUs that have zero open-source support, a far ways off even from Nvidia. They are the absolute worst. That's before you consider that all the stuff Apple did to that poor ARM probably means you can't even boot Linux into a terminal on it today.
- mepian 8y ago>Apple chips famously have Imagination GPUs Not anymore, Apple switched to in-house GPUs recently.
- stefan_ 8y agoThat makes it worse? The Imagination crap is shipped on Android phones, too, so there are at least vendor kernel drops to work from.
- craftyguy 8y agoThe vendor kernels are worthless, tainted, piles of crap. Vendors rarely, if ever, maintain them once they are posted publicly. The GPU still requires proprietary blobs to be even remotely useful.
- stefan_ 8y agoOf course. But they contain non-zero amounts of information on the chip so you can do a proper implementation or, much less ambitious, update it for newer kernel versions.
- dmayle 8y agoThe rock64 and variants should do what you're looking for.
- jandrese 8y agoI said I wanted a working GPU.
- 0xdead_beef 8y agoReleasing a chip like that would be close to useless without also developing a user-friendly hobbyist API like the Raspberry PI and Arduino's already have. Releasing the chip plus a nice users manual of all of its registers and assembly instructions might pose a security threat for device jail-breaks that they probably aren't interested in either.
- nickpsecurity 8y agoSomeone recommended in an article an ODRIOD-C2 over a Raspberry Pi. They said you get quite a bit of performance spending just a little more ($40). Here's a comparison: https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=raspberry-pi3-odroid2&num=1 https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=raspberr... I might buy one depending on what feedback I get on it. Anyone here tried those out for Linux or BSD projects?
- solidr53 8y agoSo basically a PC with GPIO? NVIDIA Jetson is the closest you can get in terms of performance, but the price is closer to $500. DX2 specs: GPU: NVIDIA Pascal™, 256 CUDA cores (1302MHz) CPU: HMP Dual Denver 2/2 MB L2 + Quad ARM® A57/2 MB L2 (1.4Ghz/2Ghz) Video: 4K x 2K 60 Hz Encode (HEVC) and 4K x 2K 60 Hz Decode (12-Bit Support) Memory: 8 GB 128 bit LPDDR4 (59.7 GB/s) Display: 2x DSI, 2x DP 1.2 / HDMI 2.0 / eDP 1.4 CSI: Up to 6 Cameras (2 Lane) CSI2 D-PHY 1.2 (2.5 Gbps/Lane) PCIE: Gen 2 | 1x4 + 1x1 OR 2x1 + 1x2 Data Storage: 32 GB eMMC, SDIO, SATA Other: CAN, UART, SPI, I2C, I2S, GPIOs
- verall 8y ago*TX2 Also it has a student discount to only $300 which imo makes it much more compelling if you're eligible.
- bitL 8y agoStill, only 1.5Tflops (roughly 750Ti level), which makes it insufficient for bleeding-edge robotics, but 8GB is nice for inference. NVidia has some high-performing board for automotive, but that one is 500W for a change...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hedora 8y agoThere is video story at all (except a serial console), but the apu2 amd-based boards are nice, stable targets, and much, much faster than a rpi for networking applications: https://pcengines.ch/about.htm https://pcengines.ch/about.htm
- lsiunsuex 8y agoWorse is the array of smart devices that are forced to use Android type hardware / Android OS. Looking at the Peloton cycle I have specifically which clearly runs Android OS. Could be so much better if it was on faster hardware / could link up to Apple Watch for stats. Make a version of iOS that companies can build off of; maintain the OS patch cycles but let them put their own app / front end on it. Tons of smart devices exist now a days; TVs, refrigerators, bikes, etc... There's a market for an Apple based system for sure. But yes - I'll taking a flying unicorn also in the interim.
- iaml 8y agoI would love this. They could also push swift with it, so I'm surprised they haven't done this already.
- ajross 8y agoThat's an interestingly spun perspective. So you're asking for Apple to produce an open source ecosystem around their hardware and OS, while simultaneously refusing to use the products of the company that did? No devices are "forced" to use "Android type hardware / Android OS". They use it because it's free. That's... important. Right?
- hedora 8y agoAndroid isn’t “free” in the FOSS or Beer sense of the word. The important bits (hardware drivers and core applications) aren’t open source (AOSP doesn’t include the new default apps or standard libraries. Also, the important stuff is tied to google services that spy on you. I think it’s completely reasonable to reject that stack, and lament that no one offers a high quality, supported alternative software stack at a reasonable price.
- ksec 8y agoI hope and I wish the market and Android will force Apple to make this decision within the next 3 to 4 years. They are still not making Apple TV set. With WatchOS and the Apple S3 chip already includes 90%+ of the features needed. I bet the S3 cost less then $20, and Apple could have sold it at $50 along with WatchOS to specfic market that Apple do not intend to compete. Fridge, Fan, Lamp, bikes, TV set, radio, kitchen appliance or what so ever. Apple currently charges $1 for the controller of Lightning Cables regardless of volume. They could have just offer similar program.
- dfrey 8y agoApple is so in love with walled gardens. I can't imagine them ever making truly open hardware. Perhaps they are uniquely qualified to make something open because of the amount of effort they have put into making things that are closed.
- astrodust 8y agoIt's not that they love walled gardens, it's that they have different priorities than other companies. Users and usability are their primary concerns. Everything else is done to support that. They have open-source initiatives, they like to be open like that when it doesn't interfere with those mandates. It's just that usability is such a huge thing that it impacts every step of their process.
- Pamar 8y agoMaybe something targeting schools/education?
- pizza234 8y ago> Seriously, a high power SBC at a reasonable price point would be insanely useful for projects like portable MAME cabinets Right now one can buy an Exynos5422, which CPU wise (I've never tested the GPU) is 4/5+ times as fast as an RPi 3b, for the price point mentioned (<100$, board only). For me, this is effectively a "high power SBC at a reasonable price", however, at the same time, users interested in SBCs (or micro-PCs) seem to have a wildly different array of requirements (I've read virtually everything: (very) low price, GPU, kernel support, open source drivers, arch, ports, form factor, etc.etc.), so a desirable SBC seems like a pipe dream due to the fuzziness of the requirements. (For reference, the CPU performance ratio is calculated on single-core performance of a generic RPi 3b core vs. a fast Exynos5422 core, on OpenVPN maximal bandwidth).
- znpy 8y agoLink/source ? Btw imho the worst part about RPi is that it has poor ethernet performance. This improved a bit with RPi 3+, but still meh.
- astrodust 8y agoThey'll fix it in the RPi 4 and then you can complain they don't have 10Gbit support, so at least you have those two things to look forward to.
- pizza234 8y agoHere is a Phoronix test suite run: https://openbenchmarking.org/result/1805276-FO-1703199RI52 https://openbenchmarking.org/result/1805276-FO-1703199RI52 It's hard to asses a generic ratio, since the performance increase is wildly variable. I think it can be reasonably assessed a "base" 3x performance ratio against the RPi 3B (with an outlier of 8x).
- usrusr 8y ago> I wish Apple would make a sort of Raspberry Pi like board with an A series chip Likely outcome of the unlikely discovery of some lost ancient document that somehow makes The Woz indisputable CEO for life.
- wwweston 8y agoSeems to take about 4-5 years from release for the depreciation&upgrade curves to bring an iPhone under $100. At that point, the main thing keeping them from being what you're asking for is: 1) No one has been particularly dedicated to developing an open-source OS for these things, despite the fact that used phones are steadily becoming some of the most common devices in the world, to the point where we have to treat them like waste. 2) Apple's treatment of ports of any kind as a blemish. Solve these problems, and you have the board in a slick package. :) I'm less than half kidding. #2 is obviously solvable, as there are lightning dongles/docks for just about everything on your list. #1 gets harder over time with security measures but it has to be possible, it's a question of resources.
- Rexxar 8y agoLet's call this product "iPhone mini". With a good name for it, I'm sure we can convince Apple to do it.
- technofiend 8y agoI'm right there with you. There are some pilikes like Espresso Bin that are much more powerful, but they just don't have the community support that Pi does. http://espressobin.net/ http://espressobin.net/ Still at $49 it's cheap enough I'm going to see if it'll work as a wall-of-ceph appliance. Would love to have an SBC designed to be an OSD node but Western Digital never put theirs in the channel and there's not much else comparable AFAIK.
- tambourine_man 8y agoNot a flying unicorn, but still a winged equine: the Mac Nano. A tiny white puck with a single usb-c plug for power and data. Inside, an A12 running OS X. Education and “enthusiast” market. GPIO as a dongle, of course. They can release the A13 version in colors the next year :)
- oliv__ 8y agoTake my money
- fastball 8y agoI'm confused as to how you have a computer with only a single port... what do you imagine plugging the one port into?
- beokop 8y agoPrevious MacBook 12” user here. Either power, or peripherals. Just not at the same time.
- fastball 8y agoMacbooks have large batteries. Wouldn't make sense to have one in this if you're going for as small as possible form factor.
- jandrese 8y agoPower I'd guess, since he didn't specify a battery. The display would be wirelessly beamed directly into your brain.
- derefr 8y agoA USB-C Thunderbolt Display that delivers power over the cable and has a USB hub built into it. These exist, though they're expensive. Or, an eGPU enclosure, which also delivers power over the cable and has a USB hub built into it. (You just need to plug a monitor into it.) These exist, and are surprisingly cheap if you buy them bundled with a graphics card.
- mirekrusin 8y agoLike Apple TV?
- hawski 8y agoYour best bet would be a SBC with i.MX8M - the same SoC that will be in Librem 5. That's because it's one of the best supported SoCs by mainline Linux kernel. With Etnaviv drivers for GPU you can be pretty much covered. And I think it will get better. I'm hoping that someone will make a netbook with i.MX8M. Or maybe even Chromebook - it would be then easily repurposeable. I'm eyeing WandPi 8M [0], armstone mx8m [1] and Nitrogen8M [2]. [0] https://www.wandboard.org/products/ https://www.wandboard.org/products/ [1] https://www.fs-net.de/en/products/armstone/armstonemx8m-with-nxp-i-mx-8m-processor/ https://www.fs-net.de/en/products/armstone/armstonemx8m-with... [2] https://boundarydevices.com/product/nitrogen8m-imx8/ https://boundarydevices.com/product/nitrogen8m-imx8/
- rogerbinns 8y ago> Raspberry Pi like board with an A series chip, ethernet, HDMI, GPIO, SD Card, etc... for $50-$100 that runs Linux. The upboard fits that description perfectly - http://www.up-board.org/up/ http://www.up-board.org/up/ The CPU is an Intel Atom which turns out to perform very well. The internal storage is blazingly fast eMMC. It has an Intel GPU which means complete open source driver support. (I can't comment on the GPU performance as I use the serial console.) They also put a 40 pin connector on it that is hardware compatible with the raspberry pi - ie the same pins, voltages, and functions. You do need kernel patches for full support of the pins because the pins are specced at 3.3V while the Atom is 1.8V. There is level shifter hardware that fixes that, which the patches control. The patches are public from Emutex (in github) and there is also a PPA if you just want to play with Ubuntu and not worry about it. It uses an AMI UEFI BIOS. You can compile the kernel with efi stub support and the upboard can boot straight into your code.
- Nelson69 8y agoOdroid N1 is getting close.
- IloveHN84 8y agoI find it's a pity there's no Mac mini anymore, at least not a powerful one, with dedicated GPU, a kind of NUC Skull Canyon. I still run a 2008 Mini with Manjaro Linux..still good for Kodi